Jump to content

Battle Of The Types! - FULL!


Daigusto Sphreez

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 309
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Well, Thermatic hasn't been online since the 3rd, so I'm not sure what's going on, but if it's any consolation I'm going to see if I can keep this contest running in his place, to make up for not getting judging done in the previous round.

 

I'll get judging done as soon as possible, and hopefully have results up within the next 48 hours.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[spoiler=Round 4 results]

 

Swordfire206

 

Name & Picture: 6/10

Creativity & Originality: 7/10

OCG & Common Sense: 8/10

Balance & Playability: 8/10

Effect & Consideration of Requirement: 9/10

 

Total = 38/50

 

Hila Inflectus Equitatius

 

Name & Picture: 6/10

Creativity & Originality: 8/10

OCG & Common Sense: 8/10

Balance & Playability: 7/10

Effect & Consideration of Requirement: 9/10

 

Total = 38/50

 

~Shadow Of Alpha~

 

Name & Picture: 9/10

Creativity & Originality: 5/10

OCG & Common Sense: 9/10

Balance & Playability: 5/10

Effect & Consideration of Requirement: 7/10

 

Total = 35/50

 

 

Eliminated:

 

<}Alpha Frogodile{>

 

Name & Picture: 8/10

Creativity & Originality: 6/10

OCG & Common Sense: 8/10

Balance & Playability: 5/10

Effect & Consideration of Requirement: 7/10

 

Total = 34/50

 

.:Blu:.

 

Non-Entry

 

25/50

 

HadesRuler

 

Non-Entry

 

25/50

 

 

The results may be lower than expected, and I had to work out a few things to make it fit into the judging system.

 

I really want to keep this going, even if I have to give out the prizes myself.

 

I'll have the task for the final round up as soon as I can think of one. :/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You may notice that I'm a harsher rater than Thermatic.

 

Well then, put in a simple way, Vengeful Prisoner has next to no playability at all - rarely will the opportunity arise that you have 10 monsters, let alone those of 1 specific attribute in your Graveyard. Then you have to discard your entire hand. This got 0 for playability/balance. Unplayable and underpowered as hell.

 

Delki needs already established field presence, most likely from Coelecanth, but due to the fact that a large number of the monsters on the field would have effects that rely on the Grave, Delki RFP's 3, loses field adavntage considerably, and the ATK gain really isn't worth the investment.

 

Skilled Warrior is more playable perhaps, but serves only to be a beatstick - destruction effect is unreliable seeing as how it is reliant on Levels.

 

Weaponsmaster is the most playable in truth, as it's SS requirements are quite easy to deal with. However, the equip effect is poor, seeing as how the Archetype revolves around RFP effects, and Weaponsmaster activates when they are sent to the Grave.

 

One of the only cards that would make these playable is Return from the Different Dimension. That card is Limited.

 

The cards have little playability. If you need even more detail, I can give some.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...