Yu-Gi-Oh! Rulings Questions

[-Griffin]

If I Summon Cyber Valley and try to use the second effect, would it be fizzled by BoM?

[Professional Duelist]

If something flips Cyber Valley down, it effect resolves.

 

If something flips target monster down, it's effect fizzles.

[Fraz]

I have Stardust/Assault out' date=' and attack his facedown GB

He uses Hedge Guard

I negate

He tries to War Chariot

 

I argued since either:

You need a faceup GB to use it, and if I tribute Stardust, the attack is negated and he never is faceup

 

If your GB is faceup that means its after damage calculation and it is destroyed, so you control NO GBs

 

Can he activate War Chariot like that?

[/quote']

Hedge Guard is during damage calc so the GB is face up on the field. You are able to chariot while there is a face up glad beast on field so stardust is negated and monster is not destroyed by battle. Monster is considered to have battled this turn and is able to tag out. Assault was destroyed while in grave so its effect cannot activate to revive a stardust.

[darkwolf777]

I argued since either:

You need a faceup GB to use it' date=' and if I tribute Stardust, the attack is negated and he never is faceup

[/quote']

 

Battle goes like~

 

1) Attack is Declared

2) Attack Declaration is successful/unsuccessful

3) If successful, opponent's monster (if face-down) is flipped face-up

4) Ability to activate cards during the Damage Step begins here (Honest, Limiter Removal, etc)

5) Damage Calculation Occurs (this is where Hedge Guard is activated in)

 

By Step 3, his GB is already face-up. If it reached Step 3, the monster being attacked would be face-up regardless of what happens between then and Damage Calculation, even if the Attacker is removed and Damage Calculation never happens.

[-Griffin]

If something flips Cyber Valley down' date=' it effect resolves.

 

If something flips target monster down, it's effect fizzles.

[/quote']

 

And if Valley is removed from the field by, for example, Compulsory Evac?

[darkwolf777]

If something flips Cyber Valley down' date=' it effect resolves.

 

If something flips target monster down, it's effect fizzles.

[/quote']

 

And if Valley is removed from the field by, for example, Compulsory Evac?

 

Cyber Valley's effect states: You can remove from play this card and 1 face-up monster you control, and draw 2 cards.

 

Since its not a cost, everything must stay valid when resolving.

 

For Cyber Valley, it just simply needs to be on the field. "This card" has no conditions to it and it is still considered "This Card" whether it is face-up or face-down on the field.

 

For the 1 Face-Up Monster, that monster must stay face-up when resolving. If it is no longer Face-Up, it is no longer a valid target and the effect fails.

 

If either monster is removed from the field, the effect will fail.

 

Edit: If it helps to mention, Cyber Valley targets. It targets itself and it targets 1 Face-Up Monster on your side of the field. Whether Cyber Valley is face-up or face-down, it is a valid target. The other card is only a valid target if it is face-up.

[-Griffin]

Thought so, thanks for confirming.

[Expelsword]

I argued since either:

You need a faceup GB to use it' date=' and if I tribute Stardust, the attack is negated and he never is faceup

[/quote']

 

Battle goes like~

 

1) Attack is Declared

2) Attack Declaration is successful/unsuccessful

3) If successful, opponent's monster (if face-down) is flipped face-up

4) Ability to activate cards during the Damage Step begins here (Honest, Limiter Removal, etc)

5) Damage Calculation Occurs (this is where Hedge Guard is activated in)

 

By Step 3, his GB is already face-up. If it reached Step 3, the monster being attacked would be face-up regardless of what happens between then and Damage Calculation, even if the Attacker is removed and Damage Calculation never happens.

 

So he COULD... now I feel bad...

[BDKMRV]

Lol Stardust/AM is still beast!

[Sephiroth_The_Legend]

If i activate Offerings to the Snake Deity, do i have to a control a face-up reptile, or is similar to Icarus where the monster can be face-down.

I figure it might be different because it says destroy and not tribute...

[evilfusion]

It has to be faceup because it targets a reptile to destroy. If it's facedown, Offerings can't tell it's a Reptile. You can Tribute facedown type-specific cards because the player's paying a cost before the effect does anything.

[darkwolf777]

If i activate Offerings to the Snake Deity' date=' do i have to a control a face-up reptile, or is similar to Icarus where the monster can be face-down.

I figure it might be different because it says destroy and not tribute...

[/quote']

 

Correct, Offering to the Snake Deity targets 1 Reptile-Type monster on your side of the field. Face-down monsters have no declared type and are not valid targets.

 

If a card effect like Book of Moon is chained so that your Reptile-Type monster is flipped face-down, so that its type can no longer be determined, then Offering to the Snake Deity will fizzle.

[Phantasy Dreamz]

-When a monster with ? ATK is summoned, say Great Maju for example, and the ATK WILL be greater than 1500, can it be Bottomless? Or will it's ATK be caculated after it's been summoned already?

 

-People told me that monsters like Sangan/Witch can't bring monsters from your Deck with ? ATK/DEF, so is it true? I thought those kinds of monsters are treated as 0 attackers.

o.0"

[-Griffin]

-When a monster with ? ATK is summoned' date=' say Great Maju for example, and the ATK WILL be greater than 1500, can it be Bottomless? Or will it's ATK be caculated after it's been summoned already?

 

-People told me that monsters like Sangan/Witch can't bring monsters from your Deck with ? ATK/DEF, so is it true? I thought those kinds of monsters are treated as 0 attackers.

o.0"

[/quote']

 

-When you're activating Bottomless, the Summon is already successful and ? ATK monsters can be targeted if they would be over 1500.

 

-That is true. ? ATK is ? ATK, not 0 or anything else. It also means that ? is not higher than any number or lower than any number, so it isn't below 500 for Debris, as an example.

[Phantasy Dreamz]

-When a monster with ? ATK is summoned' date=' say Great Maju for example, and the ATK WILL be greater than 1500, can it be Bottomless? Or will it's ATK be caculated after it's been summoned already?

 

-People told me that monsters like Sangan/Witch can't bring monsters from your Deck with ? ATK/DEF, so is it true? I thought those kinds of monsters are treated as 0 attackers.

o.0"

[/quote']

 

-When you're activating Bottomless, the Summon is already successful and ? ATK monsters can be targeted if they would be over 1500.

 

-That is true. ? ATK is ? ATK, not 0 or anything else. It also means that ? is not higher than any number or lower than any number, so it isn't below 500 for Debris, as an example.

 

Ahhh I see. Many thanks.

 

-So when a monster is summoned from my graveyard, and I have Card of Safe Return, but the summon was negated (ex. Black Horn), do I still get to draw?

[-Griffin]

-When a monster with ? ATK is summoned' date=' say Great Maju for example, and the ATK WILL be greater than 1500, can it be Bottomless? Or will it's ATK be caculated after it's been summoned already?

 

-People told me that monsters like Sangan/Witch can't bring monsters from your Deck with ? ATK/DEF, so is it true? I thought those kinds of monsters are treated as 0 attackers.

o.0"

[/quote']

 

-When you're activating Bottomless, the Summon is already successful and ? ATK monsters can be targeted if they would be over 1500.

 

-That is true. ? ATK is ? ATK, not 0 or anything else. It also means that ? is not higher than any number or lower than any number, so it isn't below 500 for Debris, as an example.

 

Ahhh I see. Many thanks.

 

-So when a monster is summoned from my graveyard, and I have Card of Safe Return, but the summon was negated (ex. Black Horn), do I still get to draw?

 

Nope. A negated Summon never happened.

[Phantasy Dreamz]

Thanks, again.

I'll have more questions later. :)

[Professional Duelist]

If something flips Cyber Valley down' date=' it effect resolves.

 

If something flips target monster down, it's effect fizzles.

[/quote']

 

And if Valley is removed from the field by, for example, Compulsory Evac?

 

Cyber Valley's effect states: You can remove from play this card and 1 face-up monster you control, and draw 2 cards.

 

Since its not a cost, everything must stay valid when resolving.

 

For Cyber Valley, it just simply needs to be on the field. "This card" has no conditions to it and it is still considered "This Card" whether it is face-up or face-down on the field.

 

For the 1 Face-Up Monster, that monster must stay face-up when resolving. If it is no longer Face-Up, it is no longer a valid target and the effect fails.

 

If either monster is removed from the field, the effect will fail.

 

Edit: If it helps to mention, Cyber Valley targets. It targets itself and it targets 1 Face-Up Monster on your side of the field. Whether Cyber Valley is face-up or face-down, it is a valid target. The other card is only a valid target if it is face-up.

 

So what I said was right?

 

You might confizzle people so please confirm this for people.

[darkwolf777]

If something flips Cyber Valley down' date=' it effect resolves.

 

If something flips target monster down, it's effect fizzles.

[/quote']

 

And if Valley is removed from the field by, for example, Compulsory Evac?

 

Cyber Valley's effect states: You can remove from play this card and 1 face-up monster you control, and draw 2 cards.

 

Since its not a cost, everything must stay valid when resolving.

 

For Cyber Valley, it just simply needs to be on the field. "This card" has no conditions to it and it is still considered "This Card" whether it is face-up or face-down on the field.

 

For the 1 Face-Up Monster, that monster must stay face-up when resolving. If it is no longer Face-Up, it is no longer a valid target and the effect fails.

 

If either monster is removed from the field, the effect will fail.

 

Edit: If it helps to mention, Cyber Valley targets. It targets itself and it targets 1 Face-Up Monster on your side of the field. Whether Cyber Valley is face-up or face-down, it is a valid target. The other card is only a valid target if it is face-up.

 

So what I said was right?

 

You might confizzle people so please confirm this for people.

 

Nothing in my response was contradictory to your response. Don't worry, what you said was correct :3c I just try and over-explain in my responses so that its understandable as to why it works that way, not just that it does x.o; Sorry if I confused you since I quoted what you said. I usually try to state that what I quoted is incorrect right away if it is (or if i mistakenly think it is) wrong.

[Cypress]

i see offen that people run foreign versons of cardsd in their decks. what foreign languages are english TCG players allowed to run?

[-Griffin]

German, Dutch, Spanish, Italian, French, English... any TCG language, so pretty much anything outside Asia.

[Icy]

A less stupid question this time...

I understand that Synchro's are summoned by removing cards on the field. But is that a Cost... or just generally removing them?

[Expelsword]

Synchro Materials are SENT

Not Tributed

Not Destroyed

SENT to the Gave and are not a cost

[-Griffin]

No cards directly interact with costs, so there is no ruling on that since it's never been needed. A negated Summon still loses the monsters, so I guess it's kinda a cost, but again, it's not an effect... so no rulings.

[Eminemrocks24]

I just made 2 yugioh cards with the yugioh card maker. Can someone tell me how to print them so i can glue the front and backs together?( if there is a back).

---

I just summoned LaDD but it got Solemn'd. Does LaDD's last effect to destroy my field and ss a monster from my grave still activate?

 

I summoned Artemis and it got Solemn'd. I chained with Dark Bribe and the chain was over. Do I still draw cards for Artemis' effect?

 

I destroyed an atk mode monster with Kycoo and inflicted damage from that battle. Am I still able to remove the monster I just destroyed with Kycoo's effect?

 

I think these will be helpful.

 

that is the coolest card ever

---

Do I have this right? To summon a level 8 Syncro Monster you tribute a tuner and non tuners whose levels add up 8? Like' date=' could I for example, tribute a level 4 tuner and a Dark Blade to Syncro Summon a Syncro?

[/quote']

 

yeah. you should be able to.