TheComposer vs. FTW(For The Wynn) - Again... AGAIN!

[TheComposer]

This time around me and FTW are doing a Card A, Card B voting style.

 

[spoiler=Requirements]

-Must be a Sea-Serpent type monster

-EDIT: We decided to change the rules a little, so now it's just a monster that can equip to another monster

-Can only equip to opponent's monsters

-Weakens the monster it is equipped to

 

 

[spoiler=Prize]1 rep from the loser

 

 

[spoiler=When the contest will end]The contest will end when someone gets 3 votes, or 1 week after the cards have been posted, whichever comes first.

 

 

[spoiler=Vote count]Card A(FTW(For The Wynn):1

Card B(TheComposer):3

 

 

[spoiler=Card A]

Lore:

When this card is destroyed in battle, equip it to 1 monster your opponent controls. That monster loses 1000 ATK and cannot change battle position nor activate its effect. When this card is destroyed by a Spell or Trap Card effect you can Special Summon 1 Level 5 or lower WATER Attribute monster from your Deck or Graveyard. That monster cannot attack during your next Battle Phase.

 

 

[spoiler=Card B]

Lore:

Once per turn, during your Main Phase, if you control this monster on the field, you can equip it to a face-up monster on your opponent's side of the field OR unequip the Union equipment and Special Summon this card in face-up Attack Position. When equipped to a monster by this card's effect, that monster is switched to Attack Position and cannot change it's position. That monster also loses 100 ATK/DEF each turn. (1 monster can only be equipped with 1 Union Monster at a time. When the monster this card is equipped is destroyed this card is destroyed instead.) When this card is destroyed, you can send 1 monster on your side of the field to the Graveyard to Special Summon this card in face-up Attack Position.

 

 

 

NO VOTING BASED OFF PICTURE OR NAME!!

 

NOW VOTE!!!!!!!!!!!

[Cosmic Destroyer of Tea]

I'm confused but... ...Luck :) :)

[TheComposer]

Vote peeps!!

[Raine]

Card B can maybe be made into a deck to utilize the loop but I don't see much use in Normal or WATER decks its effect however has very good OCG and some usability

 

Card A can be used very manipulatively and works well with a Legendary Ocean Deck

 

I give my vote to Card A

[TheComposer]

Card A:1

Card B:0

 

Thanks for the vote :P

[snowyash]

Card B fit's the requirements best in my eyes, being a Union monster with a nice twist by being able to equip it to your opponent's monster instead and the ability to reuse the monster as you see fit. Unfortunately, when equipped, the effect isn't really so impressive. OCG seems...odd...in places.

 

Card A seems OP'd. Basically anything that removes it to the field activates quite a heavy effect. The first effect would be balanced on it's own, but the Spell/Trap stipulation is overkill. This card has the better OCG and picture though.

 

While less useful, Card B seems tick pretty much every box other than OCG, whereas Card A is OP'd and lacks balance.

 

I vote for Card B.

[TheComposer]

oooo Its a close one FTW :)

 

Card A:1

Card B:1

 

And thanks for the vote :P

[Guest Synergy]

It was a hard choice for me but I choose card B since it can be special summoned multiple times if you have a tribute and card a needs to tributes for a normal summon and has no re-summoning effect

[TheComposer]

Hmmm I think it's good enough :)

 

Card A:1

Card B:2

 

And thanks for the vote :P

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

Wow, 3 votes already...I'm impressed. Anyway, keep them coming people :D

[Cosmic Destroyer of Tea]

Card A.

Thats best...

Leviatham reminds me the Dartz card in Yu-gi-oh.

The Card B is nice but the Card A is best.

:)

[TheComposer]

That votes based off the name/picture so I can't count it :/ Must be based off of OCG, effect, usefulness, and balance.

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

Card A.

Thats best...

Leviatham reminds me the Dartz card in Yu-gi-oh.

The Card B is nice but the Card A is best.

:)

 

Like Composer said, we can't count this until you give a decent explanation why.

[Engetsu]

My vote goes to card B because IMO it's more balanced and has better OCG than card A, although it's effect is kinda weak.

[TheComposer]

:DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! VICTORY IS MINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

*ehem*

well, good game FTW... *tries to hold in happiness*

 

FTW: 1

TheComposer: 3

 

:)

[The Broken]

I'm going to go with card B since i believe that the OCG is pretty good and the effect can be useful during any duel against anything. I especially like the last part where it said "sacrifice one monster on your field to summon it to the field in face-up attack" i find that effect very useful.

 

Anyways, to make a long comment short, my vote goes to B. :)

[Raine]

Ahh, that sucks I was the only one to go for Card A no offense Composer your still a good guy

[TheComposer]

Well Darkmaster the contest was over but thanks anyway lol :)

 

@Grand Raine: Well, I feel like reviewing your vote, but no offense taken :)

I asked to make a Sea-Serpent type monster, not a WATER monster. Not all Sea-Serpents have to be WATER, just like all Fiends don't have to be DARK. I see your reason for voting, but I thought I should just point this out :)

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

lol, this got kind of busy. Seems good, but I won't lose next time. Fair warning :D

[Raine]

rewording ftw: For the Wynn is blasting off agian... *ding

[The Broken]

wait it was already over? o.O

[TheComposer]

haha yep XD It had just ended though so don't worry :P

 

oh, and @FTW: BRING IT ON!!!!

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

ehh, losing is fun enough, but I've been doing it too much lately, mostly because I don't really put any effort into cards lately. The only card I've put any effort into for the past 2 weeks or so is here.