[Leaderboard] Kingdom Xathers vs Dyson Sphere (Voting Over: K. Xathers Wins)

[Kingdom Xathers]

Eh, figure I might as well participate in one this time.

1. All YCM and Leaderboard rules apply.
2. Cards must be PM'd to me.
3. First to 3 votes wins, or has the most votes after 72 hours if the 3 vote rule is not met.
4. Voters must have at least two sentences of their reason of choice.
5. Loser must give 1 Rep to the Winner.
6. Written cards are allowed.


Deadline: Must send entry within 48 hours, and voting ends 72 hours after the cards are in.


Condition: Challenger's Choice (challenge suggests the requirement which I can accept or decline)

"Make an Upgraded Version of an existing Lv.4 or lower monster" (Submission can be a different Level from the original, or be an Xyz Version of the original)


[spoiler=Card A]


You can tribute 1 "Flamvell Firedog" and 1 FIRE monster you control to Special Summon this card (from your hand or Deck). When this card is Special Summoned: You can Special Summon 1 Level 4 or lower FIRE monster from your hand or Graveyard. When this card is destroyed and sent to the Graveyard: You can target up to 2 cards on the field, destroy those targets.[/spoiler]
[spoiler=Card B]


You can banish 1 EARTH monster from your Graveyard; Special Summon this card (from your hand). You can only Special Summon "Milus of the Radiant Earth" this way once per turn. All EARTH monsters you control gain 200 ATK for each of your banished EARTH monsters. When this card leaves the field and is sent to your Graveyard: Add 1 of your banished EARTH monsters to your hand.[/spoiler]

[Qliphort Tool]

I challenge you to make an Upgraded Version of an existing Lv.4 or lower monsters

[Kingdom Xathers]

I challenge you to make an Upgraded Version of an existing Lv.4 or lower monsters

Same level, or can it be an "evolution" that's a higher Level/an Xyz Monster?

[Qliphort Tool]

Any level (or rank) just the original form is Lv.4 or lower (not rank, since many of R4 are already powerful) monster

[Kingdom Xathers]

Okay!  I accept your conditions!

[Kingdom Xathers]

Just a reminder: Both Contestants have until 11:30 PM Sunday to submit their entries.

 

 

... feels kinda funny saying that, since I'm one of those contestants. @___@

[Kingdom Xathers]

Cards are now up, voting time is now!

[Maeriberii Haan]

Card A...the fact it's played like a Synchro BUT somewhat more flexible and it being able summoned as a +0 while also giving the threat of a double pop when it die seems to be too much. Card B is somewhat underwhelming though, but compared to A's potential of abuse, I had to choose for B.

[Kwisatz-Haderach]

I mean, long comments are not needed in this case, a part from the card you've chosen to evolve.

 

A has got a special summon effect that activates in Deck too, which is very obscene and, much probably, illegal in present rulings. Once touches the field, there's a lvl4 s.summon effect from both hand and grave. And once it is destroyed in any way, pop 2 cards on field....and it's a lvl 7 2600atk

 

B is balanced and useful, nice card for fast rank4 and recycle eff

 

in my opinion both cards missed the contest task, however i vote B cuz A is unaccpetable

[Kingdom Xathers]

Card B is currently in the lead, 2-0

[-Noel-]

yea Card A is too much, that charmer ss condition is not fit with the 2.6k beater, also with 2 additional effects which are too great, Card B effect is not so good, why I will run this instead of Heavy Storm on 1900 body? but even I think Card B is too weak, I have to Vote Card B due to Card A's absurd.

[Kingdom Xathers]

Okay, so, with 3 votes to 0, that means Card B, and thus myself, is the winner of this 1-vs-1.

And a bit of trivia: Card A is Flamvell Firedog (according to the effect), while Milus of the Radiant Earth is Milus Radiant (his Level, ATK and DEF are all multiplied by four).

Funny thing is, I was originally going to have Milus' boost effect be 300 for each banished EARTH, but then I considered the fact that some EARTH monsters could easily reach 2100+ ATK with just 3 banished EARTHs, not to mention that you could have two Milus' out... so yeah, I chicken' out and lowered the boost to 200.

[Kingdom Xathers]

[spoiler=I know this contest has already been decided, but I was simply curious: since the rules for Leaderboard prohibits you from submitting a card that's already been posted on the Forum, I could not post the following card, but if I had not made this card beforehand and submitted it for this contest, how would it have faired?]



Can be Special Summoned (from your hand) by banishing 1 "Elemental HERO Wildheart" from your Graveyard. This card's name is treated as "Elemental HERO Wildheart" while on the field or in the Graveyard. When this card is successfully Summoned, it gains 1000 ATK. This card is unaffected by the effects of Trap Cards. You can return one of your banished "HERO" monsters to your Deck to negate the activation and effect of a Trap Card and destroy it. When a Fusion Monster that lists "Elemental HERO Wildheart" as a Fusion Material is successfully Fusion Summoned using this card as a Fusion Material, that monster gains this card's effects.[/spoiler]

 

 

Also, Dyson Sphere hasn't been on for two days... =-|

[Blue Amoonguss]

This card is a free summon with Wildheart in the grave, with 2500 points. I think it would have the same problem as Card A in the contest.