Machine Gun Soldier / Destructive Summoning

[GlaceEx]

Machine Gun Soldier EARTH
Level 3
Warrior/Effect
Once per turn: You can pay 1000 Lifepoints to destroy all cards your opponent controls, this card gains an extra attack this turn for each spell/trap card destroyed by this cards effect. this card gains 200 ATK each time it attacks your opponents Lifepoints directly. While this is the only card you control this card cannot be destroyed.
ATK/100 DEF/1200

Destructive Summoning Spell
Quick-Play
When you activate this card, destroy all cards you control and special summon 1 Level 4 or lower monster from your deck, hand or Graveyard.

These work great together especially if Machine Gun Soldier is near the bottom of your deck, First attack with all of the monsters you can to deal damage then,use Destructive summoning on your turn, all your cards die, you special summon Machine Gun soldier and activate his effect and deal alot of damage to your opponent.

Are these cards good?

[GlaceEx]

please rate my cards

[Communityreborn]

Machine Gun Soldier is absolutley broken. If you have Machine Gun Soldier, there isn't a reason to nuke with Black Rose Dragon anymore, to waste your Dark Hole, and heck, JD will seem like a chore to summon out. There is just so many things WRONG with it, that it's pretty much an instant ban, and Tradtional Format is screwed because they have to face this card.

Your spell is quite balanced, however, except if you draw it in your opening hand. Seeing that it can be abused to an extent, it would be limited, because being able to summon any LV4 or lower monster is a big help for any deck.

Machine Gun Soldier, no matter how you look at it, is completley broken. Even if you make it so that you pay but one life point to destroy everything, it's still completley broken, especially if you already have a field full of monsters. I suggest you ditch the idea.

[GlaceEx]

[quote name='Communityreborn' timestamp='1313373475' post='5443600']
Machine Gun Soldier is absolutley broken. If you have Machine Gun Soldier, there isn't a reason to nuke with Black Rose Dragon anymore, to waste your Dark Hole, and heck, JD will seem like a chore to summon out. There is just so many things WRONG with it, that it's pretty much an instant ban, and Tradtional Format is screwed because they have to face this card.

Your spell is quite balanced, however, except if you draw it in your opening hand. Seeing that it can be abused to an extent, it would be limited, because being able to summon any LV4 or lower monster is a big help for any deck.

Machine Gun Soldier, no matter how you look at it, is completley broken. Even if you make it so that you pay but one life point to destroy everything, it's still completley broken, especially if you already have a field full of monsters. I suggest you ditch the idea.
[/quote]

it only destroys your opponents cards and the most damage you can do with it is 3600 in 1 turn. and its not that hard to negate.

[Communityreborn]

[quote name='GlaceEx' timestamp='1313444267' post='5445747']

it only destroys your opponents cards and the most damage you can do with it is 3600 in 1 turn. and its not that hard to negate.
[/quote]

Doesn't matter. It just serves as a field cleaner, and nothing more. Sure, it's not that hard to negate, but the chances that your opponent has just the right card to counter you is low. That is what broken is, meaning that it's basically unstoppable, and if it can be stopped, the conditions are too specfic to counter it.