Jump to content

Dumbledore's Army


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 317
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Who would want to kill Umbridge? I mean, she wasn't bad. She had the horcrux on her. And she was without knowingly helping the death eaters. It is really not her fault, thus not having a meaning for death. And the death would not be anything to drastic to the series, since she was only there for mainly one book. The crowd would be happy, but it wouldn't help the story that much at all.

[quote name='☠ΤΗΑΝΑΤΟS☠' timestamp='1312334902' post='5409114']
:D YAY! DD Joined!

I hated how they kileld Alastor Moody! DX
[/quote]
;D You love me, my little onion reaper <3.
I do aswell, but it was needed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Daemon' timestamp='1312334990' post='5409117']
Who would want to kill Umbridge? I mean, she wasn't bad. She had the horcrux on her. And she was without knowingly helping the death eaters. It is really not her fault, thus not having a meaning for death. And the death would not be anything to drastic to the series, since she was only there for mainly one book. The crowd would be happy, but it wouldn't help the story that much at all.


;D You love me, my little onion reaper <3.
I do aswell, but it was needed.
[/quote]


I know but still! D:< I hated her (but I love the b*tchy charcters! :D)

Aww, you remembered. :3 <3

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did state it would be a crowd pleaser, just not in those words. J. K. Rowling always had a knack for making small things bring such drastic change to the story or plot in this case. But, in her appeal, she couldn't and most likely wouldn't of done it since the only purpose that it would of caused would be happiness of the crowd and if you noticed, Rowling wasn't one for trying so hard to please the crowd, but herself and that is why the story was enjoyable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Book 7 has even more child abuse D:

[quote name='Daemon' timestamp='1312336277' post='5409191']
Please explain to me this. I do not quite understand since I never stated i had hate or love, which you said like, for Umbridge.
[/quote]
Well, you said you enjoy child abuse and you dont want Umbridge dead. I put 1+1 together and I got like 2.2 :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Luna Lovegood' timestamp='1312336345' post='5409192']
Book 7 has even more child abuse D:


Well, you said you enjoy child abuse and you dont want Umbridge dead. I put 1+1 together and I got like 2.2 :)
[/quote]
I never said I didn't want Umbridge dead, I would surely be grateful if she was. But it would not be a plot builder for the story. But great math skills. I could never be that good.

[quote name='☠ΤΗΑΝΑΤΟS☠' timestamp='1312336401' post='5409201']
DX Like how fred dies!? :D

@DD: Pretty much. :3
[/quote]
I love Fred's final words :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...