[Leaderboard] Zazu vs Goalmaster (It has been done)

[Zazubat]

1 .Normal Leaderboard Rules apply
2. First to 3 or when the contest ends (May 29th) wins.
3. Writtens are allowed.
4. Votes must be valid.

5. Winners gets a point in the leaderboard, and gets a like from the opponent.

6. The goal is to make a Level 4 Main Deck Tuner. You can make it for an Archetype if you wish to, but it's NOT a requirement.

 

Card A:

When this card is Normal Summoned:Add one level 4 or Lower "Darkness Kingdome"Monster from your Deck to your hand.
When this card is Summoned While you control no "Darkness Kingdome"monster:You can add one Level 5 "Darkness Kingdome monster from your deck to your hand.
You can Synchro Summon a "Darkness Kingdome" monster using this card and other "Darkness Kingdome"from your hand as Synchro materials

Card B:

If this card is Normal Summoned: You can target 1 “Gusto” monster in your Graveyard; shuffle that target into the Main Deck, and if you do, Special Summon “Gusto” Level 4 or lower non-Tuner monster from your hand or Graveyard with its effects negated while on the field, and when it is sent to the Graveyard. This card cannot be used a Synchro Material Monster, except for the Synchro Summon of a “Gusto” Synchro Monster.

[Goalmaster]

i would like to join but what do you mean exactly by "Main Deck Tuner"?

[Zazubat]

i would like to join but what do you mean exactly by "Main Deck Tuner"?

That I don't want a Fusion Tuner or a Synchro Tuner. Anyway, if you're fine with that, I'll accept you.

[Goalmaster]

So you mean something like "Junk Synchron" right?

[Zazubat]

So you mean something like "Junk Synchron" right?

Yes. I mean a Tuner monster, just not something like Formula Synchron, which does not belong in Main Deck, it belongs in the Extra Deck.

[Goalmaster]

ok im in.

[Northern Sage]

With so little information on the archetype it supports, it is very hard to judge Card A. Based on its own merits, however, and some good other support, there is no way this is going to be good design, when you are +1ing just by Summoning it. There is no balancing act with such a design.

I believe B does a swell job at supporting its archetype, so vote for Card B.

[Zazubat]

Card A 0

Card B 1

 

Thx 4 da votz.

[Aix]

What kind of extreme brokenness is this? Card A is a +2 upon Normal Summon in addition to a hand-Synchroer.

 

Vote to Card B.

[Zextra]

I hate to be the d*ck who points this out, but Card B isn't a Tuner, so it doesn't follow the requirements. :o
So although Card B is superior, due to it not being a Tuner I will reluctantly have to give my vote to Card A.

[.codex]

I hate to be the d*ck who points this out, but Card B isn't a Tuner, so it doesn't follow the requirements. :o
So although Card B is superior, due to it not being a Tuner I will reluctantly have to give my vote to Card A.

I'm quite sure he meant it to be a Tuner, I mean, it was the only requirement after all :/ 
But anyway, I have to agree with others here, card B is way less broken, plus I got no idea what that archetype even is, at least I know a bit about Gustos, so those would probably like this. 

[Zextra]

[quote name=".codex" post="6206563" timestamp="1369251171"]I'm quite sure he meant it to be a Tuner, I mean, it was the only requirement after all :/ [/quote] While I am fully aware that is the case, a seemingly small mistake like that is crucial in a contest match, since I feel a contest card should be throroughly refined and checked for mistakes before being posted. Though as I did point out before, Card B is by far the better of the two cards, due to Card A not having an Archetype we can judge upon, as well as it likely being abusable should said archetype be the slightest bit competitive.

[.codex]

While I am fully aware that is the case, a seemingly small mistake like that is crucial in a contest match, since I feel a contest card should be throroughly refined and checked for mistakes before being posted. Though as I did point out before, Card B is by far the better of the two cards, due to Card A not having an Archetype we can judge upon, as well as it likely being abusable should said archetype be the slightest bit competitive.

True true, though some things do sometimes just slip past our heads. 

[Zazubat]

Oh, that's weird, I made this card before the contest even started, and I meant for it to be a Tuner, but I must have forgotten to add it. Anyway, the standings are 3-1, so I guess I win.