The Dueling Arena

[Ultimate Ryan]

good luck both of frlf and hunterb and yankee this is so when you post judging you don't have to double post! (I put $500 Kuriboh cash on frlf, sorry hunterb but i want that card of yours to get beaten!)

[Yankee]

Frlf:

 

Hunterb:

 

Ok, here we are, the challange between hunterb, and the challanger, Frlf.

Lets first look at Frlf's card:

His effect is pretty straigh forward, remove to darks from the grave, you get to summon him. If he kills a light monster, it destroyes a spell or trap.

Thats it, lol

While it may seem increadibly simple, thus bad, it's not. It has many ways of being abused, such as, cards that use rfp cards, and heck, the 2ndary effect kicks ass, so, it's a good card overall.

 

Rates:

Name: 5/10 Has a ring to it, but it's not understandable =/

Pic: 8/10 It's cool

Effect: 7/10 Pretty cool to

Grammar: 8/10 Good, but the light monster effect is worded wrong.

Overall: 7/10 It's ok, just a few problems. Plus, i'm a harsh rate, lol

 

Now it's Hunterbs turn:

 

It is safe to say that this card is NOT simple.

First of all, when you summon it, you get to go to you OPPONENT'S grave, and pick a fusion. There is a problem on it's effect, how often is it that a person has a fusion anymore, much less in the grave, typicly, the fusion only comes in the end game. But say you stopped your opponent, you get to choose a fusion. It's what you do with the fusion that makes this a cool effect. You have to pay lp equal to half the ATK of the monster you chose, then you get to equip it to this card. Then you increase the ATK AND DEF of this card by the ATK and DEF of the fusion. See the balance? Want this guy to be way strong? You have to pay a ton of lp. So, you may be thinking, "so what? this guy is drunk with power". Well, hold you midless fools XD

If your opponent manages to destroy this mighty beast, your opponent gets the fusion monster back on there side of the field. This card is really balanced, but, if you look at it, is actually bordering on underpowerd, but it is still increadible.

 

Rates:

name: 7/10 good

Pic: 6/10 works with name, thats about it.

Effect: 9/10 very good

Grammar: 8/10 it's good, but I spot a few ocg problems

Overall: 30/40 or 7.5/10

 

Very good job

 

 

So, your winner is Hunterb, but not by as much as everybody expected, maybe the next challanger can beat him XD

100 points will be sent to Hunterb ^_^

[Ultimate Ryan]

my turn against hunterb, your going down, and when we are both done can if he/she is on can ruby judge? Hunterb how much you gonna put up?

[Aximil]

the name is understandable to me...it's German...although he does have a spelling error...this is his cards name,i will show you the spelling mistake

 

Steuermann-Der Latzte Einwohner Der Welt...the correct spelling is: Steuermann-Der Letzte Einwohner Der Welt which translates to: Attendant - the last inhabitant of the world

[Ultimate Ryan]

here hunterb i had put up $500 kuriboh cash and i lost so here,

[Huntar!]

^

 

that is spam.

 

aximil, you too.

 

__

 

anyway, I will go up against ultimateryan next. I seem to have more matches than anyone else in my own arena. ;)

 

PEOPLE, YOU CAN CHALLENGE 72NIGHT, AXIMIL, RUBY, AND anyone on the list IF they have your concent.

[Ultimate Ryan]

ruby do you wanna judge me and hunterb's match wud ya?

[The Ruby]

sure...

[Ultimate Ryan]

Ruby we both agreed to pay 50 points and i sent mine just now...

[The Ruby]

Ok...all i need now is Hunterbs...>_>

[Huntar!]

sent. looking for a GOOD card.

[Ultimate Ryan]

here iz my card, "bites nails"

[Huntar!]

[Huntar!]

Frlf:

 

Hunterb:

 

Ok' date=' here we are, the challange between hunterb, and the challanger, Frlf.

Lets first look at Frlf's card:

His effect is pretty straigh forward, remove to darks from the grave, you get to summon him. If he kills a light monster, it destroyes a spell or trap.

Thats it, lol

While it may seem increadibly simple, thus bad, it's not. It has many ways of being abused, such as, cards that use rfp cards, and heck, the 2ndary effect kicks ass, so, it's a good card overall.

 

Rates:

Name: 5/10 Has a ring to it, but it's not understandable =/

Pic: 8/10 It's cool

Effect: 7/10 Pretty cool to

Grammar: 8/10 Good, but the light monster effect is worded wrong.

Overall: 7/10 It's ok, just a few problems. Plus, i'm a harsh rate, lol

 

Now it's Hunterbs turn:

 

It is safe to say that this card is NOT simple.

First of all, when you summon it, you get to go to you OPPONENT'S grave, and pick a fusion. There is a problem on it's effect, how often is it that a person has a fusion anymore, much less in the grave, typicly, the fusion only comes in the end game. But say you stopped your opponent, you get to choose a fusion. It's what you do with the fusion that makes this a cool effect. You have to pay lp equal to half the ATK of the monster you chose, then you get to equip it to this card. Then you increase the ATK AND DEF of this card by the ATK and DEF of the fusion. See the balance? Want this guy to be way strong? You have to pay a ton of lp. So, you may be thinking, "so what? this guy is drunk with power". Well, hold you midless fools XD

If your opponent manages to destroy this mighty beast, your opponent gets the fusion monster back on there side of the field. This card is really balanced, but, if you look at it, is actually bordering on underpowerd, but it is still increadible.

 

Rates:

name: 7/10 good

Pic: 6/10 works with name, thats about it.

Effect: 9/10 very good

Grammar: 8/10 it's good, but I spot a few ocg problems

Overall: 30/40 or 7.5/10

 

Very good job

 

 

So, your winner is Hunterb, but not by as much as everybody expected, maybe the next challanger can beat him XD

100 points will be sent to Hunterb ^_^

[/quote']

 

Yankee, can I have my rep for winning? It is part of the whole judging concept.

[The Ruby]

~Rating System~

OCG & Grammar: 40%

Name: 10%

Pic: 20%

Balance?: 20%

Personal Interest: 10%

------------------------

Ultimateryan:

OCG: 2.4

*I saw some errors there, for instance, don't capitalize "OPPONENT"!*

Name: .6

*eh...it's "Serpent" not "Sepernt"*

Pic: 1.7

*Pic is blurry...>_>*

Balance: 1.2

*Overpowered...just 3 cards...and Battle Damage doubled...then it gets to attack again...>_>*

Personal Interest: 0.6

*Personally...i like Originality...don't see it here...>_>*

Overall: *6.5*

___________________________________________________________________________

Hunterb:

OCG: 3.8

*Only spotted a couple errors...*

Name: .8

*It's ok...but not as creative as i would have thought...*

Pic: 1.2

*I can't really tell what the image is...*

Balanced: 2

*It's pretty balanced...*

Personal Interest: 1

*The effect was very original...*

Overall: *8.8*

___________________________________________________________________________

WINNER: Hunterb, congratulations you receive 100 Points and 1 REP

[Huntar!]

:D oh yeah! :D

[Frlf]

I want to summon a duel between Ruby and hunterb.. (hunterb is getting a winning row..) ruby is our last hope!! (srry didint meant to spam.. it would be interesting to see that duel ^^)

[The Ruby]

I'll challenge him after friday...

 

i'm busy now...^_^

 

but on after friday...

 

your going down...:twisted:

[Ultimate Ryan]

i challenge frlf!

[The Ruby]

when you guys post your cards...

 

if no other judge is on...

 

i'll rate...

 

just PM me...

[Grayall]

I challange HunterB again...

I think its possible for rematch...

[Frlf]

I ACCEPT YOUR CHALLENGE, TELL ME HOW MUHC POINTS TO OWN YOO..

[Huntar!]

ruby, you are NOT an official judge. ^_^

 

ultimateryan VS. frlf *SATURDAY*

*note that I do not care much who wins. Both of you have a chance.*

 

Ruby_carbuncle002 VS. hunterb *SATURDAY*

*YOU ARE GOING DOWN! THIS TIME.

 

XD

[The Ruby]

Well...i'd like to see you try...

 

Maybe you should try making a card at that moment...

 

then maybe you'll beat me...

 

instead of searching for an old card...XD

[72night]

^_^ Oooo. this'll be fun to judge again. >=d