Jump to content

Yu-Gi-Oh! Rulings Questions

Weather Report - Stand

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 16.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
BDKMRV Newbie

BDKMRV

Posted
Posted

I've got some questions.

 

If you use Bending Destiny on Fortune Lady Light, does it's effect activate because it was removed from the field?

 

 

 

My opponent controls a Stardust and a few other monsters. I play Blaze Accelerator and send Volcanic Scattershot along with 2 other Volcanic Scattershots to destroy all my opponents monsters, but Stardust negates it. However, does my opponent take damage sent by the 2 other Volcanic Scattershots?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
werewolfjedi Newbie

werewolfjedi

Posted
Posted

If your opponent negates Polymerization with Dark Bribe' date=' the Fusion Materials still go to the Graveyard, or not?

[/quote']

 

No.

 

I do belive that the player playing the fusion card needs to desginate what fusion monster that plan to bring out though' date=' to make sure that he needed materals are availble, and therefore making it a legal play, correct?[hr']

I've got some questions.

 

If you use Bending Destiny on Fortune Lady Light' date=' does it's effect activate because it was removed from the field?

 

 

 

My opponent controls a Stardust and a few other monsters. I play Blaze Accelerator and send Volcanic Scattershot along with 2 other Volcanic Scattershots to destroy all my opponents monsters, but Stardust negates it. However, does my opponent take damage sent by the 2 other Volcanic Scattershots?

[/quote']

 

bending destiny doesn't remove monsters from play, it removes and counters the spell or trap card. if you meant slip of fortune, then yes, light does summon a replacement.

 

doesn't blaze accelerator activate it's destruction effect first, and makes it so that stardust dragon can't stop the scattershot effect?

 

because you ether target the dragon, or it negates that destruction, removing it from the equation for the scattershot destruction.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
darkwolf777 Newbie

darkwolf777

Posted
Posted

I've got some questions.

 

If you use Bending Destiny on Fortune Lady Light' date=' does it's effect activate because it was removed from the field?

 

 

 

My opponent controls a Stardust and a few other monsters. I play Blaze Accelerator and send Volcanic Scattershot along with 2 other Volcanic Scattershots to destroy all my opponents monsters, but Stardust negates it. However, does my opponent take damage sent by the 2 other Volcanic Scattershots?

[/quote']

 

bending destiny doesn't remove monsters from play, it removes and counters the spell or trap card. if you meant slip of fortune, then yes, light does summon a replacement.

 

doesn't blaze accelerator activate it's destruction effect first, and makes it so that stardust dragon can't stop the scattershot effect?

 

because you ether target the dragon, or it negates that destruction, removing it from the equation for the scattershot destruction.

 

Werewolfjedi, note that Bending Destiny is not restricted to just Spell and Trap negation, but also the negation of a Normal Summon of a monster. Bending Destiny negates the summon, so Lighty was never on the field. I guess the game would consider Lighty being sent directly from the Hand to the Remove from Game area in this case. Lighty will not gain her effect this way.

 

As for the Blaze Accelerator question, you cannot discard 3 cards at once and destroy 3 monsters. You can only activate Blaze Accelerator one at a time. You also cannot chain Blaze Accelerator to itself because it is a Continuous Spell Card and it is Spell Speed 1.

 

In this case, you send only ONE Pyro monster to the Graveyard to destroy ONE monster, and then let your opponent counter it or do nothing. If he activates Stardust Dragon to it, then the effect is negated and Blaze Accelerator is destroyed.

 

Lastly, sending the Pyro-type monster to the Graveyard is NOT the cost of activating Blaze Accelerator, but its effect. The Pyro monster is sent to the Graveyard during resolution. If Blaze Accelerator is negated, no Pyro monsters are sent to the Graveyard.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
-Griffin Newbie

-Griffin

Posted
Posted

As for the Blaze Accelerator question' date=' you cannot discard 3 cards at once and destroy 3 monsters. You can only activate Blaze Accelerator one at a time. You also cannot chain Blaze Accelerator to itself because it is a Continuous Spell Card and it is Spell Speed 1.

[/quote']

 

Read Volcanic Scattershot

Link to comment
Share on other sites
darkwolf777 Newbie

darkwolf777

Posted
Posted

As for the Blaze Accelerator question' date=' you cannot discard 3 cards at once and destroy 3 monsters. You can only activate Blaze Accelerator one at a time. You also cannot chain Blaze Accelerator to itself because it is a Continuous Spell Card and it is Spell Speed 1.

[/quote']

 

Read Volcanic Scattershot

 

My bad, didn't know that's what he meant by that :o but either way, he could just negate Blaze Accelerator before Volcanic Scattershot became a problem :< As mentioned (for BDKMRV), no monsters are sent to the Graveyard unless Blaze Accelerator resolves successfully, so if Stardust does negate Blaze Accelerator, none of your Volcanic Scattershots (including the one in your hand you planned to use for this effect) are sent to the Graveyard.

 

My opponent Normal Summons a Spellcaster' date=' I activate Bottomless Trap Hole and he activates Magical Dimension. I guess Bottomless fades?

[/quote']

 

Since Magical Dimension will resolve first (assuming we tributed the monster that triggered Bottomless Trap Hole), the monster which triggered Bottomless Trap Hole no longer exists, so Bottomless' effect disappears.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BDKMRV Newbie

BDKMRV

Posted
Posted

Oh I see. Ok thanks for the answered questions.

Now I've got another one.

 

My opponent summoned a Brionac during a his turn and discarded one card to return my Stardust back to my Deck, but I wanted to chain to its effect by activating Assault Mode Activate, yet he called priority.

 

Does my Stardust return to the deck making AM Activate's effect disappear?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
werewolfjedi Newbie

werewolfjedi

Posted
Posted

I've got some questions.

 

If you use Bending Destiny on Fortune Lady Light' date=' does it's effect activate because it was removed from the field?

 

 

 

My opponent controls a Stardust and a few other monsters. I play Blaze Accelerator and send Volcanic Scattershot along with 2 other Volcanic Scattershots to destroy all my opponents monsters, but Stardust negates it. However, does my opponent take damage sent by the 2 other Volcanic Scattershots?

[/quote']

 

bending destiny doesn't remove monsters from play, it removes and counters the spell or trap card. if you meant slip of fortune, then yes, light does summon a replacement.

 

doesn't blaze accelerator activate it's destruction effect first, and makes it so that stardust dragon can't stop the scattershot effect?

 

because you ether target the dragon, or it negates that destruction, removing it from the equation for the scattershot destruction.

 

Werewolfjedi, note that Bending Destiny is not restricted to just Spell and Trap negation, but also the negation of a Normal Summon of a monster. Bending Destiny negates the summon, so Lighty was never on the field. I guess the game would consider Lighty being sent directly from the Hand to the Remove from Game area in this case. Lighty will not gain her effect this way.

 

wow, my 1st edit. copy is missing a line.

well, that changes how I view that card.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
werewolfjedi Newbie

werewolfjedi

Posted
Posted

Morphtronic Scopen Special Summons Morphtronic Radion' date=' and then Scopen is switched to Defense Mode. Is Radion destroyed?

 

Ignition Effect VS Book of Moon. What happens?

[/quote']

 

it matters on the effect.

if you do not need the orginal effect source as a determinating factor for the effect, then it should activate without a hitch, and it negates any "attachment" effects, such as junk warrior's negation effect.

 

as far as I know.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
darkwolf777 Newbie

darkwolf777

Posted
Posted

Even I know this one:

 

Brionac's effect is Chain Link 1 because he called Priority

AMA is Chain Link 2 and thus resolves first

 

Brionac's Target disappears

 

Stardust/Assault laughs Brionac to the Stone Age

 

am I right pro players?

 

The chain is:

 

Chain 1: Brionac targeting Stardust Dragon

Chain 2: Assault Mode Activate' date=' tributing Stardust Dragon as the cost.

 

Resolving Backwards, Assault Mode Activate Special Summons Stardust Dragon/Assault Mode. Brionac's effect disappears since "Stardust Dragon" is not on the field.

 

*Edit: Sorry, i thought that was question, but apparently, this was an answer.

 

Morphtronic Scopen Special Summons Morphtronic Radion, and then Scopen is switched to Defense Mode. Is Radion destroyed?

 

Radion is destroyed because the "Destroy it during the End Phase" is a latent effect placed onto Radion itself for being Special Summoned by Scopen's effect. Whether Scopen changes position (therefore changing effects) or is removed from the field will have no affect on Radion being destroyed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BDKMRV Newbie

BDKMRV

Posted
Posted

Alright here's the same question again, but something different.

 

Stardust is on the field and my opponent has Brionac. He/She activates its effect to return Stardust to the field and calls priorty.

 

May I activate a card in response to the effect of Brionac even though my opponent has called priorty?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
The Borg Newbie

The Borg

Posted
Posted

Alright here's the same question again' date=' but something different.

 

Stardust is on the field and my opponent has Brionac. He/She activates its effect to return Stardust to the field and calls priorty.

 

May I activate a card in response to the effect of Brionac even though my opponent has called priorty?

[/quote']

 

You can chain in response. Priority just means it'll happen last on the chain

Link to comment
Share on other sites
werewolfjedi Newbie

werewolfjedi

Posted
Posted

Alright here's the same question again' date=' but something different.

 

Stardust is on the field and my opponent has Brionac. He/She activates its effect to return Stardust to the field and calls priorty.

 

May I activate a card in response to the effect of Brionac even though my opponent has called priorty?

[/quote']

 

You can chain in response. Priority just means it'll happen last on the chain

 

is it just me, or do idiots use prioty thinking it will keep their effect from being stopped?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
burnpsy Newbie

burnpsy

Posted
Posted

Book of Moon targets Spirit Reaper.

 

Reaper is not destroyed' date=' correct?

[/quote']

Correct. By the time Spirit Reaper's effect is activated it's face-down and is null'd.

 

Thank you. Tell that to the stupid judge...

 

Print out the rulings on your entire deck. That's what I do.

 

Reaper had this as one of its rulings already.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nishi-chan Newbie

Nishi-chan

Posted
Posted

Ok, I have one for you guys...

Spirit Reaper attacks directly and activates it's effect to make your opponent discard a card. Your opponent activates Divine Wrath. You chain Seven Tools of Bandit. Even though the trap was negated, Spirit Reaper was still targeted by a trap. Is it destroyed?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
darkwolf777 Newbie

darkwolf777

Posted
Posted

Ok' date=' I have one for you guys...

Spirit Reaper attacks directly and activates it's effect to make your opponent discard a card. Your opponent activates Divine Wrath. You chain Seven Tools of Bandit. Even though the trap was negated, Spirit Reaper was still targeted by a trap. Is it destroyed?

[/quote']

 

Divine Wrath does not target.

 

Either way, if a card's activation is negated that targeted Spirit Reaper, then Spirit Reaper will not destroy itself.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...