[Leaderboard] The Progenitor vs. Nobita Nobi (CLOSED)

[Progenitor]

Copied from myself.  Keep the train going

Voting:

• Votes must be with valid reasoning, going "Card A wins" won't do, follow the Leaderboard rules!
• Voting is based on the functions they have in the game, meaning that you should talk about the effect, stats etc.
• Satisfactory votes will receive a rep.
• Both I and the opponent have the right to decline your vote based on your comment or ask for further reasoning if either contestant feels that it's not adequate.
• Both contestants can disagree with the others acceptance of the vote if they feel that the answer was no adequate.

 

Rules and Rewards:

• All YCM and 1v1 Leaderboard rules apply.
• First to 3 votes OR whoever has most votes when the contest ends wins.
• Winner gets a rep from the opponent, other rewards are optional.
• Must fit in the rules of realistic cards on this site.

 

Entry Requirements and Theme:

• Create a U.A. Monster, Spell, or Trap.
• Must be written OR made in YCM and remember to make sure that it's not possible to see who made the card, i.e. remove your name from it.
• Send a PM to me with your card and remember to include text. Other information is optional.

 

Deadline:

• Entries are due 2 days after the challenger is accepted. Votes are due 3 days after it's open. November 13th, 8:00 AM EST

 

[spoiler Card A]

U.A. Blitz Backer

Level **** EARTH

1300 ATK/500 DEF

Warrior/Effect

You can only use each of the effects of "U.A. Blitz Backer" once per turn.  You can Special Summon this card (from your hand) by returning 1 "U.A." monster you control to the hand, except "U.A. Blitz Backer".  You can discard this card: Add 1 "U.A." Spell or Trap card from your Deck to your hand.  During the turn this card was Normal Summoned, you can Normal Summon 1 "U.A." monster in addition to your Normal Summon/Set.[/spoiler]

 

[spoiler Card B]

[spoiler Card B Lore]

During the turn this card was Normal Summoned,You can Normal Summon 1 "U.A." monster in addition to your Normal Summon/Set with 1 less Tribute.(You can only gain this effect Once per turn.) During either player's Battle Phase: You can discard this card, then target 1 face-up "U.A." monster you control; it gains 500 ATK and DEF until the end of Battle Phase.[/spoiler][/spoiler]

[Nobita Nobi]

i always wanted to try 1 on 1, so i'm in

[Progenitor]

Alrighty the Challenge is accepted.  PM me your Card (Written or otherwise) to me by November 12, 1:16 AM EST

[Progenitor]

Alrighty Cards are up and Voting can now begin.  Votes are due November 13th, 8:00 AM EST

[VampireofDarkness]

Card A:
Looks like the U.A. got themselves a utility box. In the hand, it serves double purpose of searching Stadium or Power Jersey or for being Special Summoned by bouncing one. Once it hits the field (Unless by its own effect), it's a Hunder. I dig it. I feel U.A. needed this. Even without the fact that you could also Tribute Summon Slugger, you got Midfielder, which makes the combos seem quite nice. I was seeing people play pure U.A. the other day, this makes it that much more practical. I actually like the idea of that.

Card B:
What? Another Hunder U.A.? I dig it, but I feel this one is a little overdoing it. Usually you got Monarchs Stormforth for Tributing, that's enough, but this makes the Mighty Slugger plays scary. In fact, if I thought about it hard enough, I probably could come up with an OTK involving this card. As for the hand trap effect, the boost is nice during your opponent's turn, I don't think anything except Killer and Construct would be a relevant problem in that situation, and both of those you wouldn't be able to get around with this. If you left the two Level 4s (Meaning this card and Midfielder), you'd probably just Xyz anyway, which leaves only the case of BLS vs Perfect Ace, which is way too situational. It's a decent concept, but just not all the way there

Overall, Card A gets my vote. I get what Card B wants to do, but it just either ends up being too overwhelming or too underwhelming.

[Progenitor]

Thanks for the vote.  That makes it 1-0 Card A

[Darj]

Both cards are Normal Summonable Level 4s that grant additional Normal Summons, so I will comment on the effects that make them different.

 

Card A:

Has the "tag out" effect of U.A.s, which adds a bit more of flavor and could be handy sometimes. Then it searches for Stadium, Jersey and whatever S/Ts they get in the future, but with the 2 first Spells the card is already good, since U.A.s need their Stadium to take off, and Jersey to actually beat stuff. The only issue is that you can loop 2 copies of this and Special Summon them endlessly, since their summoning condition is not actually an effect and thus is not bound by the card's first restriction, but most likely the card creator overlooked this and is meant to be an OPT Special Summon like the rest of the U.A.s.

 

Card B:

Personally, this card feels like an overkill. First, with Jersey and Stadium, ATK boosts is among the things that U.A.s need the least; not saying that a Honest-like 500 ATK boost is bad, but I think U.A.s would prefer a different kind of support. Then, Normal Summoning an additional U.A. without tributes feels like a slippery slope. The Level 5+ U.A.s have really good effects, and basically what keeps them on check is their high Levels, but once you take that out of the way, things may become problematic.

 

 

I vote for Card A because with its Spell/Trap searching effect it helps U.A.s to set up and get things started.

[Progenitor]

Thanks for the vote, and that brings the count to 2-0 in favor of Card A.

[Nobita Nobi]

thx for people who voted

 

bump, 1 more day to vote...

[Progenitor]

And with that the deadline has passed, making it 2-0 Card A and my Win.

[Nobita Nobi]

well good game