Jump to content

A Victory 1 on 1 - Spoon vs. Galadrien (1-4) *LOCK*

Spoon

By Spoon
in Finished Contests

Recommended Posts

Spoon Newbie

Spoon

Posted
Posted

I'm still not satisfied, I'm bored and I have a fitting card in my collection... that means: More 1on1s!

 

Rules:

- First one to post who thinks that he/she can beat me (and fulfill the not so easy requirements this time) is my opponent.

- First to 4 votes wins.

- Prize: 1 Rep

 

Card Requirements:

I didn't choose those overblown words in the topic without a reason ;) Make an Effect Monster Card (can also be Fusion, Synchro or Ritual) that, under certain conditions, wins the Duel (like Exodia, Exodius the Ultimate Forbidden Lord or Vennominaga the Deity of Poisonous Snakes). That's all.

 

[spoiler=Galadrien's card (4 Votes)]245354hi.jpg

Lore:

You can Special Summon this card from your hand, if you do, decrease this card's DEF by 1000. This card's ATK is unaffected by card effects. During each of the Standby Phases, place 1 Mini-Victory Slab Counter on this card. During each of the End Phases, decrease this card's DEF by 500. When this card's DEF reaches 0, destroy this card. When there are 10 Mini-Victory Slab Counters on this card, you win the Duel.

 

 

[spoiler=Spoon's card (1 Vote)]234848ys.jpg

Lore:

"Night's End Sorcerer" + 2 or more non-Tuner Spellcaster-Type monsters

Each time you Special Summon a Spellcaster-Type monster (including Synchro and Fusion Summon), place Spell Counters on this card equal to the Level of the Summoned monster (max. 50). This card gains 100 ATK and DEF for each Spell Counter on it. Spell Counters on this card cannot be removed except by it's own effect. Once per turn, you can remove up to 8 Spell Counters from this card to return Spellcaster-Type monsters from your Graveyard to your hand whose total Level is equal to the number of removed Spell Counters. During your opponents End Phase, if there are 50 Spell Counters on this card, you win the Duel.

 

 

May the best Card Maker win :)

 

So long,

 

Spoon

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Phantom M.C. Newbie

Phantom M.C.

Posted
Posted

not my best card, but it'll have to do

 

[spoiler=card]245354hi.jpg

Lore:

You can Special Summon this card from your hand, if you do, decrease this card's DEF by 1000. This card's ATK is unaffected by card effects. During each of the Standby Phases, place 1 Mini-Victory Slab Counter on this card. During each of the End Phases, decrease this card's DEF by 500. When this card's DEF reaches 0, destroy this card. When there are 10 Mini-Victory Slab Counters on this card, you win the Duel.

 

 

EDIT: image credit to jazinkay

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Spoon Newbie

Spoon

Posted
  • Author
Posted

not my best card, but it'll have to do

 

[spoiler=card]245354hi.jpg

Lore:

You can Special Summon this card from your hand, if you do, decrease this card's DEF by 1000. This card's ATK is unaffected by card effects. During each of the Standby Phases, place 1 Mini-Victory Slab Counter on this card. During each of the End Phases, decrease this card's DEF by 500. When this card's DEF reaches 0, destroy this card. When there are 10 Mini-Victory Slab Counters on this card, you win the Duel.

 

 

EDIT: image credit to jazinkay

 

Alrighty, guys, we need votes!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
NightGuardian1764 Newbie

NightGuardian1764

Posted
Posted

Spoon gets my vote.

 

Galadrien: If it is unaffected by card effects, that self-destruct effect is not needed. Moreover, how your opponent gonna defeat it? It is unaffected by card effects, Destroys it by battle? No, your opponent must got 3000 ATK monster before there are 10 Counters, I suggest that it's hard to do like that. In addition YOU WIN before the DEF becomes 0. Also, your opponent cannot decrease its DEF as it's unaffected by card effects. Oped.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Phantom M.C. Newbie

Phantom M.C.

Posted
Posted
If it is unaffected by card effects, that self-destruct effect is not needed. Moreover, how your opponent gonna defeat it? It is unaffected by card effects, Destroys it by battle? No, your opponent must got 3000 ATK monster before there are 10 Counters, I suggest that it's hard to do like that. In addition YOU WIN before the DEF becomes 0. Also, your opponent cannot decrease its DEF as it's unaffected by card effects. Oped.

 

read the effect again, you are really wrong, only it's ATK is unaffected by card effects, so your opponent could still use card effects to decrease its def, and also, if you did some counting, you would find that with this card's original DEF as 5000, it would only get 9 counters before its def reaches 0, so you would need DEF boosting cards to make it work. and if you use its ss effect with its DEF as 4000, you would even need more boosts to its def.

 

@dyspraxia: wtf, you did the same thing on my other 1on1, you're reason is always: "i don't understand galadrien's card" do you have something against me?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Zextra Newbie

Zextra

Posted
Posted

I vote for Spoon.

 

Sorry, Galadrien. I really like the idea you made, but it just seems to be too hard to pull off. When its DEF reaches the 1500-ish range, it makes it an easy target to kill.

Spoon's on the other hand, is easy to kill in the beginning, but is highly effective in Spellcaster Decks, where Special Summons are quite common. Therefore, the card's effect is easier to activate.

 

It was close, and Galadrien, really nice card (I will give both of you a rep each), but my vote goes to Spoon for more playability.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
chedbonlahor Newbie

chedbonlahor

Posted
Posted

OK THIS IS REDICULOUS!!!!!

 

King of Dyspraxia HadesRuler1 and newfie1 I'm getting royally p***ed off when you comment on 1 on 1s like you do. You cant enter the fray and weigh in on a 1 on 1 if you dont understand the cards, it's simply not fair. If you dont understand a card submitted then that is YOUR problem and you are not in a position to call a winner either way. Now, I know from being here and I know from experience that Spoon and Galadrien are top card-makers and any confusion you have about the cards is yours alone. I promise you all that if I see any more voting along the lines of:

 

-didn't understand the effect so the other guy wins.....or

-the effect was too long the other guy wins

 

I will have to call the moderator in because voting like this makes a mockery of the 1 on 1 section and makes it difficult for good card makers like these to get good feedback.

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Now to voting, this one is a toughie, it's in fact one of the hardest ones i've had to call.

 

I am going to have to give the vote to Galadrien. Spoon your card under normal circumstances is incredible, I like the usage of the counters and the strategy involved, the imagery is great and it is overall a fantastic card, however Galadrien's card is exceptional, the different types of tactics that come into play when using his card, which is more DEF rather than token based is very intruiging. It's feels more like a climactic countdown with Galadrien's card, I could imaging sitting there with 500 DEF and praying for my opponent to end the turn. I guess that Galadrien GMV as it would feel like a greater achivement to win using his card rather than yours spoon, you were bested by pure brilliance here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Spoon Newbie

Spoon

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Yes, I still wish this forum had an ignore button... but since it's all about opinion in this Section of the forum, I can't blame them either... I mean, I can, but I can't just ignore their votes. But... well, the rules don't specifically say that I can't but I assume if I just could ignore votes as I pleased, chaos would be assured.

 

Anyways, thank you for voting, that makes it 3-1 for Mr. Galadrien... if you should win this, I'll give you the paycheck for it in the Arena ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
RedRuler Newbie

RedRuler

Posted
Posted

OK THIS IS REDICULOUS!!!!!

 

King of Dyspraxia HadesRuler1 and newfie1 I'm getting royally p***ed off when you comment on 1 on 1s like you do. You cant enter the fray and weigh in on a 1 on 1 if you dont understand the cards, it's simply not fair. If you dont understand a card submitted then that is YOUR problem and you are not in a position to call a winner either way. Now, I know from being here and I know from experience that Spoon and Galadrien are top card-makers and any confusion you have about the cards is yours alone. I promise you all that if I see any more voting along the lines of:

 

-didn't understand the effect so the other guy wins.....or

-the effect was too long the other guy wins

 

I will have to call the moderator in because voting like this makes a mockery of the 1 on 1 section and makes it difficult for good card makers like these to get good feedback.

 

I think you didn't understand me Ched, what i said was that i did understand the effect of Galadrien's unlike the others, and that it's effect was better.

I never said that i never understood Spoon's card effect or that it' effect is too long to read.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...