FTW vs snowyash07

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

Yep, it's Skizo (snowyash) vs me to make an actually useful AoJ card (besides Catastor, which is debatable).

 

[spoiler=Read This!]

Rules: All YCM rules apply, no spamming, no flaming, no trolling, no +1 Posts, no joke cards, etc.

 

Requirements: Make an Ally of Justice card or Ally of Justice support card that does not specifically target LIGHT monsters.

 

Time Limit: 1 Week or first to 4 votes

 

Prize: 1 Rep

 

[spoiler=Card A]

 

 

[spoiler=Card B]

 

This card cannot be destroyed in battle or by the effects of LIGHT or DARK monsters (damage calculation is applied normally). As long as this card remains face-up on the field when your opponent controls monsters with the same Attribute, all of your opponent's Effect Monster's effects are negated while on the field.

 

[.:Wolf O'Donnel:.]

i have to go with no. 1. its much stronger.

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

i have to go with no. 1. its much stronger.

 

This isn't a vote unfortunately. It needs more explanation.

[TheLegenderyKingVildeChaya]

I think A is better because its pic is MUCH better and both of the effects are pretty much the same so........ that leaves a as the winner

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

I think A is better because its pic is MUCH better and both of the effects are pretty much the same so........ that leaves a as the winner

 

Hmm...Idk whether to count this or not. Could you add more to this? A vote based solely on a pic doesn't count.

[Daigusto Sphreez]

So so hard to choose, both good cards with sound OCG, tasty pictures and effects.

 

I will base it solely on balance given that I put them on par in all other areas.

 

I think Card B to be slightly overpowered, whereas Card A is just right.

 

Card A gets it by a smidgen.

 

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

Alright, that is a valid vote.

 

Card A- (1) Card B- (0)

[The Sleeping Dude]

hmmm....

i vote for card a

because i like its effect most of it came from catastor and good for anti-strong cards like Judgement Dragon, Worm King and other ace cards that is not a non-DARK and the pic is a AOJ-like picture and very unique

card b.. well card b has a good effect but the thing is AOJ is only an anti-LIGHT but since you added DARK on it its pretty bumb the picture is good too but not much of an AOJ pic

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

Thanks for the vote :D

Card A (2) Card B (0)

[Heavens Guardian]

Both pics are really good

Effect are close but card b is overpowered

 

Card A its harder to summon and less powerful effect then b so it balanced

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

I'll call that a vote.

 

Card A (3) Card B (0)

[.Ash]

Bump

[The Broken]

I'm gonna vote for card A.

 

I like where card B is going, but in my opinion, Ally of Justice cards are good against non-Dark attributed monsters so the effect of Enigma (This card cannot be destroyed in battle or by the effects of LIGHT or DARK monsters) really defeats the purpose of it.

 

Card A is better in my opinion because it works with the Ally of Justice cards. The effect relates to it along with other Ally of Justice cards and when it's destroyed, you can reclaim the tuner and use it for another Ally of Justice Syncro Monster.

[.Ash]

So it's pretty much a clean sweep. Just need FTW to validate this before we can reveal the winner.

[Tee-Jaie]

I vote card B, it fits the dark attribute type, which makes it very balanced, and is very creative.

 

Whoops, forgot about Darkmasters vote. My bad.

[The Broken]

What about my vote?

[Tee-Jaie]

My bad, I didn't see it. :unsure:

[.Ash]

Like I said, seeing as how FTW made the thread, just need him to validate votes. Probably valid, not sure about Ryu's, but just need to wait for now.

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

Sorry, I took a break for a few days. Yep, clean sweep for Skizo. My skills must be getting rusty...nah, I lost this one. Good job Skizo ^^