~Hila Nuerfa~ vs ~ks2ill34~

[Hila Ⅰ]

Ok heres like everything you need to know

 

[spoiler=Prize] The Prize is 50 points and 1 reps from the loser

The loser also gets a rep

 

 

[spoiler=Requirements] My opponent decides

 

 

[spoiler= Votes] Votes cannot be based on, name, picture and must have a valid reason to be based on OCG. I as the host have the ability to turn a vote down if it is not detaled enough.

First to 4 votes wins

 

 

[spoiler= End Date] Um... 25th December

 

 

[spoiler= My Card]

This card cannot be Special Summoned. When this card is Normal Summoned the ATK of all monsters on the field becomes 0. Any monster Summoned while this card is on the field also has it's ATK reduced to 0. Each time a Spell card is activated place 1 Spell Counter on this card. During your opponents Draw Phase By removing 1 Spell Counter from this card you can skip 1 of your opponents Phases. By removing 2 Spell Counters from this card you can skip 1 of your opponents Phases and conduct that phase twice during your turn.

 

 

[spoiler=ks2ill34's card]

 

This card's Attribute is treated as DARK, EARTH, FIRE, WATER, and WIND. Whenever a LIGHT, DARK, EARTH, FIRE, WATER, or WIND monster is Summoned, place 1 Spell Counter on this card. This card gains 800 ATK for each Spell Counter on this card. You can remove 1 Spell Counters anywhere on the field, to destroy 1 monster on the field that shares an Attribute with this card except this card.[/

b]

 

[lewis atherton]

ok explain further please i would like to vs you but i have read your info and im still confused since i have never done one before

[Hila Ⅰ]

What do you want to know

[Abe - Demonic Sammich Guy]

just one question. are we allowed to make pop culture cards and insert cards made before?

if so, then my requerments are to make a video game boss character

[Hila Ⅰ]

No i reject your requirements, and new cards only plz

[The Sleeping Dude]

i wanna join lets make a spellcaster-type monster!

[Hila Ⅰ]

Be more specific plz

[The Sleeping Dude]

spellcaster-type monster who is expert in spell counters (e.g. Arcanite Magician)

[Newfie Kuriboh Shark]

you can only give 1 rep as a prize.

[Hila Ⅰ]

changed prize and ks2ill34 i accept, have your card up by tommorow

[The Sleeping Dude]

yes sir

[Hila Ⅰ]

bump

[.Ash]

Hila's Card

Technically, "1st Edition" isn't a type. I think you may have made a mistake there. That aside, the card seems lock-down based, and could has easy hand-control by locking the draw phase. Unfortunately, seen as how it's Spellcaster-themed, there is little way of pressing your advantage while it is on the field, due to it cutting the ATK of everything on the field. I can only see Burn cards profiting from this, something that Spellcasters don't have much of.

 

ks2ill34's Card

Tribe-Infecting Virus was banned for a reason. This in a Spell Counter heavy deck can destroy any monster your opponent throws at you. You can stock-pile it's ATK and use Magical Citadel of Endymion and it's support to systematically destroy any monster. It's BTH-proof as well. :/

OP'd.

 

It's difficult to judge accurately. Hila's gains little advantage other than a shaky Lockdown, whereas ks2ill34's can destroy anything it wants with ease.

 

I vote for ks2ill34, because it provides more firepower for Spellcaster decks.

[Hila Ⅰ]

Thanx for voting, just realised about 1st Edition :) 0-1

[Guest Synergy]

I vote ks2ill34 since the first card is kind of complicated to use and summon and ks2ill34's card is better for a spellcaster type deck i hope this counts

[Hila Ⅰ]

More detail plz eg. Why is mine complicated to use and why is ks2ill34's card better for a Spell caster type deck

[Guest Synergy]

spellcaster decks aren't based on skipping phases and your card is complicated because if you skipped your opponents end phase does that mean he couldn't end his turn

[The Sleeping Dude]

@synergy more details pls there must be a reason why hila's card is complicated and mine is good for spellcasters?

[Daigusto Sphreez]

I vote for Hila Nuerfa

Reason: Love the effect 'ATK of all monsters on the field becomes 0.'

I also like the skipping phase idea too, just because its a spellcaster it doesnt have to be used with spellcaster decks..

The picture is pretty dam nice too and overall its not to Overpowered.

 

I like the other card too, but its a bit overpowered and not as original as the first card.

 

[Hila Ⅰ]

1-1 for now, until synergy gives a good enough reason

[The Sleeping Dude]

so how many votes to win?

[The Sleeping Dude]

bump

[Xguy]

i vote for the 2nd card. it is more creative and usefull.

[The Sleeping Dude]

is that acceptable hila?

anyways bump

[Hila Ⅰ]

you have won anyway, deadline has passed