[Leaderboard] Tori Vs. Yuuko/Yuuji (Vote imo)

[towitori]

Rules:
-All Leaderboard rules apply.
-Best of 3 votes wins
-All voters must elaborate on their votes.
-Both contestants have the right to refuse votes, but must explain why they don't accept it.
-Written cards only for anonymity.
-Cards must be PM'd to me.
-In case a downtime happens, the deadlines may be extended.

Rewards:
-The winner gets a rep from the loser.
-All voters get a rep for voting.

Deadlines:
-Contestants have 48 hours to submit their entries.
-The contest ends after it starts in 3 days. After that, next vote wins.

Requirement:
Fish Support

 

Card A:

Superancient Lore

Spell / Normal

Discard 1 card: Special Summon 4 Level 4 or lower Fish-Type monsters from your Deck in face-up Defense Position but their effects are negated and you cannot Special Summon any other monsters the turn you activate this card, except WATER monsters. During the End Phase, banish all monsters Special Summoned by this card.

 

Card B:

Abyss Kraken
Level 3 / WATER
Aqua / Pendulum / Effect

Scale: 2 / 2
ATK: 500 DEF: 1900
PE: Once per turn, when a Fish, Sea Serpent, or Aqua-Type monster you control is banished: You can draw 1 card. (The banished monster(s) must be Fish, Sea Serpent, or Aqua-Type even after being banished to activate and resolve this effect.)
ME: When this card is Normal Summoned: You can send 1 Fish, Sea Serpent, or Aqua-Type monster from your Deck to the Graveyard, and if you do, change this card to face-up Defense Position. If this card is Special Summoned: You can banish it to add 1 Fish, Sea Serpent, or Aqua-Type monster from your Deck to your hand, except "Abyss Kraken". You can only use this effect of "Abyss Kraken" once per turn.

[ÆƵ–]

Bork Bork. Let's make some fish support

[towitori]

Okie

[towitori]

Open again

[Abdelrahman]

I'm in so let's make a Rank 4 Deck support.

[towitori]

I'm in so let's make a Rank 4 Deck support.

Sorry m8 Yuuji already PM'd me before for that Fish Support card (also cause I already have the fish card)

[Blake]

Card C.

 

Card A is just pseudo-Hana Awase for 4 or lower Fish, designed in a way to reflect Superancient Deepsea King Coelecanth, and... that's just not a funking fair design. You either get too much value out of this card existing or too little.

 

Oh, and it's a 1.5 card double bahamaut double treatoad.

 

At least, I assume all this, based on name/design... Because it doesn't specify where the Fish come from, leaving it incapable of being judged.

 

Card B is an arma knight with upsides for running Beautunal Princess. Because... reasons? Nimbles, Coelecant setup ala Star Seraph Scepter/Lavalval Chain, 

 

Only fish really matters, because it's worse than Swap Frog for Aqua/Sea Serpent hardly exists, but the general point remains.

 

And then it has an effect that rewards you for PSing it (with more princess) or any of an absurd number of cards. And it doesn't even have to be PS, just extra value from it.

 

But... it lacks a Pendulum Scale. Again making it unable to be fully covered.

 

Both cards are overkill in design, and they both lack defining characteristics needed to judge them, so neither deserve to win.

 

I am also disappointed in one of the posters for basically disregarding anonymity while I talked about one card at a time. Be more sportsmanlike.

[Blake]

Apologies to Striker, but I'm going to have to lock this.

 

When submitting cards to a contest, you are standing upon a stage.

 

http://i.imgur.com/9jwgzqy.png

 

This is the initial state of the cards submitted. It has been changed since my post last night, with both participants editing their cards. The picture was taken by one of the participants, so I have rehosted it.

 

The fact that the two of you submitted an unfinished product is on you two. If you set a precedent of being able to touch up a card mid-contest, everyone has to have that right.

 

If you turn in a school paper that is unfinished, you lose points. I don't run this contest circuit, but I would encourage a punihsment of some sort for this unsportsmanlike conduct, on behalf of the rest of the people involved in the Leaderboard.

 

And I would count this as a wash, not as Card C, considering how the rules tell me that 2 Card Cs means that you get a win and a loss. Again, not my governing area, so up to Striker.

 

Lock.