Done.

[Smesh]

blah blah first to 3 votes wins, first to post is opponent, the requirement is simple: Make a Level 4 or lower non-Tuner monster. Prize is 1 rep.

 

Cards will be anonymous, send me your card without your name, circulation, or set ID via PM.

 

Opponent cannot be someone I have faced before.

 

kk gogogo

 

[spoiler=Card A]

When this card is destroyed by battle, you can return 1 card your opponent controls back to their hand. If this card is destroyed by a card effect, you can Special Summon 1 "Bionic Piranha" from your hand.

 

 

[spoiler=Card B]

When this card on the feld is destroyed and sent to the Graveyard, its effect is activated. After activation, during this turn, any Battle Damage that the controller of this card takes becomes 0. When this card is sent from the field to the graveyard as a result of battle, when the monster that destroyed this card is sent to the graveyard as a result of battle, return this card to the top of your deck.

 

[Newfie Kuriboh Shark]

ill challenge

[Smesh]

Okay, and I got your card, so gimme a sec to make a card.

 

Cards are up. Vote.

[NobleShadow]

Card A: A bit OP

Card B: OCG error (bad pic but that doesn't count)

My vote goes to Card B

[Smesh]

1-0 B.

 

Btw, when voting, explain why it's OP'd, and explain what the OCG errors are.

[NobleShadow]

Oh sorry

Card A is OP because it has a high defense, and can keep resummoning itself.

the OCG error in Card B is: When this card is sent from the field to the graveyard as a result of battle, when the monster that destroyed this card is sent to the graveyard as a result of battle, return this card to the top of your deck.

I got the main concept though.

[The Great Wolf Sif]

Oh sorry

Card A is OP because it has a high defense, and can keep resummoning itself.

the OCG error in Card B is: When this card is sent from the field to the graveyard as a result of battle, when the monster that destroyed this card is sent to the graveyard as a result of battle, return this card to the top of your deck.

I got the main concept though.

Same reasons Card B has my vote

[Smesh]

I hardly count resummoning itself OP'd especially when it has to be in your hand to be executed.

And that OCG fix is vague.

 

2-0.

[The Great Wolf Sif]

I hardly count resummoning itself OP'd especially when it has to be in your hand to be executed.

And that OCG fix is vague.

 

2-0.

-sigh- First time for everything I gusse -sigh-

 

Sorry Smesh I didn't see The only Hand part my Bad

 

Vote go's to card A

[Smesh]

K then 1-1.

[Guest Zetsubou Black]

Card B is terrible. It cancels battle damage? Cyber Larva does it better, and you get another Larva to boot. Not that Larva is splashable, and neither is this. Why would you WANT it back, especially with such a conditional chance at returning?

 

Also, it's art is horrid.

 

Card A seems underpowered, but more Realistic. I mean, Penguin Soldier does it better, albeit old and gone, and the SS effect is underpowered (Seeing as it has to be in the HAND), so it is really not the best, either. But, then the 2200 DEF helps it, so it is worth it, again, in some decks.

 

Still, Card A >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Card B, so Card a has my vote.

[shelds9]

Both are very playable, IMO. Both can reproduce, but Card B, easier, and it is just a Winged Kuriboh without that effect. Card A is simple and effective.

 

Card A GMV

[Newfie Kuriboh Shark]

Card B is terrible. It cancels battle damage? Cyber Larva does it better, and you get another Larva to boot. Not that Larva is splashable, and neither is this. Why would you WANT it back, especially with such a conditional chance at returning?

 

Also, it's art is horrid.

 

Card A seems underpowered, but more Realistic. I mean, Penguin Soldier does it better, albeit old and gone, and the SS effect is underpowered (Seeing as it has to be in the HAND), so it is really not the best, either. But, then the 2200 DEF helps it, so it is worth it, again, in some decks.

 

Still, Card A >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Card B, so Card a has my vote.

i gave it a 0 damage effect because thats traditional for kuribohs.

[Guest Zetsubou Black]

I don't care WHY you did it, it's not good.

 

Cyber Larva has a damage negating effect when it is TARGETED, not destroyed. You can Normal Summon it, and not worry about damage. Then it recycles itself.

 

And yours is a bad, conditional-recycling, HaneKuriboh, whereas Card A is defense that bites.

[Newfie Kuriboh Shark]

I don't care WHY you did it, it's not good.

 

Cyber Larva has a damage negating effect when it is TARGETED, not destroyed. You can Normal Summon it, and not worry about damage. Then it recycles itself.

 

And yours is a bad, conditional-recycling, HaneKuriboh, whereas Card A is defense that bites.

i dont give a crap about cyber larva! can you stop saying cyber larva cando this better than ur card!

[Guest Zetsubou Black]

Comparing cards to REAL cards shows if it's realistic or not.

 

I'm comparing it to an IRL card that outclasses Winged Kuriboh in everyway, and, as such, outclasses your card. And Cyber Larva is not splashable, really.

 

I don't see why comparing your card to a REAL card is bad. Do you admit your card is nto realistic?

[Smesh]

I take that as 3 votes. I winnerz yey.

 

And don't get mad at Black. He's helping you. You might not like how he's doing it, but he's helping you.

[Newfie Kuriboh Shark]

Comparing cards to REAL cards shows if it's realistic or not.

 

I'm comparing it to an IRL card that outclasses Winged Kuriboh in everyway, and, as such, outclasses your card. And Cyber Larva is not splashable, really.

 

I don't see why comparing your card to a REAL card is bad. Do you admit your card is nto realistic?

i dont. it has the same effect as winged kuriboh. its based off of winged kuriboh. listen, if you dont think i realistic thats fine. but unrealistic meens that it cant happen. which isnt this.

 

I take that as 3 votes. I winnerz yey.

 

And don't get mad at Black. He's helping you. You might not like how he's doing it, but he's helping you.

i dont like the way hes helping me. thanks for asking