Jump to content

Yu-Gi-Oh! Rulings Questions


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 16.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Trap Eater VS Royal Opression/Summon Limit/Macro Cosmos

RO and Macro lose. Summon limit probably loses but i'm not sure.

According to wikia rulings, if Macro is on the field, Trap Eater can't be summoned because the Trap can't be sent to the Graveyard. Sending Macro to the Graveyard for Trap eater's effect isn't possible because Trap Eater doesn't stop the effect of the trap before sending it to the Graveyard.

Royal Oppression loses to Trap Eater, but I'm not too sure about Summon Limit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow that's a retarded ruling. By that logic crystal abundance can't destroy macro because it says "send all cards to the graveyard". But I guess it's official.

 

Crystal Abundance can't be activated while Macro Cosmos is on the field either.

 

You're right, because you can't pay the cost to activate it... let's say norleras then.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow that's a retarded ruling. By that logic crystal abundance can't destroy macro because it says "send all cards to the graveyard". But I guess it's official.

 

Crystal Abundance can't be activated while Macro Cosmos is on the field either.

 

You're right' date=' because you can't pay the cost to activate it... let's say norleras then.

[/quote']

 

Apparently the ruling for Norleras says that you can't activate Norleras if your opponent controls a Protector of the Sanctuary because it causes you to draw a card, even though that's part of the effect. That's because drawing a card and sending all the cards to the graveyard happen at the same time. Since PotS can stop Norleras because it stops part of the effect, I figure using Macro to stop the sending cards to the Graveyard would work similarly. There are no specific rulings against that on the Norleras page though, so I'm not sure.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If Dark Resonator is face down and is attacked, does dark resonator effect activate or no. I checked both Yugioh Wikia and Netrep for the ruling and both don't say anything on Dark Resonator.

 

Dark Resonator's effect: This card isn't destroyed by battle, once per turn.

 

The Tourny I went to said Dark Resonator is still destoyed but when I come to think of it I say they are wrong. Spirit reaper isn't destroyed when attacked face down, this is similar but only once.

 

Note: the monster attacking doesn't have any effect stopping powers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If Dark Resonator is face down and is attacked' date=' does dark resonator effect activate or no. I checked both Yugioh Wikia and Netrep for the ruling and both don't say anything on Dark Resonator.

 

Dark Resonator's effect: This card isn't destroyed by battle, once per turn.

 

The Tourny I went to said Dark Resonator is still destoyed but when I come to think of it I say they are wrong. Spirit reaper isn't destroyed when attacked face down, this is similar but only once.

 

Note: the monster attacking doesn't have any effect stopping powers.

[/quote']

 

Dark Resonator's effect is Continuous and therefore doesn't activate.

Also, continuous effects are active when the monster is flipped face-up by battle, so it isn't destroyed when attacked while face-down.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if only 1 oppression' date=' it can be offered for TE. If you did not summon more than twice that turn, you can TE Summon limit. If more than 1 macro is face up, you can not TE macro.

[/quote']

 

http://www.yugioh-card.com/en/gameplay/rulings/CRMS_sneak_ruling.pdf

 

You officially can't send Macro to the Graveyard for Trap Eater.

 

corrected and thanks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can I Special Summon Phantom Dragon during my opponent's turn?

 

And does Phantom Dragon's effect of blocking 2 Monster Zone only works when he is face-up on the field?

 

Sorry' date=' kinda new using Phantom Dragon...

[/quote']

 

Yes, yes and no point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...