Jump to content

Darkthorne vs. Cybernetic Dragon: GFX.


Draco Straybyrn

Whose is better, based on fair rating?  

1 member has voted

  1. 1. Whose is better, based on fair rating?

    • Darkthorne's
    • Cybernetic Dragon's


Recommended Posts

ok, basiclly i have to things to back me up-

 

first i didn't know what will the ratings be on. i thought he would ask me. i didnt even know we will be judged on borders.

 

i eveused Paint.Net and thought he would use the same so it's fair.

 

tehodis i dont think i deserve the 5/10 on the renders i can show you the orignal and how i rendered and i am sure you woul give me more then 8/10.

 

and background is very complex actually but the banner came super dark so it's not visible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ok' date=' basiclly i have to things to back me up-

 

first i didn't know what will the ratings be on. i thought he would ask me. i didnt even know we will be judged on borders.

 

i eveused Paint.Net and thought he would use the same so it's fair.

 

tehodis i dont think i deserve the 5/10 on the renders i can show you the orignal and how i rendered and i am sure you woul give me more then 8/10.

 

and background is very complex actually but the banne[b']r came super dark so it's not visible.[/b]

Yes, which is immensely important. I think I subtracted a total of about 15/40 because it's way too dark....

And CS3 > GIMP > Paint.net

You would have stood more chance with GIMP.

And a lot of skill to beat Darkthorne. Now it's my turn. >: D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ok' date=' basiclly i have to things to back me up-

 

first i didn't know what will the ratings be on. i thought he would ask me. i didnt even know we will be judged on borders.

 

i eveused Paint.Net and thought he would use the same so it's fair.

 

tehodis i dont think i deserve the 5/10 on the renders i can show you the orignal and how i rendered and i am sure you woul give me more then 8/10.

 

and background is very complex actually but the banne[b']r came super dark so it's not visible.[/b]

Yes, which is immensely important. I think I subtracted a total of about 15/40 because it's way too dark....

And CS3 > GIMP > Paint.net

You would have stood more chance with GIMP.

And a lot of skill to beat Darkthorne. Now it's my turn. >: D

 

nope, actually i dont think i could have rendered with Gimp at all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ok' date=' basiclly i have to things to back me up-

 

first i didn't know what will the ratings be on. i thought he would ask me. i didnt even know we will be judged on borders.

 

i eveused Paint.Net and thought he would use the same so it's fair.

 

tehodis i dont think i deserve the 5/10 on the renders i can show you the orignal and how i rendered and i am sure you woul give me more then 8/10.

 

and background is very complex actually but the banne[b']r came super dark so it's not visible.[/b]

Yes, which is immensely important. I think I subtracted a total of about 15/40 because it's way too dark....

And CS3 > GIMP > Paint.net

You would have stood more chance with GIMP.

nope, actually i dont think i could have rendered with Gimp at all.

Which method of rendering do you usually use?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

DARK

Render Quality: 9/10

Background Complexity/Quality: 8/10

Font Matching: 8/10

Palette Choice (All colors used are in multiple places and blend well): 7/10

Border uniqueness: 6/10

Overall Appeal: 18/20

 

Total Average (X/70, Divided by 7): 8/10

 

CYBER

Render Quality: 8/10

Background Complexity/Quality: 5/10

Font Matching: 4/10

Palette Choice (All colors used are in multiple places and blend well): 4/10

Border uniqueness: 2/10

Overall Appeal: 9/20

 

Total Average (X/70, Divided by 7): 4.5/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ok' date=' basiclly i have to things to back me up-

 

first i didn't know what will the ratings be on. i thought he would ask me. i didnt even know we will be judged on borders.

 

i eveused Paint.Net and thought he would use the same so it's fair.

 

tehodis i dont think i deserve the 5/10 on the renders i can show you the orignal and how i rendered and i am sure you woul give me more then 8/10.

 

and background is very complex actually but the banne[b']r came super dark so it's not visible.[/b]

Yes, which is immensely important. I think I subtracted a total of about 15/40 because it's way too dark....

And CS3 > GIMP > Paint.net

You would have stood more chance with GIMP.

nope, actually i dont think i could have rendered with Gimp at all.

Which method of rendering do you usually use?

 

magic wand, but it's better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

magic wand' date=' but it's better.

[/quote']

Magic wand FAILS.

 

ACCEPT DEFEAT, COWARD. By no means is any respected member on this site going to vote for you, unless to spite me. But, the way the system's set up, they can't even. So bleh.

 

Accept defeat, and then we can have this locked.

 

whatever, but you cant say it was completly fair.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...