Yu-Gi-Oh! Rulings Questions

[Expelsword]

Alright, I had that strategy going in, but it turned out to not matter, thanks

[Expelsword]

Does Necrovalley stop Stardust Dragon?

[-Griffin]

No. Stardust doesn't target

[werewolfjedi]

No. Stardust doesn't target

 

doesn't stardust also get around it because the effect orignates in the grave?

 

anyway, thunder king ryo, he can't stop fusion summons when you do it with spells, correct?

just thinking of using him a FL deck, and want to make sure. (EHAZ user over here is ticking me off. course, he ran into light with it's effect, so, lol.)

[-Griffin]

No. Stardust doesn't target

 

doesn't stardust also get around it because the effect orignates in the grave?

 

No' date=' just because it doesn't target. Where it activates means nothing.[/b']

 

anyway, thunder king ryo, he can't stop fusion summons when you do it with spells, correct?

just thinking of using him a FL deck, and want to make sure. (EHAZ user over here is ticking me off. course, he ran into light with it's effect, so, lol.)

 

Correct. RO can only stop contact fusions.

[Expelsword]

Solemn cannot negate an active Royal Oppression right?

[darkwolf777]

Solemn cannot negate an active Royal Oppression right?

 

Solemn Judgment only negates the activation of cards (playing them face-up), not the activation of their effects. Solemn Judgment cannot negate an already face-up Continuous Spell/Trap/Field cards that have an effect that activates.

 

The only card that can "negate and destroy" an already face-up Royal Oppression when it activates (by chaining to that activation) to my knowledge is Stardust Dragon/Assault Mode.

[Cypress]

if two of my monsters are destroyed, and both their mandatory effects activate, can i choose in which order they resolve?

[darkwolf777]

if two of my monsters are destroyed' date=' and both their mandatory effects activate, can i choose in which order they resolve?

[/quote']

 

Well, if they are both activating, then you will need to announce which is Chain Link 1 and which is Chain Link 2, so that your opponent can respond with an appropriate Chain Link 3 (if he wants to add to the chain).

 

But yes, you get to choose which order they resolve.

[Zauls]

If you have Phoenixian Cluster Amaryllis in your Grave and an Oppression on the field and you activate it's effect and negate the Special Summon with Oppression, does Cluster's effect activate dealing burn damage?

[darkwolf777]

If you have Phoenixian Cluster Amaryllis in your Grave and an Oppression on the field and you activate it's effect and negate the Special Summon with Oppression' date=' does Cluster's effect activate dealing burn damage?

[/quote']

 

No, it does not.

 

The Trigger is "When this card you control is destroyed and sent to the Graveyard". You do not control Phoenixian Cluster Amaryllis until it is successfully Summoned. Therefore, if its summon is negated, then you did not control it when it was destroyed.

[Cypress]

book of life SS reaper?

[darkwolf777]

book of life SS reaper?

 

You can. Spirit Reaper only gets destroyed by its own effect if it was targeted while face-up on the field.

[Captain Lawless]

When I have a monster that must attack when possible, such as Berserk Gorillaz or a Karakuri monster,

does it only have to attack when I go into my battle phase?

So can't I Just skip my battle phase and end after my Main Phase 1?

Meaning they must attack only if I decide to go into the battle phase?

[-Griffin]

B-Gorillaz forces you to enter the Battle Phase.

There are no rulings on Karakuri, but I'd expect the same one.

[darkwolf777]

When I have a monster that must attack when possible' date=' such as Berserk Gorillaz or a Karakuri monster,

does it only have to attack when I go into my battle phase?

So can't I Just skip my battle phase and end after my Main Phase 1?

Meaning they must attack only if I decide to go into the battle phase?

[/quote']

 

If a monster "must attack", then you must have your Battle Phase. You cannot choose to skip it.

[evilfusion]

Berserk Gorilla, Savage Colosseum and Battle Mania have the same sort of condition. If you CAN enter your Battle Phase, you must. If they CAN attack, they must.

[~Gigatic_Millenia~]

Berserk Gorilla' date=' Savage Colosseum and Battle Mania have the same sort of condition. If you CAN enter your Battle Phase, you must. If they CAN attack, they must.

[/quote']

extremely bad card while faced with Exxod.

[賢狼ホロ]

If you target Spririt Reaper with Caius, is Spirit Reaper sent to the Graveyard or removed from play? Is the damage inflicted?

 

What cards can cancel out the destruction effect of Future Fusion? Seems that all anti-spell cards negates the activation, while I only want to negate 1 effect. : /

[-Griffin]

If you target Spririt Reaper with Caius' date=' is Spirit Reaper sent to the Graveyard or removed from play? Is the damage inflicted?

[/quote']

 

RFG'd. Damage done.

[darkwolf777]

What cards can cancel out the destruction effect of Future Fusion? Seems that all anti-spell cards negates the activation' date=' while I only want to negate 1 effect. : /

[/quote']

 

Well, the "When this card is removed from the field, destroy that monster" is a Continuous Effect of Future Fusion. It cannot be chained to when it is removed from the field. You would have to protect it prior to or chain to the effect which would destroy/remove Future Fusion.

 

Your options would be either to protect it from destruction (with a card like Card Guard), having a card effect that can Continuously negates Spell Card Effects (Spell Canceller), an effect that temporarily removes the Fusion Monster from play so that it is not targeted by Future Fusion anymore (Interdimentional Matter Transporter, Dimensionhole), or by flipping the targeted Fusion Monster face-down (Book of Moon).

[evilfusion]

Spirit Reaper's self-destruct effect occurs AFTER the effect resolves. So cards that remove SR from the field work on it and won't trigger that effect. Cards like Brain Control will successfully steal it, then promptly kill it afterwards.

[Captain Lawless]

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Karakuri_Disassembling_Manual

I use Book of Moon on any of my Karakuri, does Manual get a counter?

I'd think so, but someone wanted to debate it didn't.

[burnpsy]

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Karakuri_Disassembling_Manual

I use Book of Moon on any of my Karakuri' date=' does Manual get a counter?

I'd think so, but someone wanted to debate it didn't.

[/quote']

 

It works with Morphtronic Map, so it works with that.

[.Gideon.]

If colossal is destroyed by battle and resummoned by its eff while Black Garden is face-up, Black garden won't halve its ATk nor SS a token right ?