Yu-Gi-Oh! Rulings Questions

[darkwolf777]

Solemn is Judgment, Warning is Warning.

 

No one ever thinks of Solemn Wishes, but what Lapras says is correct.  When someone says "Solemn", they generally mean "Solemn Judgment".  People will say "Warning" if they mean "Solemn Warning".

[Zeppeli Gyro Supreme]

No one ever thinks of Solemn Wishes, but what Lapras says is correct.  When someone says "Solemn", they generally mean "Solemn Judgment".  People will say "Warning" if they mean "Solemn Warning".

There's a lot of Solemn cards, but nobody really uses the others. So we all ignore them in favor of laziness.

[Cute Rotten Yoshika]

There's a lot of Solemn cards, but nobody really uses the others. So we all ignore them in favor of laziness.

 

theres 4 but wishes and aesir might as well not exist given how often theyre used.

[Zazubat]

"You can target 1 Defense Position monster you opponent control; change it to face-up Attack Position, and if you do it, negate it’s effect, also that card’s ATK becomes half of it’s original ATK until your opponent’s next End Phase."

 

From my card, I want to write it so only the "also" effect is until the End Phase, but I am not sure if what I'm writing is applies to all of it, or only the last part. I think its the former though, so I don't know how to write it. Can anybody help? Also, there's a once per turn and monster specific clause there somewhere, just not important.

Reposting since people ignored.

[newhat]

You can rewrite it as

 

You can target 1 Defense Position monster your opponent controls; change it to face-up Attack Position, and if you do, negate its effects, also until your opponent's next End Phase, its ATK becomes half its original ATK.

[Zazubat]

You can rewrite it as

That would work I suppose, thanks.

[Aix]

Can I use Special Summon Exodius when I have an Extra Deck monster in my Graveyard?

[evilfusion]

Can I use Special Summon Exodius when I have an Extra Deck monster in my Graveyard?

 

I would say yes, because you returned a monster from the Grave to the Deck. Exodius does not specify "Main Deck", and I expect it to work the same as Pot of Avarice (although Avarice is an effect, not a Summon Condition).

 

There doesn't seem to be a ruling right now that says either way, other than you must have at least 1 monster in your Grave to SS it.

[Zeppeli Gyro Supreme]

I have seen a number of tournament players use it (to make Gustaph Max, but these decks don't usually make it past regionals, but that's beside the point), and there has been no mention of such a ruling where it can't be summoned if you have Extra Deck monsters.

[ihop]

Avarice is an effect and not a cost, to fulfill a cost you need to meet all the conditions, for example you could technically Beckoning Light back a Synchro to the extra, but you can't bounce a Synchro for Birdman. Honestly I think you can still summon it but the Extra Deck cards in the grave would stay there.

[Aix]

Is this worded right? I want the cards banished for as long as the card is face-up on the field. >_

[Zazubat]

Is this worded right? I want the cards banished for as long as the card is face-up on the field. >_< Don't want to lose another contest due to poor wording.

"while this card remains face-up on the field" is how I would word it, but that might be an old way of writing it, I don't see any faults with the wording otherwise.

[Kyng's Old Account]

Probably a noobish question, but if I'm using them I should be sure on this: I am right in saying that Ignoble Knight of Black Laundsallyn cannot tribute itself for its own effect?

[Zazubat]

Probably a noobish question, but if I'm using them I should be sure on this: I am right in saying that Ignoble Knight of Black Laundsallyn cannot tribute itself for its own effect?

No, it can Tribute itself. Only if it said "an other"/this card must be face-up on the field" or something like that.

[Coffee Black]

This is mainly a Bottomless Trap Hole question.

 

I'm playing Heroes vs a Harpie player. My field is a Prisma and a set Super Poly. Their field is a set BTH and the Hunting Ground field spell. They normal summon Harpie Dancer, trigger Hunting Ground, targeting my set card. I chain Super Poly, and use both monsters for Great Tornado. Afterwards, my opponent uses BTH. My question is can BTH be used at that time? I know Hunting Ground missed, but maybe it resolves without effect? If I'm right along those lines, then I think BTH can't be activated. But if I'm wrong, can I get a quick example of when a card resolving without effect would be significant? Thanks

[ihop]

This is mainly a Bottomless Trap Hole question.

 

I'm playing Heroes vs a Harpie player. My field is a Prisma and a set Super Poly. Their field is a set BTH and the Hunting Ground field spell. They normal summon Harpie Dancer, trigger Hunting Ground, targeting my set card. I chain Super Poly, and use both monsters for Great Tornado. Afterwards, my opponent uses BTH. My question is can BTH be used at that time? I know Hunting Ground missed, but maybe it resolves without effect? If I'm right along those lines, then I think BTH can't be activated. But if I'm wrong, can I get a quick example of when a card resolving without effect would be significant? Thanks

 

Card's don't leave the field mid-chain so the Hunting Ground would still then destroy the Super Poly before it's sent to the grave, so I believe it would miss timing, yes.

[Aix]

Say Player A has Fire King Beast Yaksha and Hazy Flame Cerberus and Player B Normal Summons Tour Guide and Special Summons Tour Bus, then, Player A activates his Torrential Tribute, so how would the chains work? (I mean with three monsters on the field that have an effect that triggers upon being destroyed and/or sent to the Graveyard, who resolves first and whatnot.)

[Zazubat]

Say Player A has Fire King Beast Yaksha and Hazy Flame Cerberus and Player B Normal Summons Tour Guide and Special Summons Tour Bus, then, Player A activates his Torrential Tribute, so how would the chains work? (I mean with three monsters on the field that have an effect that triggers upon being destroyed and/or sent to the Graveyard, who resolves first and whatnot.)

Always follow this:

1. Turn Player's Mandatory Effects
2. Non-Turn Player's Mandatory Effects
3. Turn Player's Optional Effects
4. Non-Turn Player's Optional Effects

This means that it's Tour as Chain Link 1 and then your opponent gets to choose which order they want to activate either Yaksha or Cerberus in as Chain Link 2 and 3.

[Miror B]

This means that it's Tour as Chain Link 1 and then your opponent gets to choose which order they want to activate either Yaksha or Cerberus in as Chain Link 2 and 3.

Almost.

CL1: TGU

CL2: Torrential

Resolve

CL2: Everything ont he field dies

CL1: Monster is summoned

NOW Fire Kings start a chain by the order you gave.

[Zazubat]

Oh oops, never mind, I didn't notice he also said Tour Guide.

[Brinolovania]

Can Tiger King activate its effect during both turns? I cba to call an admin on this guy, so I'm probably gonna lose, but meh.

[darkwolf777]

Can Tiger King activate its effect during both turns? I cba to call an admin on this guy, so I'm probably gonna lose, but meh.

 

Once per turn: You can detach 1 Xyz Material from this card; negate the effects of all face-up Effect Monster currently on the field, except Beast-Warrior-Type, until the end of your opponent's turn

 

This is an Ignition Effect.  It can only be activated during your own turn.

[Brinolovania]

Once per turn: You can detach 1 Xyz Material from this card; negate the effects of all face-up Effect Monster currently on the field, except Beast-Warrior-Type, until the end of your opponent's turn

 

This is an Ignition Effect.  It can only be activated during your own turn.

Thought so...just wanted to be sure I wasn't missing something. Thanks.

[Phantasy Dreamz]

If I summon TWO monsters at once with >1500 ATK and my opponent Bottomless them, I chained it with Lance

 

Does Bottomless just gets negated entirely since it states that "Destroy that monster(s)"?

 

Or does it still destroy the monster that didn't get Lance?

[Cute Rotten Yoshika]

the monster not targetted by lance will be destroyed.