Jump to content

The OFFICIAL "September 2008 Ban List Discussion Thread"


Recommended Posts

Alright, I know there are some other ban list threads, but this one can be used to discuss anything you think will "or should" happen.

 

Provide arguements for your suggestions so that people don't get angry.

 

I think Gladiator Beast Bestiari should be limited. Although it won't stop the Prisma + Test Tiger + Darius loop, I suppose it weakens Gladiators a little.

 

While it would be logical to ban Gyzarus, it's obvious that Konami will most likely keep it at 3, or limit it XD.

 

I also think that Disk Commander needs to go, as well as Crush Card Virus.

 

As for my prediction about what card will follow Monster Reborn and get its turn off the list, I'm going with Black Luster Soldier - Envoy of the Beginning, because Konami will be able to make a lot of money off of the Secret Rare IOC one and BLS-EOTB isn't the most broken card on the list, so it's not like the Metagame will be wrecked if it were to be limited. That's just my prediction, hate on it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Test Tiger limited

 

Ouch; didn't consider that one. I hate Gladiator Beasts, as they caused me to place 4th out of 22 in my first Hobby League. That loop with Darius and Prisma is ridiculous.

 

Does anyone think we'll finally get Reinforcements of the Army, Magical Stone Excavation, and Book of Moon back at 3?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

JD banned.

 

BLS will never be unbanned' date=' he was one of the original reasons behind the banlist.

[/quote']

 

Kazuki Takahashi said that no card will remain forbidden forever, lol.

 

Anyway, Judgment Dragon won't be banned because Lightsworn haven't made much of an impact yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

cheeselord, if that was the case, why did he go a whole list untouched? If you can remember, CED was banned first, not BLS. I honestly think the choices off the list are completely random. How else can you explain MR over Call? I disapprove the idea of BLS only because it will be the final tool to set Twilight through the roof. Its bad enough they have both freebies, DAD and JD, DO NOT GIVE THEM BLS!

 

I could care less what gets Banned, but something should happen to

 

DAD

JD

DISK

GYZ

HERI

 

Something does have to happen to these power houses.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I say it in every single Ban Thread. Heavy Storm Banned. MST at 2.

 

No card should be at 2, except maybe Volcanic Scattershot.

 

See, a card can't be good at 2, but bad at 3. It's 3 or 1, there's no need for a card to be semi-limited unless it somehow damages the game by using 3 copies of itself, as Volcanic Scattershot might have the potential to do.

 

What's anyone's idea about Deck Devastation Virus and Eradicator Epedemic Virus being hit?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I highly doubt that Lightsworn will get touched. They pretty much do have to make an impact in America before they matter. Sorry folks, that's just the way it is.

 

DAD should be banned. Gyzarus should be banned. Test Tiger should be limited. The list goes on. (JD should be banned too, I just doubt it.)

 

Also, lol at BLS ever coming back.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This thread's got a small amount of posts and it's already managed to fail on a few levels.

 

Kazuki Takahashi doesn't make the banlists.

 

KT made YGO. For all intents and purposes' date=' it is "his"; so, yes, he does make the banlists, or at least one of the guiding principles behind banlist management.

 

something should happen to

HERI

 

Prove it.

 

I say it in every single Ban Thread. Heavy Storm Banned.

 

Prove why HS should be banned.

 

 

I also see a good number of folks saying that Test Tiger either should be or will be punished; to the should-be kids, I say that there's no definitive evidence proving why it should be punished.

 

The will-be kids... I doubt their accuracy on this one solely because Lists have not had a habit of carrying over any OCG-TCG discrepancies.

 

Test Tiger will not be available as Slave-Tiger until long after the next list is finalized.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My predictions

 

Banned: Disk' date=' CCV, Gyzarus, Dark Magician of Chaos

Limited: JD, DAD, *Something unexplainable, such as Change of Heart*

Semi-ed: Nobleman of Crossout, CoSR

Unlimited: Mask of Darkness

[/quote']

Link to comment
Share on other sites

BAN: Dark Armed Dragon; Monster Reborn; Judgment Dragon; Jinzo; Heavy Storm; Disc Commander; Gladiator Beast Gyzarus; Crush Card Virus; Chimeratech Overdragon

 

LIMIT: Test Tiger; ANY Monarch; Destiny Draw; Breaker the Magical Warrior; Imperial Order

 

SEMI: Mystical Space Typhoon

 

UNLIMIT: Overload Fusion; Reinforcement of the Army

 

My thoughts. Take them or leave them. :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...