Remake a Card

[Darj]

I find amusing that you nominated Spellbreaker of IB, because for me she is among the best IB monsters in Rank4 spam builds, notably because she is a Salvage target.

Spellbreaker of the Ice Barrier
WATER/Spellcaster/Effect/Level 4
1200/2000
If you control no monsters, or all monsters you control are "Ice Barrier" monsters: You can Special Summon this card from your hand. You can only use this effect of "Spellbreaker of the Ice Barrier" once per turn. Once per turn (Quick Effect): You can send 1 "Ice Barrier" card from your hand to the GY; Spell Cards cannot be activated until the End Phase of your next turn.


Next:
Genex Ally Reliever

[Rayfield Lumina]

Haha, you have a point, but I'd say being "one of the best IBs" is not exactly a wonderful thing, considering how bad they are in general (for my great displeasure, because i love their theme and artworks). That self-summoning effect you gave her is pretty nice.

Genex Ally Reliever

DARK

Level 5

Machine / Effect

If you negate the activation of a Spell Card, Trap Card, or monster effect activated by your opponent, you can Special Summon this card from your hand, and if you do, you can banish 1 Machine monster from your GY, and if you do that, this card's Attribute become the same as the banished monster and is unaffected by monster effects with an ATK equal or lower than the banished monster.

ATK 2200 / DEF 1000

 

Next - Injection Fairy Lily

[Dramatic Crossroad]

 

Injection Fairy Lily 

(EARTH) [Spellcaster/Effect] Level: 3 | ATK: 400 | DEF: 1500

Once, during the damage calculation when a monster you control battles: you can pay up to 2000 LP (in multiples of 100); your monster gains 150 ATK for each 100 LP paid during that damage calculation only.  

 

 

Next: The Six Samurai - Yariza

[morrisoni4]

(Same stats)

This card can attack your opponent directly, but if it does so using this effect while you don't control a "Six Samurai" monster with a different name, reduce its ATK by half during that damage calculation only. If this card would be destroyed, you can destroy another "Six Samurai" monster you control instead.

 

Next: "Goblindbergh"

[Rayfield Lumina]

Goblindbergh

EARTH

Level 4

Warrior / Tuner / Effect

If this card is Normal Summoned: You can Special Summon 1 Level 4 or lower monster from your hand, also, after that, change this card to Defense Position OR: You can discard 1 card, then Special Summon 1 EARTH Level 4 or lower monster from your Deck, but if you do, you cannot Special Summon monsters from the Extra Deck for the rest of this turn, except EARTH Link monsters.

1500 / 0

 

Next: Gagagigo

[morrisoni4]

"Gagagigo"

(Same stats)

If you control "Marauding Captain": you can Special Summon this card. If a "Marauding Captain" you control is destroyed: You can Tribute this card, Special Summon one "Giga Gagagigo" from your hand or Deck.

 

Next: "Rose Spectre of Dunn"

[Rayfield Lumina]

Rose Spectre of Dunn

DARK

Level 6

Plant / Fusion / Effect

"Feral Imp" or 1 "Aroma" monster + "Snakeyashi"

Plant monsters you control gain 100 ATK for each Plant or Fiend monster in your GY with a different name than all other monsters in your GY. This card gains 1 of the following effects based on the Fusion Material used for it's Fusion Summon:

*Feral Imp: Your opponent cannot attack Plant monsters you control except this one.

*"Aroma" monster: Once per turn, If your LP are higher than your opponent: You can discard 1 card; draw 1 card.

2200 / 1700

 

Next: Talaya, Princess of Cherry Blossoms

[morrisoni4]

"Talaya, Princess of Cherry Blossoms"

(Same stats)

This card gains 100 ATK for each Plant monster you control. Other Plant monsters on the field cannot be destroyed by card effects. Once per turn, you can Tribute all other Plant monsters you control, inflict 500 damage to your opponent for each.

 

Next: "Sangan"

[Dramatic Crossroad]

Sangan... 2nd errata? LOL 

Critter (DARK)

Level 3 / [Fiend / Effect ]  ATK/1000 DEF/600

If this card is sent to the GY: Add 1 monster with 1500 or less ATK from your Deck to your hand (except "Critter"). You can only use this effect of "Critter" once per turn.

(Hard once per turn without the overkill balancing text that ruined it.)

 

Next: the most confusing card ever - Inspector Boarder

[Thomas★Zero]

Time to make Inspector Boarder easy to understand.

Inspector Boarder
lv 4 LIGHT
Machine/Effect
Cannot be Normal or Special Summoned if you control a monster. If theirs a monster on the field that was Special Summoned from the hand or Extra Deck neither player can activate monster effects.
ATK/2000 DEF/2000

Next: Zombyra the Dark

[morrisoni4]

"Zombyra the Dark"

(same stats)

If this card attacks your opponent directly, destroy it at the end of the Damage Step. If this card destroys an opponent's monster by battle, it loses 200 ATK and gains 200 DEF.

 

Next: "Hardened Armed Dragon"

[Rayfield Lumina]

Hardened Armed Dragon

EARTH

Level 4

Dragon / Effect

(This card is not treated as an "Armed Dragon" card.)

You can Special Summon this card (from your hand) by sending 1 Level 8 or higher monster from your hand to the GY, or by banishing 1 Level 8 or higher monster from your GY, face-down. If you Tribute this card for the Tribute Summon of a Level 7 or higher monster, that monster cannot be destroyed by card effects. Once per turn: You can pay 1000 LP; change this card to Defense Position, also it cannot be destroyed by battle until the end of your opponent's turn.

ATK 800 / DEF 1500

 

Next: Fusionist

[morrisoni4]

"Fusionist"
(Same stats)

"Petit Angel" + "Mystical Sheep #2"

You can substitute this card for any 1 Fusion-Material Monster. When you do this, the other Fusion-Material Monster(s) must be the correct one(s). If you Fusion Summon using this card as Material, that Fusion Summoned monster gains this effect:

• This card can attack twice per Battle Phase.

 

Next: "Snatch Steal"

[Rayfield Lumina]

Snatch Steal

Equip Spell

Equip only to a monster your opponent controls. Take control of the equipped monster. During each of your opponent's Standby Phases: They gain 1500 Life Points. You cannot use the monster you take control of with this card as a material during the turn you activate this card.

 

Next: Ordeal of a Traveler

[morrisoni4]

"Ordeal of a Traveler"

Continuous Trap

When an opponent's monster declares an attack: Shuffle your hand and choose 1 random card from it, your opponent calls the type of the card (Monster, Spell, or Trap). If they call it right, discard that card. If they call it wrong, return the attacking monster to the hand.

 

Next: "Advanced Ritual Art"

[Rayfield Lumina]

Advanced Ritual Art

Ritual Spell

This card can be used to Ritual Summon any 1 Ritual Monster. You must also send Normal Monsters from your Deck to the GY whose total Levels equal the Level of that Ritual Monster. You can banish this card from your GY; Ritual Summon 1 Ritual Monster. You must also banish Effect Monsters from your Deck, face down, whose total Levels equal the Level of the Ritual Monster. You can only use 1 effect of "Advanced Ritual Art" per turn, and only once that turn.

 

Next: Magician of Faith

[morrisoni4]

"Magician of Faith"

(Same Stats)

FLIP: Banish 1 Spell from your GY, this effect becomes that card's effect when activated.

 

Next: "Grinder Golem"

[Thomas★Zero]

Grinder Golem
lv 8 DARK
Fiend/Effect
Cannot be Normal Summoned/Set. Must be Special Summoned (from your hand) to your opponents side of the field by Special Summoning 2 "Grinder Tokens" (Fiend/DARK/Level 1/ATK 0/DEF 0) in Attack Position on your side of the field. You can only Special Summon "Grinder Golem" once per turn this way. At the start of the damage step, if a "Grinder Token" battles an opponents monster: destroy that monster and inflict damage to your opponent equal to the original ATK of the destroyed monster. These tokens cannot be tributed or be used as Link Material for a Link Summon.
ATK/3000 DEF/300

Next: Bird of Roses

[morrisoni4]

"Bird of Roses"

(Same Stats)

When this face-up Attack Position card is destroyed by battle with an opponent's attacking monster and sent to the Graveyard, you can Special Summon 1 Plant Tuner monster and one non-Tuner Plant monster from your Deck in face-up Defense Position, then immediately Synchro Summon one Plant Synchro Monster, using those 2 monsters as Material.

 

Next: "Poison of the Old Man"

[Dramatic Crossroad]

Poison of the Old Man (SPELL)

Normal Spell Card

Activate 1 of these effects;
● Gain 1200 LP and additional 1200 for every "Poison of the Old Man" in your GY.
● Inflict 800 damage to your opponent and additional 800 for every "Poison of the Old Man" in your GY.

 

(LOL Emergency provisions of the old man OTK)  

Next: Sophia, Goddess of Rebirth

[Thomas★Zero]

Sophia, Goddess of Rebirth
lv 11 DARK
Fairy/Effect
Cannot be Normal Summoned/Set. Must be Special Summoned by banishing 1 Ritual Monster and Pendulum Monster from your Deck and 1 Fusion, Synchro, Xyz and Link Monster from your Extra Deck face-down. You can only Special Summon "Sophia, Goddess of Rebirth" once per turn this way. This cards summon cannot be negated. When this card is Special Summoned: Banish all other cards on the field face-down. Your opponent cannot activate cards or effects in response to this effects activation. If this card leaves the field, return all banished cards to the Deck.
ATK/3600 DEF/3400

Next: The Wicked Worm Beast

[Dramatic Crossroad]

The Wicked Worm Beast (EARTH)

Level 3 [Beast / Effect] ATK/1400 DEF/700

During each End Phase; return this card to its owner's hand or return other cards you control (min.1) to the hand so you only control this card.

 

NEXT: Harpie Lady Sisters 

[Rayfield Lumina]

Harpie Lady Sisters

WIND

Level 6

Winged Beast / Effect

Cannot be Normal Summoned/Set. Must first be Special Summoned with "Elegant Egotist" or the effect of a "Harpie" monster. Once per turn: You can discard 1 card, then target 1 WIND monster you control and 1 monster your opponent controls; return both targets to the hand, and if you do, you can decrease this card's Level by 2 until the end of this turn.

2000 / 2100

 

Next: Element Valkyrie

[MUDKIPISAWESOME!!!]

Oh, I've been waiting for her! A low-key babe card plus all the 'Element' Monsters could use an update, just not sure how to go about them. Wish she went with the Valkyrie archetype though...
Stats are a bit low without the FIRE boost, so I personally would bump it to 18/13 and bump the FIRE boost to a +700 to both, however, this may not work as well if we applied this boost across the board for the 'archetype' since the ones without the FIRE effect wouldn't hit the even 2500(plus Dragon might go crazy), which also seems kind of a lot for a Level 4 to hit. The WATER effect's a little trickier, personally I haven't played against control-switching decks in a while so it feels a bit outdated, but I'm not sure what else fits the WATER idea so I went with a tentative idea that may end up too much, feel free to change this with future 'Element' Monsters and we'll just assume it retroactively altered this.

SUGGESTED NEW VERSION:
Level 4 LIGHT Fairy
1800 DEF, 1300 DEF
(This card is not treated as a 'Valkyrie' card/cries)
This Monster gets the following effects while there is a Monster(s) with the following Attribute(s) on the field:
FIRE: This card gains 700 ATK/DEF.
WATER: This card is unaffected by your opponent's Spell/Trap effects, also your opponent cannot Tribute this card.

UPDATE SUMMARY:
Stats bumped up to compete with the heavier-hitting new stuff out there, since she's not a Valkyrie and doesn't have any archetypes to synergize with - if either player has a FIRE Monster, she'll hit 2500/2000, I'd say that's quite respectable for a Level 4. She now also carries partial immunity to your opponent's cards and can't be Kaiju'd if either player has a WATER(though ironically if neither player does your opponent can still Gameciel her).

NEXT UP:
Let's fix all the 'Element' Monsters while we're here - you can select one of Element Doom, Soldier, Magician, Dragon, or Saurus. I would recommend Element Dragon, as it's the closest to a still good card from what I've seen.

[Rayfield Lumina]

damn it, @MUDKIPISAWESOME!!!, this is the most enthusiast post I've seen in this game, I'm glad there's someone else who likes the Valkyrie as much as I am. So, following your previous structure:

Element Magician

LIGHT

Level 4

Spellcaster / Effect

This monster gets the following effect(s) while there is a monster(s) with the following Attribute(s) on the field:

* WATER: Control, ATK/DEF and Battle Position of this card cannot change by your opponent's card effects.

* WIND: If this card destroys a monster by battle, it can make a second attack each Battle Phase this turn. Your opponent cannot activate cards or effects until the end of the Damage Step.

ATK 1800 / DEF 1300

 

Next: Element Doom/Soldier/Dragon or Saurus