Jump to content

Greatest Elite Four Member: Kanto


The original Elite fou....three!  

16 members have voted

  1. 1. Kanto Elite, fight!



Recommended Posts

Cause screw it I wanna do these now. XD

Basically just the E4 version of the gym ones.

Vote for which of the E4 members you like most.

Disclaimer so no one complains. I see Lance as more a Champion, as he was only a common E4 member for a short time.

Also the Johto games group will be seperate, so this and Johto will really be an Elite 3.

 

Match ends May 31st midnight (CST time)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Where is Drake? And is it only the 4 trainers before the Champ or does he/she count to?

 

As of now, I cant vote since my fav isn't here!!

You seem quite confused.

The Champ doesn't count cause they aren't the Elite Four, pretty simple. They'll have a separate Poll.

Also Drake is in the Hoenn one?

 

Anyway I don't particularly care for these but Bruno is pretty cool.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You seem quite confused.

The Champ doesn't count cause they aren't the Elite Four, pretty simple. They'll have a separate Poll.

Also Drake is in the Hoenn one?

 

Anyway I don't particularly care for these but Bruno is pretty cool.

 

Well, I just mixed them up, that's all, and it was only the names. I do that sometimes. Just who I am.

 

Anyway, why isn't Lance on here? He is still a part of Elite Four in Kanto

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I just mixed them up, that's all, and it was only the names. I do that sometimes. Just who I am.

 

Anyway, why isn't Lance on here? He is still a part of Elite Four in Kanto

I already explained this.

 

 


Disclaimer so no one complains. I see Lance as more a Champion, as he was only a common E4 member for a short time.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lance isn't the Champion!!! He is the last of Elite Four!!! He is part of the four strongest trainers before you meet the champion!

He was the Champion except for the, idk, day that Blue was Champion. Plus he's the Champion in Johto.

Basically there was a short time frame when he was a regular member of the Elite Four. And besides that maybe one single day he was the Champion. And he kept that title for years. I think that entitles him to a spot as a Champion instead of Elite Four.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He was the Champion except for the, idk, day that Blue was Champion. Plus he's the Champion in Johto.

Basically there was a short time frame when he was a regular member of the Elite Four. And besides that maybe one single day he was the Champion. And he kept that title for years. I think that entitles him to a spot as a Champion instead of Elite Four.

 

Lance was never the Champion of Kanto. So he cant be considered the Champion. Maybe in the manga he was the champion, but not in the games/anime. And what does Johto have anything to do with this Elite Four? It is a completely different region. Even if Lance is the champion in Johto, he isn't in Kanto. If you dont count him in as a member of Elite Four, the Elite four would be the Elite Three + Lance. And that is so wrong on so many levels.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lance was never the Champion of Kanto. So he cant be considered the Champion. Maybe in the manga he was the champion, but not in the games/anime. And what does Johto have anything to do with this Elite Four? It is a completely different region. Even if Lance is the champion in Johto, he isn't in Kanto. If you dont count him in as a member of Elite Four, the Elite four would be the Elite Three + Lance. And that is so wrong on so many levels.

He was the top member until Blue came around. And after Blue was beaten by the player, the player then leaves his spot as Champion, and then Lance is on top again. This change lasted perhaps a day. Therefore he was the champion.
You're literally the only one with an issue about this, so I don't see a need to change it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He was the top member until Blue came around. And after Blue was beaten by the player, the player then leaves his spot as Champion, and then Lance is on top again. This change lasted perhaps a day. Therefore he was the champion.
You're literally the only one with an issue about this, so I don't see a need to change it.

 

So what if he was the top. That doesn't mean in any way he was actually the champion. It never states he actually was the champion. And after you finish the game, shouldn't Blue step down as champion since the player then becomes the champion? And will he go down to a part of the Elite Four (talking about Blue now), and push out Lorelei?

Oh and in the games, even Lance say he is a member of the Elite Four, so I guess that isn't canon as a member of Elite Four.

 

And no I have no problems with it. You seem to not know about the Elite Four of this Region, is all. And the same with Johto, was only 3 members of Elite Four if I remember correct. You excluded Bruno.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So what if he was the top. That doesn't mean in any way he was actually the champion. It never states he actually was the champion. And after you finish the game, shouldn't Blue step down as champion since the player then becomes the champion? And will he go down to a part of the Elite Four (talking about Blue now), and push out Lorelei?

Oh and in the games, even Lance say he is a member of the Elite Four, so I guess that isn't canon as a member of Elite Four.

 

And no I have no problems with it. You seem to not know about the Elite Four of this Region, is all. And the same with Johto, was only 3 members of Elite Four if I remember correct. You excluded Bruno.

I will explain this one last time before I go to bed.

Lance is the top member of the Elite Four, being the top member would qualify him to be the Champion. If there is no other Champion then the top member of the Elite Four would be the champion.

Blue is the Champion for a moment, he gets beaten by the player. He decides not to take a spot as an E4 member (canonically). The player also doesn't stay as a Champion (canonically) and so that would only leave Lance as the head of the Elite Four (which would make him Champion of the Elite Four)

I know exactly what I'm doing, don't worry.

As for Bruno, i saw no reason to put him in two separate Elite Four matches.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I will explain this one last time before I go to bed.

Lance is the top member of the Elite Four, being the top member would qualify him to be the Champion. If there is no other Champion then the top member of the Elite Four would be the champion.

Blue is the Champion for a moment, he gets beaten by the player. He decides not to take a spot as an E4 member (canonically). The player also doesn't stay as a Champion (canonically) and so that would only leave Lance as the head of the Elite Four (which would make him Champion of the Elite Four)

I know exactly what I'm doing, don't worry.

As for Bruno, i saw no reason to put him in two separate Elite Four matches.

 

Well, he never was champion so there is no reason not to have him an elite four member. He may be the champion of Elite Four, but not the "Champion" of the game/anime, like Cynthia or Wallace or Steven! He has always been the top Elite Four member. Never gone above that in the Kanto region.

 

HE NEER WAS CHAMPION. BEFORE BLUE, THERE WAS ONLY ELITE FOUR!!!! And maybe an unknown Champion. But Lance never was Champion.

 

I understand your decision, and I can see how people will believe that, but your facts are wrong.

 

EDIT: I can kinda agree to some degree about Bruno not be in Johto but still, he is the third of the Elite Four still so...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Plot twist: Because the Pokemon Leagues for Kanto and Johto are the same place, that means that Lance was indeed a Champion in Kanto.

Mind blowing, I know.

 

 

That means the entire Elite Four also changed except Bruno. And Koga surpassed 3 gym leaders and probably multipple Elite four members!! Haha... No he didn't! And it is not same as Kanto!! they are indeed at same place but 2 different Elite Four leagues

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That means the entire Elite Four also changed except Bruno. And Koga surpassed 3 gym leaders and probably multipple Elite four members!! Haha... No he didn't! And it is not same as Kanto!! they are indeed at same place but 2 different Elite Four leagues

Logically speaking, you are right in that they are 2 different Elite Four leagues. One from the past, and one 3 years later.

 

But you are wrong about Koga not surpassing 3 Gym Leaders. Clearly he did because he joined the Elite Four. This is after 3 years after all, so it's very believable.

 

Anyway, the only reason I see to keep Lance out of this now is if Cow plans to put the Elite Four winners in a match with a champion (or all the champions?) because there would then be a possibility he would end up against himself.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Logically speaking, you are right in that they are 2 different Elite Four leagues. One from the past, and one 3 years later.

 

But you are wrong about Koga not surpassing 3 Gym Leaders. Clearly he did because he joined the Elite Four. This is after 3 years after all, so it's very believable.

 

Anyway, the only reason I see to keep Lance out of this now is if Cow plans to put the Elite Four winners in a match with a champion (or all the champions?) because there would then be a possibility he would end up against himself.

I think he just doesn't want him winning both elite 4 and champion.

 

Though he'll definitely have a run for his money between Steven Stone and Cynthia

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...