Max Darkness vs. Caeda LOCK.

[Guest Caeda]

Card Requirements

1. Must be a Union Monster.
   
2. Must be Level Three or below.
   
3. Must support a WATER Monster in the game.
   

 

Due to new rules, only one rep may be given to the winner.

First to seven votes wins.

 

ALL VOTES MUST HAVE A GOOD REASON.

 

[spoiler=Max Darkness' Card]

Card Lore:

2 Level 3 or lower WATER monsters

This card can only be Special Summoned from your Extra Deck by sending the above cards in your hand or on your side of the field to the Graveyard while "Umi" is face-up on the field. You can Tribute this face-up card to add 1 "Daedalus" monster from your Deck or Graveyard to your hand. Once per turn, during your Main Phase, you can equip this card to a "Daedalus" monster you control as an Equip Card, OR unequip it to Special Summon this card in face-up Attack Position. This card is unaffected by the effects of the equipped monster. Each time the equipped monster inflicts Battle Damage to your opponent, return 1 WATER monster with 1500 or less ATK or 1 Field Spell Card from your Graveyard to your Deck. (A monster can only be equipped with 1 Union Monster at a time. If the equipped monster would be destroyed, destroy this card instead.)

 

 

[spoiler=Caeda's Card]

Card Lore:

Once per turn, you can equip this card to a "White Night Dragon" you control, OR unequip it to Special Summon this card in face-up Defense Position. When equipped to a monster by this card's effect, the equipped monster cannot be destroyed by Spell or Trap cards. If "White Knight Dragon" attacks the opponent directly, destroy this card. If this card is sent to the Graveyard by the effect of "White Night Dragon" add this card to your Deck, then shuffle. (A monster can only be equipped with 1 Union Monster at a time. If the equipped monster would be destroyed, destroy this card instead.)

[Guest Striker]

The first thing I saw was the lack of an attack increase. All Union cards offer that. With that in mind, Max's is harder to summon and has a good effect, but with the lack of Umi based decks Caeda gmv.

[Guest Caeda]

The first thing I saw was the lack of an attack increase. All Union cards offer that. With that in mind, Max's is harder to summon and has a good effect, but with the lack of Umi based decks Caeda gmv.

 

Thanks Striker.

 

0-1 Caeda.

 

But no, not all of them.

 

See?

[Guest Striker]

Useless card is useless. Anyway, my work here is done. Oh, you need to set a "first to # wins".

[Guest Caeda]

Useless card is useless. Anyway, my work here is done. Oh, you need to set a "first to # wins".

 

Have you ever used Machina Gadgets? It has to run him in about two or threes to search for Fortress. Oh yeah, I forgot. D:

[Max Darkness]

The first thing I saw was the lack of an attack increase. All Union cards offer that. With that in mind, Max's is harder to summon and has a good effect, but with the lack of Umi based decks Caeda gmv.

 

"Machina Gearframe", "Machina Peacekeeper", "Freezing Beast", "Armor Breaker" and "Des Dendle" are five that offer no ATK/DEF increase. "Armored Cybern" actually does the opposite, lowering the equipped monster's ATK as a cost. A large number of early Unions offered ATK/DEF increases, but more recent ones focus on beneficial effects.

 

 

EDIT: "Machina Gearframe" is anything but useless in a Machina-Gadget Deck. It's a very potent searcher, and has enough ATK to exist on its own.

[Guest Striker]

I own the Doistu and Soistu package so I'm old school with Unions.

[Master White]

They are both Great cards, 1 supports Water monsters, brings out a good destruction strategy. The other card supports "White Knight Dragon" and they are both good combinations. Caeda's effect ties well with White Knight Dragon", but again it lacks some strength. But all-in all, I'm sorry Max, but I'm going for Caeda's b/c it benefits White Dragon Knight.

 

So my vote goes for Caeda.

[Lexadin]

I like both cards. However I vote for Max's card, becouse of 2 things. I like the idea of a Fusion/Union monster and Caeda's card has Silent Magician LV8 as a pic.

[Phantom M.C.]

vote for max, cause its a fusion/union, and goes great with Daedalus' destruction effect

[Max Darkness]

Thank you both.

 

2-2

[Guest Caeda]

I like both cards. However I vote for Max's card, becouse of 2 things. I like the idea of a Fusion/Union monster and Caeda's card has Silent Magician LV8 as a pic.

 

I can accept the first point, but I honestly can't see why you care about the picture. It fits the card, and the support, so I used it. Blame Mr. Kay.

 

vote for max, cause its a fusion/union, and goes great with Daedalus' destruction effect

 

Very well.

 

2-2.

 

More votes would be nice.

[Max Darkness]

I can accept the first point, but I honestly can't see why you care about the picture. It fits the card, and the support, so I used it. Blame Mr. Kay.

 

People on this forum don't like existing monsters being re-named, unless used in a specific support card. It shows lack of imagination in a way.

[Dranzer]

I vote Max darkness because I find the effect more usefull and creative.

[Max Darkness]

Thanks Dranzer.

 

3-2.

[Max Darkness]

Bump for votes.

[Flash Flyer - Sakura]

Max Darkness GMV.

The effect is more creative and would be more useful

[Max Darkness]

Thanks Sakura.

 

4-2.

[Ice.]

Max's card seems OP'ed, in my opinion.

 

Caeda gmv.

[Andx]

Max's cards has way too many effects all on top of each other in my opinion; makes it overpowered. But if some of the effects were removed it wouldn't exactly be useful anymore. Caeda's seems much more balanced to me and for that reason Caeda's card gets my vote.

[Guest Caeda]

4-4 Tie.

 

Thanks Ice and Andx. <3

[Max Darkness]

Bump for votes.

[Exiro]

White Dragon Djinn is almost completely useless. The only nice thing about it is the art.

4,784/10

 

I like Envoy of the Ocean King. I can actually see it being played, especially because of Salvage. It wouldn't hurt to make it a tad better, for example by having the last card add a card to the hand instead of deck. Art is horrid, lol.

7,931/10

[Max Darkness]

Thanks Exiro.

 

5-4.

[Max Darkness]

Bump for votes.