Jump to content

Yu-Gi-Oh! Rulings Questions


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 16.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I don't see why "Threatening Roar" isn't on that list, especially since it is chainable. "A Feint Plan" can almost be as good, so long as you control a face-down monster. (though direct attacks would still work, or if they remove your face-downs ><)

 

What are some good defensive cards that can be used while Decree is out and don't eat up my Normal Summons?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Scenario: You have "reversal quiz" and "backs to the wall". Backs to the wall is already set for a turn, and you activate "reversal quiz"

 

Reversal quiz has the cost of having to send all the cards in your hand and field to the graveyard, but I'm wondering if its possible to chain backs to the wall to the activation of the effect of reversal quiz? or does backs to the wall have to go to the graveyard before you can activate reversal quiz?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Scenario: You have "reversal quiz" and "backs to the wall". Backs to the wall is already set for a turn, and you activate "reversal quiz"

 

Reversal quiz has the cost of having to send all the cards in your hand and field to the graveyard, but I'm wondering if its possible to chain backs to the wall to the activation of the effect of reversal quiz? or does backs to the wall have to go to the graveyard before you can activate reversal quiz?

 

You cannot. Sending all cards in your hand and on the field are the cost to activate Reversal Quiz. Backs to the Wall will have been sent to the Graveyard before you even get a chance to activate it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Q: If my opponent chooses to add a Genex to his hand via Vindikite during the battlephase and chooses to activate the effect of R-Genex Accelerator, does the B-Phase continue or result in MP2?

 

The Battle Phase continues. Accelerator's effect is activated when a Genex monster is added to your hand from the deck, such as by Vindikite's effect. This is not an Ignition Effect (which can only be activated during the Main Phase), so the monster is revealed and Special Summoned during the Battle Phase.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Question: Do Exceed summons count as a +1 or a -1? I ask this because the underlaid monsters still are "on the field". I know it's not much of an advantage, but the question here is for a bigger one. If a card let you underlay a card in your hand to an Exceed monster, would that count as a -1 too?

 

I think it depends on the effect of the Exceed monster, and what it does with the Exceed Materials. Strictly speaking, it's a -1, since you lose 2 monsters (-2 field) for 1 from the extra Deck (+1 field). The Exceed Materials don't seem to actually count towards Field advantage.

 

Actually, I think that hypothetical card is TECHNICALLY a -2. You use it and a card from your hand (-2 hand advantage), and add a technical +0 to the field.

 

I really dont know enough about Exceeds to know how advantage plays out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Question: Do Exceed summons count as a +1 or a -1? I ask this because the underlaid monsters still are "on the field". I know it's not much of an advantage, but the question here is for a bigger one. If a card let you underlay a card in your hand to an Exceed monster, would that count as a -1 too?

 

Exceed Summons are -1s (Uses 2 monsters to bring only 1 from the Extra Deck).

 

A card that would allow you to underlay a card in your hand would be a -1.

 

Overlayed monsters do not take up field presence and can almost be considered to be like Counters (except that Exceeds do not lose their overlays when flipped face-down, and Exceed Materials are sent to the Graveyard after being used).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There are different ways of looking at card advantage, but the basic way of looking at it is (most) Exceeds require 2 cards to be played, and they add 1 card presence to the field. Therefore, an Exceed Summon is a -1 action. Depending on the effect of an Exceed Monster, however, it can be different. No cards that I know of yet immediately has an effect when it's Exceed Summoned, but a few can generate immediate advantage after they have used their effects.

 

If you were wondering, using up an Exceed Material to activate an effect, in "card advantage" terms, is not a -1. You are not losing any field or hand advantage by doing it, unless said effect used does as much.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Me: Shura attack, discard Kalut!

Opponent: Book.

 

This was in top 8 of my fairly good locals.

 

 

The above quote is part of my reasoning to the following question:

 

If a monster declares an attack I can Book it, but if the monster is buffed by a card effect (i.e. Kalut) it enters the damage step and Book misses the timing correct?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The reason you can't use Book after somebody discards for Kalut is because the game has already moved into the Damage Step (that's when you can activate Kalut's effect. Not any earlier). You cannot chain Book of Moon at this point. You can, however, chain Book of Moon in response to the attack of Shura when the attack is declared. If you decide not to, the opponent may then discard Kalut to gain its effect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The reason you can't use Book after somebody discards for Kalut is because the game has already moved into the Damage Step (that's when you can activate Kalut's effect. Not any earlier). You cannot chain Book of Moon at this point. You can, however, chain Book of Moon in response to the attack of Shura when the attack is declared. If you decide not to, the opponent may then discard Kalut to gain its effect.

 

Thanks bro =]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...