Jump to content

Pop Culture Anime Contest


Icy

Recommended Posts

Guest JoshIcy

umm... archtype, -1

first card is a 9/10 i like it....

second card wont count....

third card, why would you throw away a good card and spell fodder for that? 5/10....

 

average: 14/20... 7/10.... 6/10....

sorry... but the third card throws it off.... but i will reconsider pending you make

Shihouin Yaruichi or at least show me the card....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest JoshIcy

whoa... talk about a rush XD...

 

Fiend Z

Blastoise has a glitch... there is no pokemon archtype so the cards effect cannot activate. its secondary effect makes VL look like a pipsqueak... 7/10

Aerodactyl, best card there.... 9/10

Tyranitar, should say specifically targets or it will be overpowerd... 8/10

24/30... 8/10...

 

final score: 8/10

___________________________________________

jspamax

they work together like peanut butter and bread... but due to the abuse of the first cards effect, i will say its about a 7.5.... cute cards though...

Ill add a consolation prize for fav cards when i update the list....

___________________________________________

Nelsn3

Archtype... auto -1 from total....

sad as it may be... those cards are rather simplistic.... 7/10 + 1 simplistic point...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest JoshIcy

Cheers for the Positive Review Icy. It means a lot to me.

 

your welcome... ooh and if this were a normal thread i would have said a 9/10...

 

but due to my contest i must rate the way i am....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My Entry

From Xenosaga

 

Credit for image to

Telpsicorei

Credit for image to Telpsicorei

 

ontest.jpg

 

[align=center]This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned by removing from play 3 Machine-Type monsters in your Graveyard. When this card declares an attack, select 1 card by random from your opponent's hand. This monster gets the following effect based on the type of card selected:

-Spell: During the End Phase of a turn this card attacked, destroy this card, and you take damage equal to this monster's ATK points.

-Trap: This turn's Battle Phase ends.

-Monster: Increase your opponent's Life Points equal to the ATK points of the selected monster.[/align]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest JoshIcy

a vast majority of machine monsters are "fodder".... summoning it would be like summoning necrofear right after raviel... but the balance is unreal....

 

normally that card would be overpowerd, but i <3 the balance attempt.... 9/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest JoshIcy

hmmm.... as much as id hate to say it, ive never seen itachi use "shadow clone"....

and your cards rival my own versions... dang lol

sasuke is overpowerd....

9/10...

 

ooh and i will keep adding spaces until the contest due date is over... no real limit...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Itachi used Kage Bunshin no Jutsu against Kakashi. Kurenai commented on how fast Itachi could use different jutsu. By the way, if you're up-to-date with the manga... first, 2000 and 2300 are way too low scores for two of the strongest shinobi in the Narutoverse, and second, Itachi should be above Sasuke.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please reread the card's effects... carefully... Since Itachi has a effect that can be abused, I tried to make him balanced, in my opinion Itachi is still overpowered... Also... Sasuke isn't really overpowered unless he is Special Summoned, because he is pretty much treated as a Normal Monster if he is Normal Summoned... Also, if Itachi and Sasuke's ATK were higher, say 2800, 3000, that'll be incredibly overpowering, since their's effects are so strong if executed right... Then again, I'm still a Level 2 :lol: what do I know? lol... no bad comments on my Spell Card... right? lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Itachi is horribly underpowered for a 7-star monster. Hell, even if he was a 6-star he'd pale in comparison to a decently strong one. Sasuke is... normal, neither underpowered nor overpowered. But honestly, effects aside, it doesn't matter. If you make, say, Naruto, and you give him about 800 ATK for base, then when you make Yonbi Naruto he'd be like 3000 ATK or even higher... and we all know that both Itachi and Sasuke could mop the floor with Yonbi Naruto. But in your cards, the two would need a very complicated action to destroy a 3000 ATK monster, whereas said monster could just wipe them out in one attack.

 

As for Mangekyou, I didn't like it. It doesn't represent the power of the strongest kekkei genkai in the series. But meh. Also, in the text, you have "Sasuke Itachi"...

 

So as not to drift too far from the actual contest, I may post my Yoruichi cards later today. However, if I may enter with an Itachi set instead, I'd prefer that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

^:-< You didn't read my Itachi Uchiha's effect... if what you say about 'Yonbi Naruto' is true, you can instantly activate Itachi's effect, which means that monster will be destroyed if Itachi lasts only for 1 turn... (Also I watch Naruto but I'm not insanely crazy about it, so I don't know what a Yonbi Naruto is, if you don't mind, can you explain it to me over PM? thanks...) And sorry about the typo on the Mangekyou card... I made these cards around 2A.M. so I was barely able to stay awake to see all the mistakes... And by the way, I will end this conversation saying that what you say is right, because I do not want to fight with a Level 4 member, in fact I will say sorry to you for starting a arugement, and please don't criticize

on other contestant's cards, as it is very rude and unsportsmenship-like. Especially if your cards aren't perfect themself, I can find many OCG errors in your cards. Thank you and I will apologize to you for saying anything if it angered you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest JoshIcy

i dont care for insulting another persons cards as long as they are constructive.... and ixigo was constructive, backing up his opinions....

 

but as it stands you have the best cards up there....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...