[Leaderboard] 1v1 Me VS Zextra (VOTE NOW)

[Zazubat]

1 .Normal Leaderboard Rules apply
2. First to 3 or when the contest ends (July 11th) wins.
3. Writtens are allowed.

4. Votes must be valid

5. Winners gets a point in the Leaderboard.

6. Voters gets likes if I (or my opponent) like the review enough for it to be worth it.

7.Send by PM because of A/B system.

8. Make a card that counters something, either it be Type, Attribute, Xyz Monster, Monster Effect, Spell Card, whatever, just make it counter something directly.

 

[spoiler=Card A]

You can Set this card from your hand to your Spell & Trap Card Zone as a Trap Card. When a monster your opponent controls activates an effect while this card is Set as a Trap Card: You can flip this card face-up; equip this card to that monster. The equipped monster cannot attack or activate its effects. During your Main Phase: You can banish 1 monster in your Graveyard; Special Summon this equipped card to the field. If this card is Special Summoned by this effect: It gains the previously equipped monster’s effect until the End Phase.

[/spoiler]

 

[spoiler=Card B]

2 Level 4 monsters
During either player’s turn, when an Attack Position monster activated a monster effect: You can detach 1 Xyz Material from this card to target that monstere; negate the effect, then change that monster to Defense Position and put 1 Flare Counter on it (only 1 Flare Counter can be on that monster at a time). Monsters with Flare Counters lose 500 DEF for each colon in its card text. This card must be face-up to activate and to resolve this effect. The effect of “Pegasus Flare” can only be activated once per turn. If this card attacks a Defense Position monster, inflict piercing Battle Damage to your opponent.

[/spoiler]

[Zextra]

Ready for a rematch? :3 I'll have my card sent by tomorrow.

[Zazubat]

Ready for a rematch? :3 I'll have my card sent by tomorrow.

Sure thing.

[Sploda]

I'm not sure if an effect is allowed to target an alphabetical symbol...

 

Normally Card A would be the more unbalanced one seeing as it can still be normal summoned. However Card B is a level 4 Xyz, meaning it should be quite easy to summon. Furthermore it can activate during both player's turns, and a once per turn use isn't really that big of a drawback or restriction. Plus it deals Piercing damage.

 

My vote will have to go to the slightly less broken Card A.

[Therrion]

I usually do a long review, but this will be concise.

Effect negation is not something I would want to see on a generic Xyz, especially not of this caliber. As I was reading, I was thinking perhaps the Blaze Counter would add DEF, to perhaps slightly justify the fact you slapped effect negation on a generic Xyz, but it decreased DEF. Okay, I thought, then there is going to be some downfall later. Piercing damage. Really (known creator of Card B )? I have to vote against this card whether I like Card A or not (but I do like Card A a lot, as it is creative and balanced). The only thing I like about Card B is the fact it is original with the DEF decrease.

 

I vote for Card A.

[Zazubat]

2 for A
0 for B

[Zazubat]

I'm forfeiting this, since I assume that I won't win anyway, as my card is kinda unbalanced now that I look at it. I thought it was alright since there's powerful cards like Laggia out there, and I gave it some restrictions, but I guess I might have overdone it with that DP decrease and all that. So yeah, Zextra, you can have this one.

[Zextra]

If you're sure, then. Good match, Zazu.