Yu-Gi-Oh! Rulings Questions

[darkwolf777]

Situation:

Heraklinos is on the field and your opponent activates Skill Successor\'s effect from the graveyard.

 

Can it negate the activation of the trap card from the graveyard' date=' and if so, what happens after its being negated? Is it destroyed and sent back to the graveyard, or removed from play still?

[/quote']

 

Yes, you should be able to activate Heraklinos to Skill Successor's 2nd effect. Cards that are in the Graveyard/Remove From Play cannot be destroyed and would stay where they are. If you negate Skill Successor's second effect, it'll stay Removed From Play.

[.:pyramid:.]

king tiger V fl water, does its effect go off before its destroyed?

[darkwolf777]

king tiger V fl water' date=' does its effect go off before its destroyed?

[/quote']

 

At least write the names out, couldn't figure out what kintgivaflfwat meant.

 

In any case, King Tiger Wanghu doesn't negate summons. Fortune Lady Water will successfully be summoned and immediately will be destroyed, but her effect is a mandatory effect, not optional, so it wont miss any timing. You'll be able to draw the 2 cards with Fortune Lady Water's effect. Her effect should activate and resolve in the Graveyard (since it would've been destroyed immediately after the Special Summon was successful, before her effect will rightfully activate, and being mandatory, it has to occur, so it will from the Graveyard)

 

Quick Answer: No, it'll be destroyed first, but you will get to Draw 2 cards.

 

See following posts.

[Professional Duelist]

It's liek how Shrink doesnt work with Wanghu.

[darkwolf777]

It isn't destroyed "instantly"' date=' Wanghu still has to activate, and forms a Chain Link after Watery if she's Summoned on your turn, or before if on your opponent's. If nothing else is chained, on your turn she'll be destroyed then you draw, or you'll draw and then she's destroyed if your opponent's turn.

[/quote']

 

You're right, I was considering Wanghu as a Continuous effect rather than a Trigger Effect (probably because it lists the trigger at the end of the text instead of just stating "When a monster with 1400 ATK or less is Normal Summoned or Special Summoned, destroy that monster"... the wording just felt continuous lol). In that case, as effects activate simultaneously, they form a chain, and since both effects are mandatory, Turn Player's mandatory effects are the first in the chain, then the opponent's.

 

If it is your opponent's Wanghu and its your turn, for example, the chain will be:

Chain 1) Your FL Water

Chain 2) Your opponent's Wanghu.

 

In which case, Wanghu destroys Water, then you Draw 2 cards.

 

If you control both Wanghu and Water, then being both mandatory effects you control, you can choose the order of activation.

 

Thanks for bringing mistakes to my attention~

[DARKPLANT RISING]

Question about Destiny End Dragoon.

 

Could I use something to send DED to the graveyard, and then remove from play D-something to take him back.

[Krillin!]

Can anyone answer a Yugioh DOTR question?!

[darkwolf777]

Question about Destiny End Dragoon.

 

Could I use something to send DED to the graveyard' date=' and then remove from play D-something to take him back.

[/quote']

 

All Fusion Monsters must be successfully Fusion Summoned before they can be revived from the Graveyard/Remove From Play. If you simply send it to the Graveyard from the Extra Deck, then no, you cannot Special Summon it with its own effect.

[DARKPLANT RISING]

Question about Destiny End Dragoon.

 

Could I use something to send DED to the graveyard' date=' and then remove from play D-something to take him back.

[/quote']

 

All Fusion Monsters must be successfully Fusion Summoned before they can be revived from the Graveyard/Remove From Play. If you simply send it to the Graveyard from the Extra Deck, then no, you cannot Special Summon it with its own effect.

 

Awwwwwww... so that's why no one uses it now.

 

Oh wait, is it possible to use Summoner of Illusions?

[-Berserker-]

I have Graywing and Strange Bird of Mist Valley in my Dark World deck. What else can I add to put Dark Simorgh there too?

[darkwolf777]

Question about Destiny End Dragoon.

 

Could I use something to send DED to the graveyard' date=' and then remove from play D-something to take him back.

[/quote']

 

All Fusion Monsters must be successfully Fusion Summoned before they can be revived from the Graveyard/Remove From Play. If you simply send it to the Graveyard from the Extra Deck, then no, you cannot Special Summon it with its own effect.

 

Awwwwwww... so that's why no one uses it now.

 

Oh wait, is it possible to use Summoner of Illusions?

 

You will be able to Special Summon Destiny End Dragoon with Summoner of Illusions. Unfortunately, since this is not considered a proper Fusion Summon, you will not be able to Special Summon him from the Graveyard once it is destroyed.

[Sephiroth_The_Legend]

I have Graywing and Strange Bird of Mist Valley in my Dark World deck. What else can I add to put Dark Simorgh there too?

 

Raiza perhaps. seeing as alot of Dark World's SS, Raiza might come in handy

[Jace Beleren]

i have a question regardling ritual summon.

if i used djin of rituals (the level 1 guy thats protects ritual monsters from trap cards) to summon Garlandolf along with other djins

when he is summoned. my opponents activated bottomless trap hole as a chain......will Garlandolf get destroyed ?

[Sephiroth_The_Legend]

No. As he's unaffected by Traps.

 

Same sort of ruling behind Wildheart.

 

your opponent can activate the trap, but it will have no effect.

[Krillin!]

WILL ANYONE ANSWER THE QUESTION IVE POSTED AGAIN AND AGAIN WITHOUT A SINGLE RESPONSE?!

 

IN DOTR IF CYBER-STEIN FIGHTS AQUA DRAGON WITH EFFECT ACTIVATES?!

[Manjoume Thunder]

WILL ANYONE ANSWER THE QUESTION IVE POSTED AGAIN AND AGAIN WITHOUT A SINGLE RESPONSE?!

 

IN DOTR IF CYBER-STEIN FIGHTS AQUA DRAGON WITH EFFECT ACTIVATES?!

 

CAPS LOCK IS CRUISE CONTROL FOR COOL!

 

No one will answer your question, because:

 

1. DOTR is a stupid old game that no one plays anymore.

2. This thread is for questions regarding the card game. Not video games.

 

 

Anyway, what will happen if I try to summon Lava Golem while Oppression is on the field?

[-Berserker-]

WILL ANYONE ANSWER THE QUESTION IVE POSTED AGAIN AND AGAIN WITHOUT A SINGLE RESPONSE?!

 

IN DOTR IF CYBER-STEIN FIGHTS AQUA DRAGON WITH EFFECT ACTIVATES?!

 

CAPS LOCK IS CRUISE CONTROL FOR COOL!

 

No one will answer your question' date=' because:

 

1. DOTR is a stupid old game that no one plays anymore.

2. This thread is for questions regarding the card game. Not video games.

 

 

Anyway, what will happen if I try to summon Lava Golem while Oppression is on the field?

[/quote']

 

I suppose your opponent can negate it, but the monsters would already be gone...

[c009tas]

ok, i have a situation that i think i know how it works, but i'd just like confirmation on it.

 

Situation: its my turn, I normal summon Alien Warrior, I Call Priority to Special Summon Alien Dog from my hand, My opponent activates Bottomless Trap Hole. He cannot select Warrior because he cannot chain to warrior's summoning because i did first correct?

 

Follow up: If that situation happens, and my opponent uses BTH on my Alien Dog, do i get to distribute the Counter's from Dog's Effect?

[darkwolf777]

ok' date=' i have a situation that i think i know how it works, but i'd just like confirmation on it.

 

Situation: its my turn, I normal summon Alien Warrior, I Call Priority to Special Summon Alien Dog from my hand, My opponent activates Bottomless Trap Hole. He cannot select Warrior because he cannot chain to warrior's summoning because i did first correct?

 

Follow up: If that situation happens, and my opponent uses BTH on my Alien Dog, do i get to distribute the Counter's from Dog's Effect?

[/quote']

 

1) Even though you call priority to activate Alien Dog's effect, the last thing to occur is still the summoning of Alien Warrior, therefore, he can chain Bottomless Trap Hole to your Alien Dog's activation.

 

2) If he waits to use BTH when Alien Dog is Special Summoned, since BTH doesn't negate summons, and Alien Dog's effect is mandatory, you will be able to place 2 A-Counters on your opponent's monsters.

[c009tas]

ok' date=' i have a situation that i think i know how it works, but i'd just like confirmation on it.

 

Situation: its my turn, I normal summon Alien Warrior, I Call Priority to Special Summon Alien Dog from my hand, My opponent activates Bottomless Trap Hole. He cannot select Warrior because he cannot chain to warrior's summoning because i did first correct?

 

Follow up: If that situation happens, and my opponent uses BTH on my Alien Dog, do i get to distribute the Counter's from Dog's Effect?

[/quote']

 

1) Even though you call priority to activate Alien Dog's effect, the last thing to occur is still the summoning of Alien Warrior, therefore, he can chain Bottomless Trap Hole to your Alien Dog's activation.

 

2) If he waits to use BTH when Alien Dog is Special Summoned, since BTH doesn't negate summons, and Alien Dog's effect is mandatory, you will be able to place 2 A-Counters on your opponent's monsters.

ok, so even if i chain to my Warr's Summoning first, my opponent can still BTH my warr? tho Dog and BTH have the same speed?

[darkwolf777]

ok' date=' i have a situation that i think i know how it works, but i'd just like confirmation on it.

 

Situation: its my turn, I normal summon Alien Warrior, I Call Priority to Special Summon Alien Dog from my hand, My opponent activates Bottomless Trap Hole. He cannot select Warrior because he cannot chain to warrior's summoning because i did first correct?

 

Follow up: If that situation happens, and my opponent uses BTH on my Alien Dog, do i get to distribute the Counter's from Dog's Effect?

[/quote']

 

1) Even though you call priority to activate Alien Dog's effect, the last thing to occur is still the summoning of Alien Warrior, therefore, he can chain Bottomless Trap Hole to your Alien Dog's activation.

 

2) If he waits to use BTH when Alien Dog is Special Summoned, since BTH doesn't negate summons, and Alien Dog's effect is mandatory, you will be able to place 2 A-Counters on your opponent's monsters.

ok, so even if i chain to my Warr's Summoning first, my opponent can still BTH my warr? tho Dog and BTH have the same speed?

 

Alien Dog's effect starts a chain. The chain would be:

 

1) Your Alien Dog

2) Opponent's BTH.

 

BTH doesn't have to be directly chained to the summon, it can chain to cards that are also chaining to the summon as the Summon is still the last thing to actually occur, the timing is still perfectly fine.

 

Edit: I replicated this in TF4 using Torrential Tribute instead of Bottomless Trap Hole (since you can't BTH your own monsters), and I was indeed able to chain Torrential Tribute to Alien Dog's activation.

[JadenxAtemYAOI]

I've got two questions

 

1. Can I activate call of the haunted during my battle phase?

 

2. What deck theme would allow me to have Dark and Light monsters but have cards like Chaos Goddess, Darklord Zerato, and Dark magician. the reason why is because I'm working really hard on making a deck involving Chaos Goddess, The creator, and Dark Creator

[darkwolf777]

1. Can I activate call of the haunted during my battle phase?

 

Yes, just not during the Damage Step.

[burnpsy]

2. What deck theme would allow me to have Dark and Light monsters but have cards like Chaos Goddess' date=' Darklord Zerato, and [b']Dark magician[/b]. the reason why is because I'm working really hard on making a deck involving Chaos Goddess, The creator, and Dark Creator

 

Bolded cards are bad/horrible, making that "deck theme" bad by default if it existed.

[Manjoume Thunder]

Anyway' date=' what will happen if I try to summon Lava Golem while Oppression is on the field?

[/quote']

 

Two monsters are tributed either play can then pay 800 to negate the Summon, else it's just as normal.

 

O.o

 

So I can use Lava Golem for easy +1s?!

 

 

funk you Kat! funk you Stardust. Lava Golem > You

 

:D