Jump to content

Yuzuru Otonashi vs. Kanade


Blake

Recommended Posts

[center][center]Conditions:[/center][/center]
[center][center]Make a monster that supports an Archetype[/center][/center]
[center][center]Not a Synchro/Fusion/Xyz[/center][/center]
[center][center] [/center][/center]
[center][center]Rules for voting:[/center][/center]
[center][center]Give a reason for your vote[/center][/center]
[center][center]Do not vote on pics[/center][/center]
[center][center] [/center][/center]
[center][center][size=6]CARD A:[/size][/center][/center]
[center][center][img]http://img109.imageshack.us/img109/5415/267156.jpg[/img][/center][/center]
[center][center] [/center][/center]
[center][center][size=6]CARD B:[/size][/center][/center]
[center][center][size="5"][img]http://img822.imageshack.us/img822/4246/170146od.jpg[/img][/size][/center][/center]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I <3 voting in 1v1s. Allows me to see what people do under pressure.

[spoiler=Card A]
Ah Harpies, they needed the help. The name treating part of the effect ruins the playability of the card since it will share the same ruling as "Haprie Lady 1, 2, and 3." It brings a +2 with it upon it being Special Summoned, which is a bit too much even for an underrated archetype. Also, the last SS clause seems similar to "Glow-up Bulb".

Playabilty: 7.5/10
OCG: 9.5/10
Balance: 8/10
Creativity: 8/10
Name: 5/5
Total: 38/45
[/spoiler]
[spoiler=Card B]
You could have condensed all the HERO types to just HERO. This allows a +1, itself which is not that bad. Did you have Fusion in mind when you made this card? That is what I see, and it is done decently.

Playability: 8/10
OCG: 8.5/10
Balance: 8.5/10
Creativity: 8.5/10
Name: 4.5/10
Total: 41/45[/spoiler]

By my reviews, Card B gets my vote. Also, feel free to question my reviews. It does help the process.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Mr. Striker' timestamp='1315249380' post='5494228']
I <3 voting in 1v1s. Allows me to see what people do under pressure.

[spoiler=Card A]
Ah Harpies, they needed the help. The name treating part of the effect ruins the playability of the card since it will share the same ruling as "Haprie Lady 1, 2, and 3." It brings a +2 with it upon it being Special Summoned, which is a bit too much even for an underrated archetype. Also, the last SS clause seems similar to "Glow-up Bulb".

Playabilty: 7.5/10
OCG: 9.5/10
Balance: 8/10
Creativity: 8/10
Name: 5/5
Total: 38/45
[/spoiler]
[spoiler=Card B]
You could have condensed all the HERO types to just HERO. This allows a +1, itself which is not that bad. Did you have Fusion in mind when you made this card? That is what I see, and it is done decently.

Playability: 8/10
OCG: 8.5/10
Balance: 8.5/10
Creativity: 8.5/10
Name: 4.5/10
Total: 41/45[/spoiler]

By my reviews, Card B gets my vote. Also, feel free to question my reviews. It does help the process.
[/quote]

Just a quick comment.

Card A does NOT have the same ruling as 1, 2, and 3. Those are ALWAYS treated as Harpie Lady, this one is not ALWAYS treated as it.

Vote counted though. ^^ 0-1 Card B.


[quote name='Jord200' timestamp='1315249466' post='5494237']
I would have to say I vote for the first card because, the art is a bit more colorful. It has more in it than a shadowy black figure.
[/quote]

No voting on pictures alone, vote not counted.

0-1 Card B.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Kanade' timestamp='1315249607' post='5494245']

Just a quick comment.

Card A does NOT have the same ruling as 1, 2, and 3. Those are ALWAYS treated as Harpie Lady, this one is not ALWAYS treated as it.

Vote counted though. ^^ 0-1 Card B.
[/quote]

Why thank you very much. The inclusion of the Deck in the clause led me to assume that. If I would change the playability rating, it wouldn't make a difference in my vote.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Mr. Striker' timestamp='1315249766' post='5494257']

Why thank you very much. The inclusion of the Deck in the clause led me to assume that. If I would change the playability rating, it wouldn't make a difference in my vote.
[/quote]

I always thought it was the fact they were ALWAYS treated as Harpie Lady that created that clause, so I'm just going with that honestly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Kanade' timestamp='1315249869' post='5494268']

I always thought it was the fact they were ALWAYS treated as Harpie Lady that created that clause, so I'm just going with that honestly.
[/quote]

I'm not much of a rulings major, but I do understand them. Anyway, I've done my part.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Card B's HeroX5 instead of HERO looks almost on purpose. How can you capitalize in the name but not effect? Also, everyone loves a good ol' generic +1, huh.

...Then again, both are +1s xD

I'm voting for card A anyway, because HEROes are so oversupported it makes me sick.
[size=1][color=#ffffff]btw, this whole thing is painfully obvious. Card A is birdie's and B is Black's, and card B's mistake is on purpose. I'm going to do as you want and give her a vote, though.[/color][/size]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[spoiler='Card A - Harpie Mage']It certainly makes Harpies a lot faster, especially since you can just Reborn this monster and get two more Harpies back on the field. The last effect though kinda killed it. That basically is saying "hey, screw you, my Harpies can't be destroyed, lol troll face." I have to give a -1 to that. Especially if it is only the top card of your Deck.[/spoiler]

[spoiler='Card B - Elemental HERO Sendo']I don't really see Elemental/Evil/Masked/Vision heroes Summoning fast enough for this card's effect to kick in. Sure you can Foolish it and then use Poly to Fusion Summon something like "Elemental Hero Flame Wingman", but then, you're left with a 300 ATK/DEF card that can easily be destroyed. -1 for that. Also, why wouldn't you make Sendo a Synchro Material Monster? Another -1.[/spoiler]

[spoiler='Vote']Card A gets my vote.
Card A: 9/10
Card B: 8/10[/spoiler]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Devil's Advocate' timestamp='1315250649' post='5494341']
hey, screw you, my Harpies can't be destroyed, lol troll face. [b]Le once per turn[/b]

don't really see Elemental/Evil/Masked/Vision heroes Summoning fast enough for this card's effect to kick in. [img]http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20100911231261/yugioh/images/thumb/1/10/ElementalHEROStratosCT07-EN-SR-LE.jpg/300px-ElementalHEROStratosCT07-EN-SR-LE.jpg[/img]

Foolish it and then use Poly to Fusion Summon something like "Elemental Hero Flame Wingman" [b]Why the f*** would you Summon, or even run, Flame Wingman.[/b]
[/quote]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Devil's Advocate' timestamp='1315250649' post='5494341']
[spoiler='Card A - Harpie Mage']It certainly makes Harpies a lot faster, especially since you can just Reborn this monster and get two more Harpies back on the field. The last effect though kinda killed it. That basically is saying "hey, screw you, my Harpies can't be destroyed, lol troll face." I have to give a -1 to that. Especially if it is only the top card of your Deck.[/spoiler]

[spoiler='Card B - Elemental HERO Sendo']I don't really see Elemental/Evil/Masked/Vision heroes Summoning fast enough for this card's effect to kick in. Sure you can Foolish it and then use Poly to Fusion Summon something like "Elemental Hero Flame Wingman", but then, you're left with a 300 ATK/DEF card that can easily be destroyed. -1 for that. Also, why wouldn't you make Sendo a Synchro Material Monster? Another -1.[/spoiler]

[spoiler='Vote']Card A gets my vote.
Card A: 9/10
Card B: 8/10[/spoiler]
[/quote]
Wow, you make MBX look good at the game.

Regardless of your horrible reasoning, I am
No going to dent willy nilly. What do you think, Kanade?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='GoldenMagicMonkey' timestamp='1315250204' post='5494293']
Card B's HeroX5 instead of HERO looks almost on purpose. How can you capitalize in the name but not effect? Also, everyone loves a good ol' generic +1, huh.

...Then again, both are +1s xD

I'm voting for card A anyway, because HEROes are so oversupported it makes me sick.
[size=1][color=#ffffff]btw, this whole thing is painfully obvious. Card A is birdie's and B is Black's, and card B's mistake is on purpose. I'm going to do as you want and give her a vote, though.[/color][/size]
[/quote]

No problem counting this vote. 1-1 Tie.

...Devil's vote is tricky. I mean, it fits the requirements, but it's... just bad in reasoning. We'll talk about it before we count it in or out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pic aside, tho they're both good

Sendo seems useful if you know how to use him right.

Harpie Mage is useful for Harpies, even for a noob. (I'd assume so, since I'm useless in strategy-building and I could find ways to use it easily)


All in all Harpies would be benefit more from Hapie Mage than Heroes from Sendo (less Jaden uses Sendo)

At least, that's what I think.

Sides, reviving 2 harpies at once is smex

And with how easy SSing is currently, it is teh smex >;3

Card A gmv

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...