[Leaderboard] Me VS Tama (Koro-Sensei) Finished

[Zazubat]

1. Normal Leaderboard Rules apply
2. First to 3 or when the contest ends (August 2nd) wins.
3. Writtens are allowed.
4. Votes must be valid
5. Winners gets a point in the Leaderboard.
6. Voters gets likes if I (or my opponent) like the review enough for it to be worth it.
7. Send by PM because of A/B system.

8. Make a monster that supports a Tribute Summoned monster(s)

 

Card A:

Kuraz the Starlight Monarch
Level 8
LIGHT
Warrior/Effect
2800/1000
You can Tribute Summon this card by using 1 Tribute Summoned monster. When this card is Tribute Summoned: You can destroy up to 3 cards on the field, and if you do: each player draws 1 card for each of their monsters destroyed. If this card was Tribute Summoned by tributing a LIGHT monster, apply this effect:
•Special Summon 1 ”Servant Token” (Warrior-type/LIGHT/Level 1/ ATK 0/DEF 0) in face-up defense position. It can be treated as two Tributes for the Tribute Summon of a ”Monarch” monster. You can target 1 Token Summoned by this card’s effect; Declare 1 Attribute, and if you do: That target becomes that Attribute. This effect of ”Kuraz the Starlight Monarch” can only be activated once per turn.

 

Card B:

If you control a Tribute Summoned Level 7 or higher monster, you can Special Summont this card (from your hand). You can only Special Summon 1 “Megabot of Shining Skies” this way per turn. When this card is Special Summoned by its own effect, it gains this effect.
   When Level 7 or higher Tributed Summoned monsters attack, it gains 1000 ATK during Damage Calculation only. Level 7 or higher Tributed Summoend monsters cannot be targeted, or destroyed by your opponent’s card effects. If this card would be destroyed, you can destroy 1 Level 7 or higher Tribute Summoend monster you control instead.

 

Creator Note: The first 2 effects apply to both playes, where the third only applies to you.

[Northern Sage]

Gimme.

[Zazubat]

Gimme.

Alrighty.

[Northern Sage]

Entry sent, good luck.

[~Shin~]

Stop using the system, it always fail.

 

Voting A.

Because: Lights are easier to TS than other attributes (Thanks to Photon Sanctuary). If I understand it correctly, you SS a token before destroying meaning this is +0 in two forms a token or a draw. It drawback is creative, as its both fair/limiting and avoidable. The token effect & the last effect support other LV8 monarchs greatly.

 

IMO B is Xyz fodder at best (and Illusory Snatcher does it better). But from "If this card would be destroyed, you can destroy 1 Level 7 or higher Tribute Summoend monster you control instead." it seems you think of it as tank. Yet what it gives to other +LV7s is not worth the set up it requiers. And since it shoud be run in a deck that TS, why does TSing it leaves you with nothing but a -2 for a beatstick?

What I really want to say is, I think that you choosing to not make it support single tribute monsters is just uninsightful/unwise.

[Northern Sage]

1-0 Card A

Thanks for voting.

[Zazubat]

Any votes?

[Mugendramon]

Card A has too many effects cluttered into one and is a generic +3. That's a bit too much considering the kind of Deck he'd be ran in.

 

The other one is rather interesting, but there are cards that do any of its jobs better. Illusiory Snatch for SSing, and March of the Monarchs for protection. It's flat out unneeded.

 

Card A, then.

[Zazubat]

Card A has too many effects cluttered into one and is a generic +3. That's a bit too much considering the kind of Deck he'd be ran in.

 

The other one is rather interesting, but there are cards that do any of its jobs better. Illusiory Snatch for SSing, and March of the Monarchs for protection. It's flat out unneeded.

 

Card A, then.

I don't really get what you mean with the March of teh Monarchs. The no ED and the fact that it's a Field Spell, where this is monster with an extra layer of protection, but regardless:

 

2 to card A

0 to card B

[Mugendramon]

I don't really get what you mean with the March of teh Monarchs. The no ED and the fact that it's a Field Spell, where this is monster with an extra layer of protection, but regardless:

 

2 to card A

0 to card B

 

March of the Monarchs isn't a Field Spell. And if you run March of the Monarchs and Unearthing, you don't run Illusory. Plus the only Tribute Summonable Level 7 that monarchs can use with the aforementioned kinda still sucks.

 

Also when in a Card A/B 1-v-1, don't defend a card. It makes it obvious that you made it, in most cases. Wait till the votes are over, else you might create bias.

[Zazubat]

March of the Monarchs isn't a Field Spell. And if you run March of the Monarchs and Unearthing, you don't run Illusory. Plus the only Tribute Summonable Level 7 that monarchs can use with the aforementioned kinda still sucks.

 

Also when in a Card A/B 1-v-1, don't defend a card. It makes it obvious that you made it, in most cases. Wait till the votes are over, else you might create bias.

It's 7 and above, might I add. And I get that people would be biased, but at the same time, I think most people who generally vote in the 1v1s, or have seen my cards, know what template I use for it.

[Mugendramon]

It's 7 and above, might I add. And I get that people would be biased, but at the same time, I think most people who generally vote in the 1v1s, or have seen my cards, know what template I use for it.

 

You know that's not an uncommon template. A lot of people use it.

 

You could have chosen to make a written for a change.

 

But you know what, it's as you wish.

 

Also what Deck Tribute Summons outside of Monarchs?

 

Or rather who would run that just for LaDD?

[Zazubat]

You know that's not an uncommon template. A lot of people use it.

 

You could have chosen to make a written for a change.

 

But you know what, it's as you wish.

 

Also what Deck Tribute Summons outside of Monarchs?

 

Or rather who would run that just for LaDD?

Well, I don't see it used very often, it's either the Card Maker, YuGiCo, or MSE I see, though I get your point, and at times I make writtens of the cards I made, just not what I did that day.

 

There're plenty that can Tribute. Anything that's LIGHT or DARK can use Photon Sanctuary and Fires of Doom for their Tributes, so Decks like Photon Galaxy, Blue Eyes and Archfiend can do it. Heck, Steelswarm is an Archetype all about Tribute Summoning, they would probably like this guy. And it's more about expanding the use of higher Level Tribute Summons, and on top of that, this card works (at least is intended to work) with cards that reduce the quired number of Tribute Summons. Anyway, you have made your vote, and I have accepted it, so leave it for now.

[Zazubat]

Bumps.

[Zazubat]

Come on people, this is deader than a cemetery.

[Sander]

As much as I like Card B, I have to vote for Card A, given how it works with cards like Molding the Monarchs, and is searcahble by it as well actually makes the card pretty good. It also does support other Monarchs that require 2 tributes, but it requiring LIGHT monsters to get the token effect will not be used too much.

 

So yeah, Card A gmv.

[Zazubat]

3-0

 

I lose, well, I suppose I do get people's point here. Well, anyway, GG Tama