Casual VS Overpowered

[Ultimagamer]

I have some support ideas for the Egyptian god cards, but I'm not sure if they would be too broken or not, and I would like to refrain from placing them in the joke section. I'm not sure what to do for this. 

 

This includes giving them a field spell, giving the gods changed effects via a continuous spell, a quickplay spell card with effects depending the number of divine type monsters you control, and filling out the roster of disciple cards for all the gods and improving the original effect of Ra's Disciple.

[Phelphor, of the Deep]

You kidding? gods already got some support*: a field spell, some spells/other cards to support them. What we really need are NEW gods cards. 3 to tribute (going -2 even through you are guaranteed like 90% of the time to get that god on the field) their effect might been strong then but know they are not strong enough and the effort to get out is annoying to say the least.

[Ultimagamer]

You kidding? gods already got some support*: a field spell, some spells/other cards to support them. What we really need are NEW gods cards. 3 to tribute (going -2 even through you are guaranteed like 90% of the time to get that god on the field) their effect might been strong then but know they are not strong enough and the effort to get out is annoying to say the least.

 

I'm talking about retraining some of the old support, like mound of the bound creator, which is bad. making their cards better and give them much better alternatives to regular tribute summoning, making their tributes not big negs

[(GigaDrillBreaker)]

If it isn't intentionally broken, along the line of "pay 0 life; you win" or whatever, then it belongs in Advanced/Casual. The "overpowered" part of joke/overpowered is that they are so overpowered that it is a joke.

[Dova]

You kidding? gods already got some support*: a field spell, some spells/other cards to support them. What we really need are NEW gods cards. 3 to tribute (going -2 even through you are guaranteed like 90% of the time to get that god on the field) their effect might been strong then but know they are not strong enough and the effort to get out is annoying to say the least.

 

Their question is where they would post something like this, and a comment like this is not helpful.

 

I have some support ideas for the Egyptian god cards, but I'm not sure if they would be too broken or not, and I would like to refrain from placing them in the joke section. I'm not sure what to do for this. 

 

This includes giving them a field spell, giving the gods changed effects via a continuous spell, a quickplay spell card with effects depending the number of divine type monsters you control, and filling out the roster of disciple cards for all the gods and improving the original effect of Ra's Disciple.

 

 

I actually made Divine-Beast support earlier. Really, you shouldn't be making broken support intentionally unless you want to put it into the Jokes and OP section. If you don't want it to be broken, then yeah, post it into the casual section for people to comment on and tell you how to improve it if they are broken. I would suggest not making actual DIVINE monsters, but support for them and Divine-Beast should be fine.

[Ultimagamer]

If it isn't intentionally broken, along the line of "pay 0 life; you win" or whatever, then it belongs in Advanced/Casual. The "overpowered" part of joke/overpowered is that they are so overpowered that it is a joke.

 

I actually made Divine-Beast support earlier. Really, you shouldn't be making broken support intentionally unless you want to put it into the Jokes and OP section. If you don't want it to be broken, then yeah, post it into the casual section for people to comment on and tell you how to improve it if they are broken. I would suggest not making actual DIVINE monsters, but support for them and Divine-Beast should be fine.

 

ah ok, I see what you guys mean. I had some ideas for the egyptian god cards, but I wasn't sure if I made it too good or not. Not intentionally way too overpowered or anything along those lines, but testing to see what would be the most beneficial to the set of cards, making them a fun playable deck, somewhat along the lines of the sacred beast support, where they got a lonefire blossom like card and a pot of greed field spell

 

If you guys wanna check it out, heres the post with all the support, along with the original gods

 

https://forum.yugiohcardmaker.net/topic/371640-egyptian-gods-support/

 

I would always love a review if you guys have the time