[Leaderboard] Thunderclap vs Raito-kun

[Northern Sage]

-All Leaderboard rules apply.
First to 3 votes or most votes by the deadline wins.
All voters must elaborate on their votes.

-The winner gets a rep from the loser.
-All voters get reps.
-The deadline for entries is May 29th.
-The contest ends on June 1st.
-Written cards are allowed. (Must be in written format, cards with blank pictures are not acceptable)

-Cards must be PM'd to me.
-Remove any evidence of the card being made by you to ensure anonymity.
-In case a downtime happens, the deadlines may be extended.

 

Requirement: Make a Trap Monster. Or a Spell Monster, whichever you prefer.

 

Card A:

 

Special Summon this card as a Tuner Monster (Fairy-type/WIND/Level 3/ATK 1000/ DEF 1300), then you can target 1 other monster you control; It gains 1 Level, and its Attribute becomes WIND, if possible. (This card is still treated as a Trap Card). If this face-down card is destroyed: You can target 1 Spell/Trap Card on the field; Return it to the deck.

Card B:

 

Activate when 2 or more cards on the field have been destroyed on the field by a card effect: Special Summon this card as an Effect Monster (Fiend-Type/DARK/Level 8/ATK 1000/ DEF 0) (This card is also still a Trap Card). This face-up card cannot be targeted by your opponent's card effects. Once per turn, if this card would be destroyed; You can target 1 monster in your Graveyard and banish it instead. Then if you do: This card gains ATK equal to the destroyed monster's ATK instead. When this Set card is destroyed by a card effect; Return all face-up monsters on the field to the Hand.

[Βyakuya]

Our eyes met, let's battle.

[Northern Sage]

Our eyes met, let's battle.

Nice.

[White Hollow]

Hm. Although both have similar effects, I;ll have to prefer Card A. Because both the image is better and the effect can support more decks, since IMHO Card B could only be 'useful' in Trap Monster decks. However, shouldn;t a Trap Monster also be considered a Trap? Because Card A doesn't mention that. It's kind of... overpowered summoning a Monster from a Trap while not being a Trap too(according to trap monster logic). I assume you forgot to add that part.

 

Anyways, I go for Card A

[Northern Sage]

1-0 Card A

Thanks for voting.

[Βyakuya]

Hm. Although both have similar effects, I;ll have to prefer Card A. Because both the image is better and the effect can support more decks, since IMHO Card B could only be 'useful' in Trap Monster decks. However, shouldn;t a Trap Monster also be considered a Trap? Because Card A doesn't mention that. It's kind of... overpowered summoning a Monster from a Trap while not being a Trap too(according to trap monster logic). I assume you forgot to add that part.

 

Anyways, I go for Card A

 

The OCG in cards like Tiki Soul and Shapesister have that clarification in order to establish the dual nature of the Trap Monster.

[Excalibur the Divine]

Hm. Although both have similar effects, I;ll have to prefer Card A. Because both the image is better and the effect can support more decks, since IMHO Card B could only be 'useful' in Trap Monster decks. However, shouldn;t a Trap Monster also be considered a Trap? Because Card A doesn't mention that. It's kind of... overpowered summoning a Monster from a Trap while not being a Trap too(according to trap monster logic). I assume you forgot to add that part.

Anyways, I go for Card A

Card A says that it is still a trap card, or was that edited after you made your post
Card A:This card is pretty good and helps synchros like shapesister does. Also, I like how it has an effect that activates if it is destroyed by cards such as mst while it's facedown.

Card B: I like this card, but this card is not very flexible and can be used in very few decks.

Although card B is great too, I vote card a because it can be used in more decks.

[Northern Sage]

Card A says that it is still a trap card, or was that edited after you made your post
Card A:This card is pretty good and helps synchros like shapesister does. Also, I like how it has an effect that activates if it is destroyed by cards such as mst while it's facedown.

Card B: I like this card, but this card is not very flexible and can be used in very few decks.

Although card B is great too, I vote card a because it can be used in more decks.

It was edited later.

 

2-0 Card A.

Thanks for voting.

[Northern Sage]

bump

[Oriannis]

Card A. It brings out a tuner from nowhere, Raises a monster by a level and if it gets destroyed you can still use it to stall your opponent. A well rounded card and very effective.

Card B. A powerful card that costs the opponent dearly for using effects to wipe out your field which I really like the thought of.

 

It was a close one for me because I would love to use card B against lightsworn but overall I was won over by Card A.

[Northern Sage]

3-0 Card A

Unless you have a problem with any vote, Raito, this is my win.

[Βyakuya]

Well, I do admit defeat. When i made the card I found this spare image, and I knew I had to use it, and this was the best I could do making a Trap monster out of it. And frankly Thunderclap, your is more versatile and has a more flexible Synchro advantage and destruction effect, so gg to you.