Fiery Red vs Gandorator - Votes Needed -

[.P3]

1. All YCM rules apply. 2. Requirements: Make 2 monsters (ARCHTYPE AND
EFFECTS). 3. Winner gets +1 rep and 10 points from loser 4. First to 5
votes wins, voters must give a valid reason why, and not just for the
pic either. If no one reaches 5 votes Until Tomorrow the person with the
most votes win. <br><br>[spoiler=Fiery Red][img]http://img821.imageshack.us/img821/9500/286222.jpg[/img] <br>Effect;
This card gains 500 ATK for each "Harrowed Swordsman" or "Harrowed
Ranger" monster in your Graveyard. This card cannot be destroyed by the
effects of your opponent's Spell, Traps, or monsters. If this is the
only Monster Card in your control during your Standby Phase, it
automatically gains 2000 ATK. When this card is sent from the field to
the Graveyard by your opponent's card (including by battle, card effect,
or by being destroyed), remove this card from play. <br><br>[img]http://img852.imageshack.us/img852/9500/286222.jpg[/img]<br>&nbsp;Effect;
If a face-up "Harrowed Swordsman" or "Harrowed Ranger" monster, except
"Harrowed Swordsman - Kino", is destroyed by battle or a card effect,
you can pay half your Life Points to Special Summon this card from your
hand or Graveyard. Whenever you would take damage from a card effect,
place 2 Harrowed Counters on this card. This card loses 250 ATK for each
Harrowed Counter on it. Once per turn, you can remove Harrowed
Counter(s) on this card to Special Summon 1 "Harrowed Swordsman" or
"Harrowed Ranger" from your Deck, hand or Graveyard, Harrowed Counter(s)
must be equal to the Monsters level. Once per turn, you can select
another face-up monster except "Harrowed Swordsman - Kino" you control
to gain Life Points equal to that monster's Level x 100. Destroy this
card after your second Standby Phase. When this card is destroyed, toss a
coin. ● Heads: Remove this card from play. ● Tails: Increase all
face-up "Harrowed Samurai" or "Harrowed Ranger" monster's ATK by 500
points. [/spoiler]<br><br>&nbsp;[spoiler=Gandorator][img]http://img864.imageshack.us/img864/697/354791o.jpg[/img] <br><br>Effect;
If this monster is Special Summoned from your Graveyard you can Special
Summon one "Storm Affector" from your Deck or hand. As long as "Storm
Affector" is in face-up attack position on your side of the field your
monsters cannot be destroyed by battle. (damage calculation is applied
normally) <br><br>[img]http://img825.imageshack.us/img825/3463/354791.jpg[/img]
<br><br>Effect; This monster cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This
monster cannot be Special Summoned except by the effect of "Storm
Effector". As long as "Storm Effector" is in face-up attack position on
your side of the field your monsters cannot be destroyed by the effects
of Effect monsters, Spell or Trap cards.[/spoiler]

[Valkyrus]

We didn't agree on them being exactly warrior-types though?
Can you fix that in the rules?

Anyways, vote away people~~ ^^

[.P3]

Will Do

[judedudemude]

you guys need to make a poll make it easier to vote

my vote for Gandorator becuase his is not overpowered they are weak but both cards together make a near invincble duo (one in attack mode so that makes it balanced)

red is slightly overpowered with all the effects and counter but i like what you was going for (red yiou wanted it to munch this time) but a for effort

[Wind Road]

I vote for Card B. Considerably better, and it is also a good cycle of effects.

[Valkyrus]

Thanks for the votes guys! ^^
And everyone else please vote as well, we need as many votes as possible!
That makes it 2-0 to me for now.

[n8thegr8]

Um [b]I vote for card A[/b] because I think its a little to easy to get the card B monsters on the field and when you do you almost automatically win because your opponent cannot destroy monsters on your field no matter what. Also I thought card A had a much more interesting effect. However, both good job!

[Valkyrus]

[quote name='n8thegr8' timestamp='1301879030' post='5112746']
Um [b]I vote for card A[/b] because I think its a little to easy to get the card B monsters on the field and when you do you almost automatically win because your opponent cannot destroy monsters on your field no matter what. Also I thought card A had a much more interesting effect. However, both good job!
[/quote]

Thank you for the vote ^^
Okay, current result is 2:1 to Me.

A little correction still, in my case if I pull off both of the cards on my field I still need to have them both in attack position for their effects to work. Also, one of them is 0 atk and even though it can't be destroyed by battle I can still take a LOT of battle damage. Also effects that change my monsters' battle position or returns them to hand/deck can break the combo, so I definitely wouldn't call it an automatic win. I tried to make it less abusable like that.

[.P3]

[quote name='judedudemude' timestamp='1301865435' post='5112106']
you guys need to make a poll make it easier to vote

my vote for Gandorator becuase his is not overpowered they are weak but both cards together make a near invincble duo (one in attack mode so that makes it balanced)

red is slightly overpowered with all the effects and counter but i like what you was going for (red yiou wanted it to munch this time) but a for effort
[/quote]

If you read this effect it's not overpowered, There are 3 down effects
1; This Card Loses attack for each Harrowed Counter on it
2; It is Removed from play after
3; You are paying half you life points to summon it ;S

Anyway thanks for your vote.

[Valkyrus]

[quote name='Fiery Red' timestamp='1301900140' post='5113373']
If you read this effect it's not overpowered, There are 3 down effects
1; This Card Loses attack for each Harrowed Counter on it
2; It is Removed from play after
3; You are paying half you life points to summon it ;S

Anyway thanks for your vote.
[/quote]

Hey Fiery can you change the card A and card B to our names so that it's easier to understand?

anyways, more votes peopleeeee~~~

[Mecha Love]

I think I will vote for card A. The reason being that the cards are, in my opinion, a lot more interesting and original. The effects are better is what I'm trying to say. Card B's are a good idea and I like the pics but they are a bittle simple.

Sorry it took a while to reply to PM Fiery Red! :/

Vite to Fiery then!

[.P3]

It's okay Well 2-2 by the looks of the way it's going the next vote will probably be the decider

[Mecha Love]

Also. Good work to both of you! I hope to see who wins this!

[Valkyrus]

Thanks for the vote Elemental Dragon ^^

Now I hope more awesome people like you give us a vote so it's finally decided.

[Valkyrus]

lol I think it's never gonna be decided at this rate...please vote everyone!

[Valkyrus]

bump

[StealthyTyranitar]

I vote Fiery Read 4 2 reasons:

1: Storm Effector and Storm Affector are handicapped, It's very hard to summon them.

2: Fiery Red uses the coin flip effect, and people don't use that effect often.

[Valkyrus]

[quote name='Kingofmuffins' timestamp='1303000099' post='5144219']
I vote Fiery Read 4 2 reasons:

1: Storm Effector and Storm Affector are handicapped, It's very hard to summon them.

2: Fiery Red uses the coin flip effect, and people don't use that effect often.
[/quote]

It's actually quite easy to summon them if you have Effector in the Graveyard. You can summon both of them in one turn with a simple monster reborn, call of the haunted. monster eff that special summons, etc.

anyways, btw, if you like the coin flip eff you could check out my subtype in my signature, it's entirely based on die rolls and coin flips ^^

so I guess Fiery wins?

Even though if we played by the normal rules that would be me :"o
but since 1 day was too short for a good evaluation of the cards I think now is a better time to end it.

What do you say Fiery?

^^

Congrats on the win~