Jump to content

Yu-Gi-Oh! Rulings Questions


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 16.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Question.

 

I play Creature Swap while controlling 2 monsters.

My opponent has 1 monster.

 

He chains to Creature Swap with Enemy Controller taking control of a face-up monster on my field.

 

What happens to Creature Swap?

Does it resolve?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Question.

 

I play Creature Swap while controlling 2 monsters.

My opponent has 1 monster.

 

He chains to Creature Swap with Enemy Controller taking control of a face-up monster on my field.

 

What happens to Creature Swap?

Does it resolve?

 

Creature Swap doesn't target. He'll gain control of your monster, then each of you will have one monster. They'll get Swapped I believe.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Question.

 

I play Creature Swap while controlling 2 monsters.

My opponent has 1 monster.

 

He chains to Creature Swap with Enemy Controller taking control of a face-up monster on my field.

 

What happens to Creature Swap?

Does it resolve?

 

Creature Swap doesn't target. He'll gain control of your monster' date=' then each of you will have one monster. They'll get Swapped I believe.

[/quote']

 

If it's true, then I guessed correctly.

Just watched a duel between my cousin and a friend and this happened.

So I called the most logical thing that would happen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 Substitoad

3 Submarine Frog

3 Dupe Frog

3 Swap Frog

3 Poison Draw Frog

3 Unifrog

3 Des Frog

2 Flip Flop Frog

2 Ronintoadin

-25-

 

3 Moray

2 Hand Des

3 Into the Void

2 Salvage

1 One for One

1 Foolish

3 Mass Driver

-15-

 

basic' date=' very basic... majority of the deck comes common... shouldnt cost more than 20.

[/quote']

 

Moray and Void cost £4 each. Can you have a Frog FTK that doesn't run them?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If my Koa'ki Meiru Crusader hits a 1900 ATK monster and they both die' date=' I get his effect, according to the wiki.

So, if my Crusader hits Ryko and ryko kills it, do i still get it's return a KM card effect?

[/quote']

 

Crusader's effect activates "When it destroys a monster by battle". This does not include "and is sent to the Graveyard". Therefore, its effect will activate immediately after damage calculation. This is also the same time Ryko would activate. This two effects should then chain together.

 

Ryko, being the Flip effect, is Mandatory (even though it says you CAN destroy a card, being a FLIP effect by nature makes it mandatory). Crusader's effect is optional.

 

Therefore...

 

Chain Link 1: Ryko, Lightsworn Hunter (Since Ryko's effect targets, the target is chosen at this time)

Chain Link 2: Koa'ki Meiru Crusader.

 

Resolving...

 

Chain Link 2: Koa'ki Meiru Crusader adds 1 "Koa'ki Meiru" card from the Graveyard to the Hand.

Chain Link 1: If previously chosen to destroy a card, Ryko will destroy it here. Regardless if chosen to destroy or not, Ryko sends 3 cards from the deck to the Graveyard.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If there are 2 Light & Dark Dragon on the field (your's and opponents) and a Spell is activated what happens?

 

Depending on who activated the spell. The opponent's LADD activates to negate the spell (due to opponent getting priority to chain' date=' I believe), then the activator's LADD activates, negating the first LADD's effect. The Spell resolves.

[/quote']

 

While i'm not too sure on the scenario, it would make more sense that both LADDs activate simultaneously to negate the same Spell card. One will successfully negate it while the other one does not. The one that failed to negate it would not have its ATK/DEF decreased by 500. Turn Player's LADD would be lowest in the chain.

 

Chain Link 1 - Spell Card

Chain Link 2 - Turn Player's LADD. (negating Spell Card)

Chain Link 3 - Opponent's LADD. (negating Spell Card)

 

Resolving...

 

Chain Link 3 - Opponent's LADD negates Spell Card and loses 500 ATK/DEF

Chain Link 2 - Turn Player's LADD cannot negate the already negated card and fizzles.

Chain Link 1 - Spell Card is negated.

 

Will test sometime to check it out as i'm not too sure on it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1.] You can Solemn a Solemn

2.] You can negate a Flip Summon with Book of Moon

3.] You can use Urgent Tuning on you own turn

4.] If you destroy Neo Space during the End Phase, any Neos fusions will remain on the field

5.] BEWD < DM

 

Please answer with 'yes' or 'no', and a quick explaination.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1] Yes. Spell Speed 3 is not slower than Spell Speed 3, why not?

2] No. Flipping back down isn't negating anything, the Summon was completed before you could even use Book.

3] Yes, the card doesn't argue.

4] I'm sure this depends on a lot of factors... but most the time I assume it doesn't work. Just destroy it when they declare the end of the battle phase/main phase 2.

5] BEWD is much better. It has White Stone, Trade-In and REDRUM.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1.] You can Solemn a Solemn

 

Yes' date=' because Solemn A is Spell Speed 3 since it is a Counter Trap and Solemn B is also Spell Speed 3 and is a Counter Trap. They're fast enough to chain to each other.

 

2.] You can negate a Flip Summon with Book of Moon

 

No. The monster would have to be successfully face-up and summoned in order for it to be a valid target for Book of Moon. Also, Book of Moon does not negate Summons =/

 

3.] You can use Urgent Tuning on you own turn

 

Yes. Both players can have Battle Phases. It is not restricted to your opponent's Battle Phase.

 

4.] If you destroy Neo Space during the End Phase' date=' any Neos fusions will remain on the field

[/quote']

 

No, Neo-Space prevents gives them the option of not being activated. If it is removed during the End Phase, they must then activate.

 

5.] BEWD < DM

 

No, BEWD is better. I wish DM could be better.

 

Edit: Beaten to it it seems.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stardust Dragon can negate Shooting Star Dragon' date=' right?

[/quote']

 

Yes, Stardust Dragon can negate and destroy Shooting Star Dragon when it tries to negate and destroy a card, provided the card Shooting Star Dragon is negating and destroying is on the field (due to the "effect that destroy a card(s) on the field" clause of Stardust Dragon).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Special Summons are done one at a time, unless using an effect that simultaneously Special Summons multiple monsters (Return from the Different Dimension, Gottom's Emergency Call, etc). You pay the cost for one Fortress and Special Summon it. Then you can pay the cost for the second.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...