Jump to content

Awesome new cards announced for Ancient Prophesy!


Recommended Posts

I saw my friend use Dustshoot on another friend, and in his hand were 3 Gift Cards and 1 Bad Reaction to Simochi.

 

He died 1 turn later.

 

Gift Card doesn't need to change unless they make some card that says "When you activate Gift Card you win." But that card would be banned not Gift Card so Gift Card is staying.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bad Reaction and Nurse Reficule have an obvious contribution to the game without Gift Card; namely, they provide reasonable burn with cards like Soul Taker, Upstart Goblin, and Eye of Truth.

 

Without Bad Reaction, Nurse Reficule, and cards that are already banworthy for reasons unrelated to Gift Card, what uses does Gift Card have?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Gift Card is awesome.

 

Top notch post. Deserves an award.

 

Also' date=' depend on type of dueling. Do you mean single or tag duels?

[/quote']

 

Tag duels aren't worth discussing.

 

Gift card works with Air Neos.

 

Unless he declares multiple attacks at the same time, it would have no net effect on the opponent's Life Points.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bad Reaction and Nurse Reficule have an obvious contribution to the game without Gift Card; namely' date=' they provide reasonable burn with cards like Soul Taker, Upstart Goblin, and Eye of Truth.

 

Without Bad Reaction, Nurse Reficule, and cards that are already banworthy for reasons unrelated to Gift Card, what uses does Gift Card have?

[/quote']

 

Are you trying to say that's a reason to ban it or just randomly saying that?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bad Reaction and Nurse Reficule have an obvious contribution to the game without Gift Card; namely' date=' they provide reasonable burn with cards like Soul Taker, Upstart Goblin, and Eye of Truth.

 

Without Bad Reaction, Nurse Reficule, and cards that are already banworthy for reasons unrelated to Gift Card, what uses does Gift Card have?

[/quote']

 

Are you trying to say that's a reason to ban it or just randomly saying that?

 

If you have two cards that are only a problem when used in tandem but are otherwise fine, but Card A is completely useless without Card B, then just ban Card A. If Card B is banned, Card A receives a de facto ban; however, the converse is not true. Thus, Card B is essentially banned either way, so why needlessly remove Card A from the game?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bad Reaction and Nurse Reficule have an obvious contribution to the game without Gift Card; namely' date=' they provide reasonable burn with cards like Soul Taker, Upstart Goblin, and Eye of Truth.

 

Without Bad Reaction, Nurse Reficule, and cards that are already banworthy for reasons unrelated to Gift Card, what uses does Gift Card have?

[/quote']

 

Are you trying to say that's a reason to ban it or just randomly saying that?

 

If you have two cards that are only a problem when used in tandem but are otherwise fine, but Card A is completely useless without Card B, then just ban Card A. If Card B is banned, Card A receives a de facto ban; however, the converse is not true. Thus, Card B is essentially banned either way, so why needlessly remove Card A from the game?

You meant that A would be banned either way and B didn't need to be banned, right?

 

I don't really think Gift Card and Simochi/Reficule are a problem.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bad Reaction and Nurse Reficule have an obvious contribution to the game without Gift Card; namely' date=' they provide reasonable burn with cards like Soul Taker, Upstart Goblin, and Eye of Truth.

 

Without Bad Reaction, Nurse Reficule, and cards that are already banworthy for reasons unrelated to Gift Card, what uses does Gift Card have?

[/quote']

 

Are you trying to say that's a reason to ban it or just randomly saying that?

 

If you have two cards that are only a problem when used in tandem but are otherwise fine, but Card A is completely useless without Card B, then just ban Card A. If Card B is banned, Card A receives a de facto ban; however, the converse is not true. Thus, Card B is essentially banned either way, so why needlessly remove Card A from the game?

 

That's only the case when neither card is the clear culprit in this combo. The only time Gift Card can be productive is when Simochi is on the field, hence Simochi is the culprit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...