[Leaderboard] J-Max vs Aez (Done!)

[J-Max]

Leaderboard Rules apply
Voters must give a valid reason for their Votes
First to 3 or 48 Hours
Please PM your card to me with all Identification off of it.
Winner gets 1 Rep from the Loser.

 

Challenge: Create a Dinosaur-Type monster

 

CARD A

Diamannosaurus Rox
Level 6 EARTH
Dinosaur/Effect
This card is also treated as a Rock-Type while face-up on the field. Once per turn, this card cannot be destroyed by battle. Once per turn, when a face-up Dinosaur-Type monster you control is selected as an attack target: you can change the target to this face-up Defense position monster; change the battle position of this card after damage calculation.
1200 ATK/3000

 

CARD B

This card can be Special Summoned from your hand when "Jurassic World" is on the field. If this card was Special Summoned by its own effect, double this card's original ATK. Once per turn you can Banish 1 Dinosaur-Type monster from your field or 2 Dinosaur_type monsters from your Graveyard. This card can attack your opponent directly during this turn. When this card is removed from the field, you can Special Summon 1 Level 6 or below Banished Dinosaur-Type monster to your field. The ATK and DEF of the Special Summoed monster is 0.

[ÆƵ–]

I'll take you on. How about we make a defensive dinosaur type?

[J-Max]

I'll take you on. How about we make a defensive dinosaur type?

Sounds good to me :P Won't be able to use a cute image like I normally would (Unless I can find a girl dressed as a Dinosaur lol) You're on.

EDIT: Defensive might actually be hard for me as my choice of Dinosaurs (and Knowledge of them) is pretty low. Can we just make it a Dino?

[ÆƵ–]

[quote name="Kawaii Eeveelution 'J-Max'" post="6414467" timestamp="1400629877"

EDIT: Defensive might actually be hard for me as my choice of Dinosaurs (and Knowledge of them) is pretty low. Can we just make it a Dino?[/quote]

Oh yeah that will definitely be AlRight, sing add how the dinos are more on the offensive side of play.

[J-Max]

Cards are up. Go nuts people ^^

[OmegaWave]

Card A is an odd duckling. I can't really think of anything it's too useful for. Dinosaurs aren't typically known for being defensive.

 

Card B is flat out broken. It turns Jurassic World into "Special Summon up to 3 "Speedoraptor"s from your hand. Their ATK becomes 3300." It's a Level 4 3300 beater that can attack directly by banishing dinos, and then lets you plus off its own destruction by Special Summoning one of the Dinos you just banished. If put together in the right deck, this card is an OTK machine.

 

My vote is for Card A simply because Card B is just a bit too much.

[ÆƵ–]

1-0 card A. Thanks for voting Omega. Also, if I recall correctly, the original challenge was to make a defenSive dino, but we agreed that a reGular dino would work just fine.

[Excalibur the Divine]

Card A: Good defensive Dino, but can't really be used for Dino combos because dinos aren't usually for defense.

Card B: Like what Omega mentioned, this card is overpowered and the balance is bad. The idea is good, but it needs work on the balance. Also, near the end of the effect, the word "summoned" is spelled wrong.

I vote card A.

[Flash Flyer - Sakura]

Card A can essentially redirect attacks to it (and survive 2 attacks, assuming it isn't killed on the first shot). Somewhat weird given Dinos are offensively based for the most part, but protecting smaller monsters is always a nice thing.

 

Card B can become a 3000 ATK monster simply by having Jurassic World out (3300), then banishes to attack directly with that much attack. Also benefits from its destruction by SSing 1 of the monsters banished, which can lead to Xyz/Synchro spam later.

 

 

 

In essence, card A for being balanced.

[Generaxius]

Card A: Having a defensive dino with an ability to force itself as an attack target is usually good for blocking most attacks. This is a level 6 monster so it adds some balance on this card since it is cannot be normal summoned directly and cannot be changed to DEF position instantly. But mostly all Dino- Type monsters have low defense so it can be a disadvantage to some Dino combos.

 

 

Card B: This card is soooo unbalanced. Jurrasic World adds 300 ATK and DEF to all Dinosaur- Type monsters, so Speedoraptor will gain 300 ATK while in it's effect doubling it's ATK TO 3000 + 300 to 3300 which is too awesome for a level 4 monster with too easy requirements to achieve. An also, I see some TCG/OCG grammar wrong in this.

 

No offense dude, I vote for Card A.

[ÆƵ–]

Wow 4-0 card A! And with that, the contest is finIshed. Good game J-max. Like the others said, that thing is OP to the (j)max. Maybe if the increase was a lot smaller it would a bit more balanced, and perhaps you could say that only 1 Speedoraptor could attack directly per turn?

[J-Max]

Yeah I kinda messed up... I should really think more carefullt about effects in the future good game.