[LEADERBOARD] Me vs Sora START VOTING

[Northern Sage]

All YCM and Leaderboard rules apply.

-First to 3 votes or most votes by the deadline wins.

-All voters must elaborate on their votes.

The deadline is August 3rd.

All voters get a rep.

The winner gets a rep from the loser.

The condition is to make a Rank 1 monster.

 

My Card:

(Image credits to Buddha)

 

2 Level 1 monsters

If this card would be destroyed, you can discard 1 card instead. This effect can only be activated once per turn. Once per turn, if a card effect is activated by detaching Xyz Materials: You can detach 1 Xyz Material from this card; Negate that effect, then you can target 1 Xyz Monster on the field; detach all Xyz Materials from that card.

 

Opponent's Card:

 

 

2 level 1 monsters
Once per turn: You can detach 1 Xyz Material from this card to target 1 face-up monster your opponent controls; that target loses ATK equal to the ATK of the detached monster. When this card leaves the field while it had Xyz Material, you can target 1 card in your Graveyard; shuffle that target into the Deck, then draw 1 card.

[Sora1499]

Why not, what's the worst that can happen?

[Northern Sage]

Why not, what's the worst that can happen?

Alright, accepted.

Try to have your card in as soon as possible, please.

[Northern Sage]

Cards are up, start voting please.

[~Shin~]

Flusher works without materials, that is always great IMO. But other than that its just [s]a toilet[/s] another xyz hate... Even if Petals is at 1700 would this effect be worth it!? outside Meklords, you would only get ~500. That other effect makes it a possible +0; nice, still returning [b]any[/b] card is iffy. Also, it has a higher ATK than any RK 1/2, but that does not really mean anything. Vote for Petals, because it does more stuff.

[Northern Sage]

1-0 Sora

Thanks for voting.

[Zazubat]

Card A:
While the first card's OCG is totaly horrible, first effect is written as a continuous, the second has targeting the resolution of an effect, I will overlook that, just because I'm nice. Anyway, protection as minus 1, for a Rank 1 monster, probably not worth it, but it's alright I suppose. The effect is pretty nice, while your opponent most likely won't have their stuff out, as it can protect itself, it can hold it's ground until then.

 

Card B:

I dislike 1700 on a Rank 1, that's just not something I want to see, but it doesn't really break this card tbh. The highest ATK on a Level 1 is 2500, but the monsters are not that easy to get out, or are really playable, so only those under 1000 can really be used, and honestly, that decrease is just not worth it. On top of that, the last part needs it to have a Material, and while that means that Grave revival won't be possible, it also limits it. I suppose it will die rather fast anything, so I get the idea. And if anything, it can recycle itself and draw a card.

 

Card B just seems meh to me. Card A is a bit more useful, can be somewhat more control, where B is not really worth it. Card A gets my vote.

[Northern Sage]

1-1

Thanks for voting

[Aix]

Chances are, you are making a Rank 1 with monsters with 400 or less ATK, and in all likelihood, they'll have 0 ATK, so Card B really isn't worth it. Fair Flusher has a really narrow scope of use, but it could be argued that Dying Petals does as well and when Fair Flusher does something, it is something somewhat useful, so vote to Ambrosia.

[Northern Sage]

2-1 Me

Thanks for voting.

[Therrion]

Card A seems nice in a control way, but seems like it'd never actually be worth going into. The card itself boasts a somewhat promising wall, but Slacker does better in that regard. That leaves its control effect, which will next to never happen as an opponent will deal with this prior to using an Xyz Monsters effect. I love that picture, name, and all.

 

Card B is much more useful in my eyes. A sure to die body with a very minor ATK decrease is better then an 1800 that saves itself via discards in my eyes, and the return to draw is never a bad thing. Neutralizes the -1 of an Xyz Summon, and makes for more plays (like, for instance, making a Rabbit active on the same monster for a second time).

 

Card B has my vote.

[Northern Sage]

2-2

Next vote decides it.

Thanks for voting.

[Northern Sage]

Bump.

[Northern Sage]

Bump for more votes.

[Mugendramon]

Alright! Guess I'm deciding this.

 

Let's keep it simple. Flusher doesn't actually accomplish anything as most Xyz can simply run it over before activating.

 

Petals is shit as it does very little  with its effect unless you gave up Wisel, in which case why did you give up Wisel for that?

 

At least card A can float. And that's a funny play on words, there's a floater in the toilet.

 

So there's that. Card A, goodnight guys.

[Nathanael D. Striker]

Alright! Guess I'm deciding this.

 

Let's keep it simple. Flusher doesn't actually accomplish anything as most Xyz can simply run it over before activating.

 

Petals is shit as it does very little  with its effect unless you gave up Wisel, in which case why did you give up Wisel for that?

 

At least card A can float. And that's a funny play on words, there's a floater in the toilet.

 

So there's that. Card A, goodnight guys.

 

Actually, you aren't. The deadline has already passed, and thanks to rule 14 this 1v1 is a draw. How this 1v1 wasn't called beforehand, I have no idea.

 

 

14. If the deadline expires and both people are tied, then the 1v1 must be called a draw.

I. Only exception is if it is 0-0, then the 1v1 has a 24 extension before it is aborted (voided).

i. This is only the case if it doesn't go over the deadline for the Season to end.

[Mugendramon]

Interesting. Imma lock this then.