Admiral_Stalfos19 vs. Zextra [FINISHED]

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

Almost a level 3 now: only 9 posts away, after this one of course. I thought hosting my 3rd ever 1on1 would get me there ;)

 

RULES:

 

First person to post here is my opponent. I'll face anyone, although I prefer someone I haven't gone against before.

That person must pick one underpowered monster and make a Spell or Trap Card that'll turn that monster into a force to be reckoned with.

3 votes are required to win, unless 72 hrs pass, then the one with the most votes wins. The winner receives +1 Rep. Simple. Oh, and in the event of a tie, I'll initiate a tie-breaker round.

Votes on name, pic or OCG are off-limits... BUT if you can state something else wrong with the card in question, or even with both cards, then I'll probably let you off.

 

And now, I declare this 3rd 1on1... OPEN!!

 

EDIT: Adding these spoilers here in advance. These'll contain our cards:

 

[spoiler=My Card]

 

This card is also treated as an Equip Spell, and must be equipped to a face-up "Mystical Beast of Serket" that you have Tribute Summoned. The equipped "Mystical Beast of Serket" cannot be destroyed by its own effect. Once per turn, you can pay Life Points equal to the ATK of the equipped "Mystical Beast of Serket". If you do, negate any card effects that would prevent the equipped "Mystical Beast of Serket" from attacking, and destroy the cards. If you have paid Life Points to activate this card's effect before the equipped "Mystical Beast of Serket" has attacked, the equipped "Mystical Beast of Serket" can attack all monsters on the field once each.

 

 

[spoiler=Zextra's Card]

 

Activate only while you control a face-up "Dark Bat". You can discard up to 3 cards to place a number of Supersonic Counters on a "Dark Bat" you control equal to the number of cards discarded. You can remove 1 Supersonic Counter from "Dark Bat" when your opponent declares an attack to select the attack target. When "Dark Bat" is removed from the field, you can Special Summon 1 WIND monster from your Deck or Graveyard with 1000 or less ATK.

 

[Zextra]

I would like to reserve. I will make my card now, and hopefully it will be up within the next hour.

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

Yep... successfully reserved. Zextra is my official opponent, unless I don't receive a card within 24 hrs, which is pretty damn unlikely.

[Zextra]

Well, it's lame as hell, but here it is...

 

 

Lore:

Activate only while you control a face-up "Dark Bat". You can discard up to 3 cards to place a number of Supersonic Counters on a "Dark Bat" you control equal to the number of cards discarded. You can remove 1 Supersonic Counter from "Dark Bat" when your opponent declares an attack to select the attack target. When "Dark Bat" is removed from the field, you can Special Summon 1 WIND monster from your Deck or Graveyard with 1000 or less ATK.

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

K, mine will be ready in a minute...

 

EDIT: OK, cards are ready. You may start voting... NAO!!

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

*yawns* Sitting here waiting for a vote.

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

Bump Kick

[TheComposer]

wow, this was a REALLY HARD choice. But in the end, Zextra gmv because his effect is a tad more creative, and even though Admiral's card was more useful, I always judge creativity>usefulness.

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

Thanks for the vote.

 

1-nil to Zextra

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

Bump Kick

[Engetsu]

I vote for Zextra's card because IMO it's more useful and creative, even though both cards are rather situational.

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

2-nil to Zextra now...

 

One more should finish this.

[Guest Synergy]

i vote for admiral's card because zextra's card would require another monster so you could select the attack target while admiral's card is more useful since it supports a stronger monster

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

YAY, I have a chance...

 

2-1 to Zextra now.

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

Bump Kick.

[Bahamut - Envoy of the End]

Well since you're bribing me into voting:

 

Stalfos: I can only imagine how frustrating it must be to have Mystical Beast Serket destroyed by MST. This is a big FU to cheap tactics like that. Huge lie point cost for huge effect. Think being able to attack so many times is a bit much, maybe just twice would have been sufficent. And why not just make it an Equip Spell, really?

 

Zextra: Gives me no real inclination to play Dark Bat, ever. Already highlighted that you can only use this is you have another monster, so you could end up wasting a lot of cards. Was wondering why on earth there was a Deck summon ability on the end, then of course, you'd use it to bring out another Bat.

 

I like Stalfos's card more: Don't think Zextra's is worth using. Stalfos's would instantly make Serket popular.

[Zextra]

Thanks for the vote :D

2-2 Tiebreaker

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

Crap, forgot about MST...

 

Oh well, too late now. Besides, if I even attempted to do something about that, it would probably make my card even closer to broken =/

 

Confirming 2-all. If I don't receive a vote within 24 hours from now, I'll initiate the tie-breaker round.

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

3 more hours guys... We need 1 more vote on either side.

[ninjarainbowcloud6!]

I'm going to vote for admirals card because it is more useful and would make mystical beast serket a very powerful card but with zextra's you have to have another monster on your side of the field for it to work and you have to discard 3 cards

[Admiral_Stalfos19]

And that's game, with 3-2 to me. Thanks for the final vote.

[Zextra]

Alright, nice match :D

+1 rep given.