Jump to content

Tormented vs. Kuroda Kaito [KOTH #1]


Night

Which piece do you like more?  

10 members have voted

  1. 1. Which piece do you like more?



Recommended Posts

KOTH.png


 


 


____________________


 


 


The first King of the Hill match is set to decide who will be the first to hold the title of Graphics King.


 


 


 


 


 1    ejZCuqj.png        m_ZTrt_PO.png?noCache=1457929560       King-of-the-hill%20entry1_zpsqz4guluy.pn    2


 


 


 


Voting rules:


 


• Anyone can vote, you don't need any graphic design knowledge to do so, critique and analysis is appreciated but not a must, comments of any sort are favorable.


• Bribing or informing others of which submission is yours is not permitted and if found doing so, you will be banned from the graphic competitions section.


 


Voting ends 3/16 at 11:59PM EST. Whoever has the most votes at that point wins. 


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pretty solid pieces yo

 

#1 has a couple sharpening inconsistencies, though I like the atmosphere and the scene. I think some yellow lighting would help with blending a bit more

 

#2 has quite a bit going on, with smudging and bubble c4ds in two separate halves. I think full smuding would accommodate the render a bit more than c4ds. Really like the colors though

 

 

 

1 gmv

Link to comment
Share on other sites

#2 would've been a lot better without the entire right side. The hair mixes too much with the background and the colors of the sword don't really help to compliment the piece. I do feel some nice flow to it, though, and I'm a sucker for pink hair.

 

#1 gave me a Witcher 3 vibe. Nice warm colors and the way the glare of the sunlight kinda weaves through the branches of the tree is pretty cool. The render is nice, too, though while his hair made me imagine the wind adding some flow through the rest of the piece was nice, I'd've liked something more defined like some leaves or something.

 

#1 gmv

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The blurring is heinous is number one. Atmos and blending is tolerable, but inconsistent and easily drawn away from the main focal.

Two is trying to do too many things, while keeping flow being the main attribute. I like it more because it is more dynamic and working with its problems. It just has too many problems that it is trying to work it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...