Banning majorly hated members. [LOCK]

[Organized Chaos]

i do try to improve my grammar/sentrax (whatever that is will google that i supose)

 

just for the record on paper

 

english101 / gramar / spelling is not my fort'e i type fast so i have to re edit to correct that with anything

 

as you can see in my last few threads in r/c there's improvement

 

im improving all the time there people who just want to keep people down see them as targets

 

im also very big on making unique material

 

people catch me while i'm editing my threads/post

 

i mostly likely have the rank of number 1 on the greatest output in rc but due to the fact that im "left brain" there certains things i accel at then the stuff i lack in and requires inprovement

 

many people accel at certain subjects but need help in other

 

right brain people accel in english gramar but are poor in math

 

alot to take to conseration but people fail to do so and will post ranom hate

 

im not mad just want them to stop as it is not good for the forum

 

people have problems there no need to point it out and make a public freak show over it

 

you do not see me post random hate i allways take in conseration other people's situation

 

i do try to improve on my faults as all should

 

to error is human

 

even genuises have their faults one famous rumor that as smart as albert einstein was he was unable to learn to tie his own shoe appearntly thats why he's always shown wearing slipper like shoes where does not need to tie them

 

perfection is a mad man's fanasty

 

perfection is inperfection as any human or thing of human will never be perfect

 

we can not change the past but we can allways improve the future

 

Dude, just because you commented, doesn't mean you have to post multiple sayings that have nothing to do with the actual subject.

 

OT: I think it is a bad idea. At the end of the day, it is all down to individual experience with the member in question. Most people won't use it for "good", they'll use it as some sort of form of revenge. Eventually, it would be like mob-banning with some sort of ruddy hierarchy with certain people at the bottom and certain people at the top with nothing being done to change it.

 

I may be exaggerating a bit but the main jist of it is mods are mods for a reason. Herman, as illiterate as he is, offers his opinion. He may do so in a way that we cannot comprehend but we can at least try to sympathise. He's probably the reason that RC isn't dead albeit it is due to backlash at his comments. He has done nothing wrong yet you people would ban him simply because of his grammar? That is really really stupid. At least he does comment. He might not have as much experience or actual knowledge but by almost prosecuting him for this, realistically, you're comparing him to people who do this professionally, who have a real heart for Yugioh. I'm not saying Herman doesn't but you still shouldn't ban him for it. It's a forum and as long as he is not breaking the rules, he should not be banned. No matter how "annoying" he is. If he does break a rule then please. With all the sincerity of my heart, ban him. But currently, he is not breaking rules, he is simply interpreting Yugioh in a different way to you.

 

Should we really punish a member for having a different view or a different style to the normal way? Because that's the question we have to ask ourselves. Should we be so harsh to literally ban a member for not having good spelling?

 

In my opinion, no. No we should not. I'm not saying we should pick Herman up in our metaphorical cybernetic arms and dedicate a holiday for him. Just understand that he is different to you and that we should be constructive. If you disagree, state why you disagree without having to use foul language or insults. Because currently we are at that point in time friends. A point at where a person is flamed for saying something they didn't know was wrong.

 

My view is that Herman should listen to the requests about ways of improving and if not, a mod should, if they do wish so, ban him. But until we reach that stage, we should not ban him. Stupidity is not a crime, it is a neccesity of life so you may grow and gain new experience/knowledge from your endeavour. That is all I have to say on the matter and if you wish, you may say that I'm wrong. But in essence, you're proving my point. Peace be with you all, have a good day etc.

[Dr. Cakey]

i do try to improve my grammar/sentrax (whatever that is will google that i supose)

 

just for the record on paper

 

english101 / gramar / spelling is not my fort'e i type fast so i have to re edit to correct that with anything

 

as you can see in my last few threads in r/c there's improvement

 

im improving all the time there people who just want to keep people down see them as targets

 

im also very big on making unique material

 

people catch me while i'm editing my threads/post

 

i mostly likely have the rank of number 1 on the greatest output in rc but due to the fact that im "left brain" there certains things i accel at then the stuff i lack in and requires inprovement

 

many people accel at certain subjects but need help in other

 

right brain people accel in english gramar but are poor in math

 

alot to take to conseration but people fail to do so and will post ranom hate

 

im not mad just want them to stop as it is not good for the forum

 

people have problems there no need to point it out and make a public freak show over it

 

you do not see me post random hate i allways take in conseration other people's situation

 

i do try to improve on my faults as all should

 

to error is human

 

even genuises have their faults one famous rumor that as smart as albert einstein was he was unable to learn to tie his own shoe appearntly thats why he's always shown wearing slipper like shoes where does not need to tie them

 

perfection is a mad man's fanasty

 

perfection is inperfection as any human or thing of human will never be perfect

 

we can not change the past but we can allways improve the future

That was the most beautiful thing I have read in my entire life...

[Guest DDae]

Hey. I saw the word perfection without my name in that sentence. Should totally be banned for not understanding that.

I really don't care if people get banned or not.

But isn't it people like you, Darkplant, who doesn't even like CC for the exact stupidity that resides in it?

If it would make the site a lot better, why not.

The only issue with Herman is that he doesn't want to learn from his mistakes, not really that he is stupid. Even though he is.

[Guest Dem The Magic Dragon]

For the Unbanning of certain members, I give my full support. As for banning people on the grounds that the rest of the community hates them... While Darkplant does make a good point, and his argument makes sense, it's not an argument I particularly care to get behind.

Really, I don't have a lot to say on this matter. I'm mainly posting here to support the idea of unbanning the members who both contributed regularly and were overall well-liked and accepted by the community.

[Agro]

In all fairness to those who want Herman banned, I should mention that every post of his I've read in the past 24 hours, which is like 10, I've had to reread it 8-10 times and am still not even sure I understand what he's trying to say.

[Kuri]

This is a very good idea. However warnings and such should be enforced for majorly hated people. And the ban shouldn't be that long or maybe just a ban from posting in certain sections where they are majorly hated. I'm supporting this all the way though.

[Dwarven King]

So let me get this straight. There is a member who disagrees with you on what would have happened in a war if a different course of action was taken (something we can NEVER know who is right on) and has bad grammar. Albeit VERY bad grammar, I'll give you that. But because of those reasons, you want him and ANYONE else you simply don't like or can't get along with banned?

 

*sigh* Go back to your dark little corner and keep quiet. It's a ridiculous idea that should have never been entertained in the first place. <_<

[Guest Izaya Orihara]

Salem Witch Trials comes to YCM.

 

History repeats itself in mysterious ways.

[Legend Zero]

Salem Witch Trials comes to YCM.

History repeats itself in mysterious ways.

Damn it you took my comment. :[

 

And lol at Welche never doing anything.

[Guest Izaya Orihara]

Damn it you took my comment. :[

 

And lol at Welche never doing anything.

You still have the Inquisition.

 

OOH! I got it! We should form a YCM Inquisition! Where everyone that the majority don't like can be put on trial and be banned from YCM altogether! That would be awesome and would prevent any heretics or "Stupid People" from disagreeing with us and we can all live in happy ignorance!

[Dwarven King]

Damn it you took my comment. :[

 

And lol at Welche never doing anything.

 

Hello fellow moving avatar member! =D

 

OT: Just pointing out that if we move away from the "You're banned for breaking the rules" way to the "We don't like you so you're banned" way, everyone will simply become biased and the site will be nothing but a popularity with most people putting on "masks" so as to not get banned. I say most because at least myself would continue to be myself...and I've made a few people mad in the past. But if this were to take effect, I would purposely try to piss everyone off. Not going to lie. :3

[Dr. Cakey]

You still have the Inquisition.

 

OOH! I got it! We should form a YCM Inquisition! Where everyone that the majority don't like can be put on trial and be banned from YCM altogether! That would be awesome and would prevent any heretics or "Stupid People" from disagreeing with us and we can all live in happy ignorance!

1. NO ONE EXPECTS THE SPANISH INQUISITION.

2. I support the creation of an institution to arbitrarily punish and ban members. I would also like to apply for a position in this institution. Preferably one without any kind of accountability.

 

Hello fellow moving avatar member! =D

 

OT: Just pointing out that if we move away from the "You're banned for breaking the rules" way to the "We don't like you so you're banned" way, everyone will simply become biased and the site will be nothing but a popularity with most people putting on "masks" so as to not get banned. I say most because at least myself would continue to be myself...and I've made a few people mad in the past. But if this were to take effect, I would purposely try to piss everyone off. Not going to lie. :3

Maybe we should ban everyone who doesn't agree with Darkplant's idea?

[Guest Izaya Orihara]

1. NO ONE EXPECTS THE SPANISH INQUISITION.

2. I support the creation of an institution to arbitrarily punish and ban members. I would also like to apply for a position in this institution. Preferably one without any kind of accountability.

I call being The Grand Inquisitor.

Now let's round up all the JEW-I MEAN PEOPLE I DISAGREE WITH!

[Dwarven King]

1. NO ONE EXPECTS THE SPANISH INQUISITION.

2. I support the creation of an institution to arbitrarily punish and ban members. I would also like to apply for a position in this institution. Preferably one without any kind of accountability.

 

 

Maybe we should ban everyone who doesn't agree with Darkplant's idea?

 

If we did that, the forum would just be Darkplant and a handful of others. A month later it would just be Darkplant and me using my hacker friends to help me harass him since I would more than likely be one of the first ones banned. :3

[Guest God Machismo!!!!!]

I want to add that a complaint about the site as of late is that it's not active enough. If we're banning people because we don't like them, and people become afraid to post as a result (and they will,) then what?

[Guest Izaya Orihara]

How about we lock this topic for the following reasons?

1. The debate contains no amounts of intelligence in it whatsoever.

2. Darkplant is only doing this because he is angry at Herman and is using this idea as a catalyst to get him banned.

3. This suggestion is not worthwhile and is only based on anger.

4. If this suggestion were heeded, YCM would become a place full of intelligent members getting banned because the majority is butthurt about one little debate.

5. Fidel Castro is in my AVI.

[Guest Hatcher]

I disagree with the idea of doing a "banning by committee" type of thing.

 

I do however agree with the idea of banning Herman.

 

Rule Zero of any forum is simple: Don't make the place worse every time you post. Whether or not it's written, such a rule must always be present.

[Dr. Cakey]

I disagree with the idea of doing a "banning by committee" type of thing.

 

I do however agree with the idea of banning Herman.

Quoting Crab Helmet = slightly ironic, but...

[JadenxAtemYAOI]

How about we lock this topic for the following reasons?

1. The debate contains no amounts of intelligence in it whatsoever.

2. Darkplant is only doing this because he is angry at Herman and is using this idea as a catalyst to get him banned.

3. This suggestion is not worthwhile and is only based on anger.

4. If this suggestion were heeded, YCM would become a place full of intelligent members getting banned because the majority is butthurt about one little debate.

5. Fidel Castro is in my AVI.

This^ Any idiot like me can see why this suggestion is flawed and stupid. The religions we follow on this site have created such a rift religion is practically a no no in general. So what's going to happen if this follows through? LETS BAN ALL THE ATHEIST! LET'S BAN ALL THE CHRISTIANS! LETS BAN STAFF FOR LOCKING OUR THREADS! This site would become much worse and the revenue would drop drastically because with this rule in place new members have to try harder to earn respect and they may possibly quit signing in and posting. So basically, by agreeing with this suggestion you also agree that Will should shut down this site because once people start getting banned people will stop posting.

[The Dark Knight]

 

It has been said before that this would be bad and for pretty obvious reasons. If several members can gang up on an unpopular member and get that member banned, it would be abused like crazy. The problem is that this entire argument is relative to Herman and that's not good. You already have people saying he should/shouldn't be banned while showing their support or dissent for what this thread is supposed to be about. We might as well all be agreeing with the OP if we're all already giving our opinions on whether or not Herman should be banned.

 

I do not support this and I also refuse to say whether or not I'd like Herman banned, because quite honestly, it shouldn't be up for me or anyone but the mods to decide.

 

[JadenxAtemYAOI]

In the words of Oprah

Look under your seats everyone! Free bans for you and your children!

[Dr. Cakey]

You think you could actually get 50 people to ban somebody for being of a certain religion?

 

Just because it's a bad idea doesn't mean it will cause a raging war for the future of YCM.

[Guest Izaya Orihara]

Perhaps we can just do what Adolf1889 wanted and just make the Admin a member and just create ultimate anarchy in YCM.

 

This is the stupidest idea imaginable but you know what? It has way more intelligence than this topic's suggestion!

[JadenxAtemYAOI]

You think you could actually get 50 people to ban somebody for being of a certain religion?

 

Just because it's a bad idea doesn't mean it will cause a raging war for the future of YCM.

You obviously haven't witnessed the rift on this site. Someone care to fetch religion threads that went terribly awry?

[Dr. Cakey]

Perhaps we can just do what Adolf1889 wanted and just make the Admin a member and just create ultimate anarchy in YCM.

 

This is the stupidest idea imaginable but you know what? It has way more intelligence than this topic's suggestion!

Well, no, actually it doesn't.

 

...although actually making YCMaker a normal member...wouldn't change anything, would it?

 

You obviously haven't witnessed the rift on this site. Someone care to fetch religion threads that went terribly awry?

I said 50. Not two.