[LEADERBOARD] Me vs Thar FINISHED

[Northern Sage]

All YCM and Leaderboard rules apply.

-First to 3 votes or who has the most votes when the deadline has been reached.

-All voters must have a reason.

All voters get a a like.

Deadline is June 1st.

Make a Gemini Monster that can take control of your opponent's monsters.

 

My Card:

 

 

 

 

While face-up on the field and in the Graveyard: This card is treated as a Normal Monster. While face-up on the field: You can Normal Summon this card; It is treated as an Effect Monster with the following effects:

• When this card is Gemini Summoned: Place 1 Ice Counter on each monster your opponent controls. Once, while this card is face-up on the field: You can target 1 monster your opponent controls with an Ice Counter(s); Take control of that target. While you control a monster by this card's effect: It's effects are negated, and it cannot be used for a Summon, except for the Summon of a WATER monster.

 

Thar's Card:

 

Cagemaster Crystal (DARK)

[ Spellcaster / Gemini ]

This card is treated as a Normal Monster while face-up on the field or in the Graveyard. While this card is face-up on the field, you can Normal Summon it to have it be treated as an Effect Monster with this effect:

 When this card is Normal Summoned successfully as an Effect monster: You may gain control of one monster your opponent controls; that monster cannot attack, and its effects are negated. When this card is removed from the field: Return control of that monster to your opponent.

ATK: 2400 / DEF: 1400

[Thar]

I'll be taking my reserve. Expect my card sometime tonight or tomorrow evening.

[Northern Sage]

I'll be taking my reserve. Expect my card sometime tonight or tomorrow evening.

All right, accepted.

[Northern Sage]

Both cards are up, the voting shall begin now.

[Zazubat]

Both are pretty decent, card A is balanced with it's low stats, but is also pretty powerful, and card B takes a bit more to get out, but it's also stronger. I think I'm gonna go with card B on this one.

[Northern Sage]

1-0 Card B

Thanks for voting

[~Red~]

Hmm...Geminis. I haven't ever meddled with these guys too much, but they definitely seem cool. Anyway, on to the cards themselves. Card A has pretty low stats, and would have a harder time of actually getting Gemini Summoned BUT its effect offers lots of options, as well as being able to play off of any other card that uses Ice Counters. Now Card B is a higher level, requiring tributes, making it harder to get out AND THEN you still have to Gemini Summon it, but it does have a more likely chance of staying on the field long enough to make use of its effects. I'll go with Card B here, but they were both decent. 

[Northern Sage]

2-0 Card B

Thanks for voting.

[Zextra]

Both are pretty solid cards; while Ambrosia's card has synergy with Ice Counters, Thar's card is slightly harder to pull off, but is more universal. However, I think Ambrosia's card is overall more effective, since it's easier to Gemini summon (since you can SS it by using something like Mother Grizzly, for example), and it doesn't restrict the monster as much as Thar's.

 

So my vote goes to Card A.

[Northern Sage]

2-1 Card B

Thanks for voting

[Thar]

We need at least one more vote. Put 'em in a Molotov and chuck it so we can burn this thread down and be done with it.

[Thar]

Not sure if this is against the rules for bumping a thread that isn't mine, but it's within the 24 hour minimum and we need votes.

[Ren✧]

My vote is going to Card B. I just don't think Card A is going to stay on the field long enough to make much use of its effect. I know there are cards that give Geminis there effects right off, but in my experience, most Gemini Decks tend to Gemini summon the normal way(or troll with Gemini break). Card B just has more staying power than Card A, although Card A's effect is noticeably stronger. 

[Northern Sage]

3-1 Card B

Thanks for voting

GG Thar

[Thar]

Agreed. Thanks for reserving me a spot.