Skizo vs cornholio2007 [FINISHED]

[snowyash]

This is me vs my dear brother, who took it upon himself to challenge his card making abilities. I will only be accepting votes with at least some degree of detail, and anything primarily focused on images or names will not be accepted.

 

We'll go until someone has 5 votes.

 

The only card requirement is that it be Machine-Type, so interpret the cards at your leisure.

 

[spoiler=My Card]

Lore

While this card is face-up on your side of the field, you can discard 1 card in your Hand and designate 1 Phase. During your opponents turn, they skip the designated Phase. During your next turn, you must also skip the designated Phase.

 

 

 

[spoiler=cornholio2007's Card]

Lore

Once per turn during your main phase 2, while this card is face up on your side of the field, you can special summon 1 machine-type with 1500 ATK or less to your opponents side of the field. When this card destroys a machine-type monster your opponent controls, increase your life points by 200 points.

 

 

 

Score:

 

Skizo 5 - cornholio2007 2

[Abe - Demonic Sammich Guy]

i'll vote 4 skizo

the effect is not seen in many a card and the ocg is a tad better

[Newfie Kuriboh Shark]

i vote for cornholio.

 

ok ocg, more descriptive, and more usefull

 

how many votes to win anyway?

 

also, brother vs. brother. this will be good

[snowyash]

@abethedemon

 

We both just about agreed that your vote is accepted. Thanks for voting.

 

1-0 to Skizo.

 

@newfie shark

 

Thanks for the vote. We'll be going until one of us gets 5 votes.

 

1-1

[ninjarainbowcloud6!]

I vote for skizo more creative effect and better OCG

[snowyash]

2-1 to me.

 

Thanks for the vote.

[·Toot]

i vote 4 skizo

he has a better effect

better OCG

and a slightly better pic

sorry cornholio but skizo gets my vote

[snowyash]

Thanks for voting iRiolu!.

 

Thats 3-1 now.

[Serenity the Candyman]

I vote for skizo's. The card has better ocg and a more of a creative effect of shutting down a phase. the other card allows you to summon monsters for your opponent during your 2nd main phase. You made it easier for your opponent to summon that lv 8 monster. if it was the 1st main phase, then that would be different

[snowyash]

Thanks Candy. For any other potential voters, this is a good example for a reason.

 

Skizo 4 - cornholio2007 1

[TheComposer]

Well I found OCG errors in both cards, but more so in Cornhlio's. I think Skizo's is slightly more op'ed than cornholio's, so for that, I vote for cornholio, because I always rate effect>OCG.

[snowyash]

OP'd how? If you can explain, I'll let you have that.

[TheComposer]

If you can have them skip a phase with good cards in your hand, it could give you an extra turn to set up your field for an onslaught.

[Techi☺]

This was a fairly close match up. They both are pretty good cards with cool pics. The card effects both made sense and the names were not something retarted like: "fejfoi340j" <--- I have seen something like that before...)

The attack strength's and def were pretty well set. So... I'm sorry to say this, but Cornholio get's my vote because it feels slightly less op... Yes... this vote was THAT DAMN close...

[snowyash]

It doesn't negate the turn. There's a Main Phase 1 & 2 for your opponent to play whatever.

Did you read the effect?

[TheComposer]

If you negate the battle phase, it gives you a turn to set up.

[Serenity the Candyman]

but you also lose you battle Phase, which gives your opponent the same oppotunity

[TheComposer]

BUT, if you have all the cards you need, it could become to big of a game changer.

[Serenity the Candyman]

same goes for your opponent. You never know if they have the right cards for such a situation.

[TheComposer]

I EXPLAINED MY VOTE! WHAT MORE DO YOU PEOPLE WANT!!

[Guest Synergy]

i vote for skizo since the effect is more creative. Also it can help you in a jam like if your opponent controls a monster with high ATK and a red dragon archfiend then the red dragon archfiend would destroy the other.

[snowyash]

@composer

 

And we dismantled your reason due to it being rather... weak.

[Serenity the Candyman]

congrats for "winning" this battle Skizo

[snowyash]

Let's overview.

 

@Composer, your vote is given. Despite your reasons being flawed, you did attempt to give a good reason. This is merely out of pity.

 

@techi, Your vote is not given due to the same reason Composers was originally disallowed.

 

@synergy, vote accepted.

 

Final result,

 

Skizo 5 - cornholio2007 2

 

Edit: Although, looking back I am tempted to cut out ninjarainbowcloud6's vote for similar reasons.