Jump to content

Creative Challenge Championship I (Tournament is Finished)

Goodnight

By Goodnight
in Finished Contests

Recommended Posts

Goodnight Newbie

Goodnight

Posted
Posted

[spoiler=Rules]

There will be 5 rounds. Contestants will be given 72hours to turn in their card after a new round has started. The exception is the 1st round, which will last for 5days, or until all contestant spots have been filled. Assuming the maximum time is taken to finish the tournament, it will end on March 10th.

 

No fake types or attributes. only cards that could be considered actual TCG cards.

 

A score will be given to each card. You will keep your score the entire tournament and every round will continue to add to your score.

 

At the end of every round, the contestant(s) with the lowest scores will be eliminated. How many contestants that are eliminated will be decided upon once I know how many people will be in the tournament.

 

I will be the only judge.

Each round I will give you something specific I want with a card and it will be your job to fulfill my conditions the best way you can.

Scores will be taken on Originality/Creativity, OCG, Aesthetics and Balance. There will be different sub-divisions of those categories depending on what the specific round's card is.

 

All cards will be PM'd to me. After the round is over, or when I have received all cards, I will post the cards along with their score. Any cards turned in late will result in a score of 0.

 

 

 

[spoiler=Entry Fee/Applicant info]

20 points is the minimum to join. If you would like to make a higher donation, a Ref will be given for a donation over 100. (All points taken for this tournament will be given back as prizes)

Anyone can join, however if you have a post count lower than 150, I will require either a link to cards you have already created, or PM me a newly created card and I will decide to accept or decline based on that.

Warning to the inexperienced; this won't be a simple tournament.

 

 

[spoiler=Prizes]

Prizes will only go to the top 3.

1st Place = 4Reps and 50% of the point pot

2nd Place = 2Reps and 25% of pot points

3rd Place = 25% of pot points

 

 

 

[spoiler=Contestants]

1.TCG Warrior

2. Dingo

3. Spoon

4. .:Kai Hiwatari:.

5. WildAndCrazy

6. thekazu4u

7. }~Gob~Zom~{

8.

9.

10.

11.

12.

 

 

 

 

[spoiler=Round 1]

 

 

 

Round 1 will end February 27 10pm Central Time or once all 12spots have been filled and all cards have been turned in.

Remember to PM me your card and not to post them in the thread.

 

Update: If there is anyone who signs up now, the deadline will be pushed until the same time tomorrow (feb 28th), but there will be no more extensions after that.

 

 

Round 1 Challenge

Make a monster card (not synchro,exceed or fusion) that is harmful to the Black Wing and Six Samurai archtype without using the words "Black Wing", "Six Samurai", "Winged Beast", and "Warrior".

 

Scores will be taken on:

Simplicity:10points

Originality:10points

Picture/Name: 5points

OCG: 5points

Effectiveness: 10points

Balance: 10points

 

 

 

[spoiler=Round 2]

I am giving you the following stats:

 

Regular Effect Monster(no fusion/synchro/exceed/Spirit/Toon/etc etc). Level 4. Attack=4500. Defense=3200.

 

I want you to create a monster with those stats, filling in the missing stats. For its effect, I want you to make this card not over powered, yet still playable. Obviously this card would be OP no matter what given that Skill Drain exists, but for the sake of this round, I'm just going to pretend it doesn't exist.

 

This card's effect cannot include the following:

 

"This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set." and/or "This card can only be Special Summoned..."

 

Scores will be taken on:

Simplicity: 5

Picture/Name: 10

OCG: 5

Effectiveness: 10

Balance: 20

 

This card is due March 2. 10PM CST

 

 

 

[spoiler=Round 3]

I want a monster card that is more dangerous/effective in the hand than on the field, but it cannot special summon itself from the hand(like cyber dragon, gorz, machina fortress) or change the attack of a monster (like Honest).

I also do not was a Darkworld or Fabled monster. Similar effects to them is fine, but that may hurt your Originality score.

 

Scores taken on;

 

Simplicity 10

Originailty 10

Name/Picture 5

OCG 5

Effectiveness 15

Balance 10

 

Cards will be due on March 4 by 10PM CST

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[spoiler=Round 1 results]

Spoon: 34.5/50

WildAndCrazy: 30/50

-Dingo-: 40.5/50

thekazu4u: 37.5

TCG Warrior: 16/50

}~Gob~Zom~{: 41.5/50

.:Kai Hiwatari:.: 0/50 - DQ

Kai and TCG are eliminated from the tournament.

[spoiler=Entries]

Spoon's Entry

234848j.jpg

This card is also treated as a Plant-Type monster while it is face-up on the field or in your Graveyard. If your opponent Special Summons a monster while they control more cards than you do, you can remove monsters in your Graveyard from play whose total ATK is equal to or higher than the ATK of the Summoned monster to destroy that monster and Special Summon this card from your hand or Graveyard. Once per turn, during either player's Main Phase, you can select 1 face-up Attack Position monster your opponent controls and send 1 monster in your hand to the Graveyard to have that monster lose ATK equal to the ATK of the sent monster, until the End Phase.

 

Simplicity: 5/10

 

Originality: 8/10

 

Picture/Name: 4/5

 

 

OCG: 4.5/5

 

Effectiveness: 4/10

It only stops 1 monster from being summoned, which wont help much since the opponent will already have more monsters on the field than you.

 

Balance: 9/10

 

34.5/50

 

 

------------------------------------

 

 

WildAndCrazy

30ku7g5.jpg

 

simplicity: 7.5/10

 

originality: 6/10

 

picture/name: 2.5/5

picture is a bit uninteresting, and name doesn't really have much to do with the effect.

 

ocg : 3/5

 

effectiveness: 4/10

It has way too little attack to be all that playable, and your opponents being able to use the effect limits its playability to no special summon decks, or light decks.

 

balance: 7/10

way underpowered for not being able to special summon itself.

 

30/50

 

 

-----------------------------------------

 

-Dingo-

 

342593.jpg

 

simplicity: 8.5/10

 

originality: 9/10

 

picture/name: 5/5

 

ocg: 3/5

capitalized words everywhere.

 

effectiveness: 10/10

Very effective at stopping blackwings and 6sam, and well, every monster ever.

 

balance: 5/10

can stop the summon of any kind of monster and has really high defense for a 1 tribute. balanced a bit better because it takes up spell/trap zone spots and will most likely have to be set summoned and wait for opponent to attack it.

 

40.5/50

 

-----------------------------------------------

 

 

 

thekazu4u

 

358064.jpg

When your opponent Special Summons a monster other than "Spell Absorbing Lotus" from their hand, you can Special Summon this card to negate the summon of the monster and remove it from play. As long as this card is on the field, players cannot Special Summon monsters from their hand. When this card is removed from the field, remove it from play.

 

simplicity 8/10

 

originality 7/10

 

picture/name: 3.5/5

 

 

ocg 4.5/5

 

effectiveness 10/10

 

balance 4.5/10

It's basically a Solemn Warning that you don't have to set and don't pay a cost for, plus it gives you a 2900def monster.

 

37.5/50

 

 

-----------------------------------------------------

 

 

TCG Warrior

 

268846.jpg

 

Simplicity 3/10

4 effects with multiple costs

 

originality 5.5/10

 

picture/name 2/5

Not a great picture

 

ocg 1/5

 

effectiveness 3/10

Doesn't meet full requirements.

 

balance 3/10

a Fabled monster able to discard up to 6 cards in a single turn is just broken, even though they mostly require an opponent's actions.

 

16/50

 

 

 

--------------------------------------------------------

 

}~Gob~Zom~{

 

139954j.jpg

 

simplicity 8/10

 

originality 8.5/10

 

picture/name 5/5

pic/name effect are all related

 

ocg 5/5

 

effectiveness 9/10

very effective at what it does. If this card actually existed it'd most likely be ran in 3s in machina gadget.

 

balance 6/10

For reasons that made its effectiveness so great, I had to mark down its balance. Also, its guaranteed(minus summon negation) destruction of an opponent's monster with no cost is probably a bit OP.

 

41.5/50

 

-----------------------------------------------------------

 

.:Kai Hiwatari:.

 

no card

 

DQ

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[spoiler=Round 2 Results]

Okay, so after some thinking, I've decided to abandon the "points carry over" thing. Reason being that I assumed I would have a lot more people and with a much smaller number, the gaps in score just start to get to big and then near the end it gets to be less of a competition.

2 people will be eliminated this round, 1 will be eliminated in Round 3, leaving Round 4 to be the final 1 on 1 round.

 

 

-Dingo-: 45.5

}~Gob~Zom~{: 42

WildAndCrazy: 40

Spoon: 36

thekazu4u: 35

 

Spoon and thekazu4u have been dropped from the tournament.

 

-Dingo-

342593g.jpg

 

Simplicity 4/5

Picture/Name 10/10

OCG 4.5/5

Effectiveness 8/10

Balance 19/20

 

45.5

==========================================

}~Gob~Zom~{

139954w.jpg

When this card is Normal Summoned, you can add 1 Zombie-Type monster with 2000 or less DEF from your Deck to your hand. As long as this card remains face-up on the field, you cannot Summon monsters or activate the effects of Effect Monsters, other than this card. When this card attacks, reduce it's ATK by 1500. When this card reaches 0 ATK by this effect, it is removed from play. When this card is removed from the field, it is removed from play.

 

 

Simplicity 4/5

Picture/Name 8/10

OCG 5/5

Effectiveness 8/10

Balance 17/20

 

42

===========================================

Spoon

234848u.jpg

This card cannot be Special Summoned. This card cannot be Tributed except for a Tribute Summon. If there are 9 or less DARK monsters in your Graveyard, this card cannot declare an attack and it loses (10 - the number of DARK monsters in your Graveyard x500) ATK. During each of your End Phases, send 1 DARK monster (except this card) from your hand or field to the Graveyard or take damage equal to this card's ATK. When this attacking card inflicts Battle Damage to your opponent, you can remove 3 DARK monsters in your Graveyard from play to destroy all cards your opponent controls and send all cards in your opponent's hand to the Graveyard.

 

Simplicity 2/5

Picture/Name 9/10

OCG 5/5

Effectiveness 10/10

Balance 10/20

 

36

===========================================

WildAndCrazy

2873y2w.jpg

 

 

Simplicity 4/5

Picture/Name 9/10

OCG 5/5

Effectiveness 7/10

Balance 15/20

 

40

===========================================

thekazu4u

358064e.jpg

This card cannot be Special Summoned. Destroy this face-up card during the End Phase of a turn it is Normal Summoned of flipped face-up. This card is unaffected by your Spell and Trap Cards. This card looses 1000 ATK for each other monster you control. This card cannot attack unless you discard 1 card. When this card attacks with an ATK that is higher than the DEF of your opponent's Defense Position monster, inflict the difference as Battle Damage to your opponent's Life Points.

 

 

Simplicity 3/5

Picture/Name 10/10

OCG 3/5

Effectiveness 7/10

Balance 11/20

 

35

 

 

 

 

 

[spoiler=Finals Results]

Simplicity 10

Originailty 10

Name/Picture 5

OCG 5

Effectiveness/usefullness 15

Balance 10

 

I will mention that because the scores were so close, I had a second judge who judged the 2 cards.

We both came up with the same winner, so here are the results.

 

}~Gob~Zom~{ 44.5/50

 

WildAndCrazy 45/50

 

Guest Judge came up with these scores;

Gob Zom : 51/60

WildAndCrazy: 54/60

 

}~Gob~Zom~{

139954k.jpg

 

Simplicity 7/10

Originality 9/10

Name/Picture 4/5

OCG 4.5/5

Effectiveness 12/15

Balance 8/10

44.5

 

 

WildAndCrazy

ogyser.jpg

Simplicity 9/10

Originality 6/10

Name/Picture 4/5

OCG 4/5

Effectiveness 12/15

Balance 10/10

45

 

 

Points and reps will be given out shortly.

edit: WildAndCrazy, I can no longer give out reps today. I will have to send you your last 2 reps tomorrow.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Goodnight Newbie

Goodnight

Posted
  • Author
Posted

accepted and rep'd

 

A reminder that all cards are due in exactly 24hours. However I have added that if anyone who signs up now(after the 24hour mark) will push the deadline to the same time tomorrow, if they need the time.

The time will not be extended another day however.

 

Gob, I'm assuming you read what the due date is before you signed up, so you were aware it was due today, but if you need the extension I might just increase it now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Goodnight Newbie

Goodnight

Posted
  • Author
Posted

eh, well, I was probably being too picky on Balance. And a few other things.

 

Oh, and I'll say this now; The next round (round 3), will be a special round when it comes to scoring. No one will be eliminated that round. It will only probably be worth around 20 scoring points or less. and only the winner of that specific round will be given the scoring points.

This is to give those who have fallen behind a chance to catch up. Or, it could even just end up giving the leader an even bigger lead.

Again, that is for round 3. Not the current round.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...