LOCK Cherry Wins

[Guest ~Cherry~]

Rules:

All YCM rules apply, no spamming/trolling, etc. You know the drill.

Votes must have a good reason, otherwise, it isn't a valid vote.

 

Prizes:

1 Rep to the winner.

 

Card Requirements:

- Make a Synchro Monster that isn't Generic

- Give the monster an effect to protect itself in some kind of way

 

Time Limit:

Contest ends in 5 days, or until someone gets 5 Votes.

 

Cards:

 

Andx's Card

Collector Of Divided Souls

1 Tuner + 1 or more non-Tuner Gemini monsters

This card is treated as a Normal Monster while face-up on the field or in the Graveyard. While this card is face-up on the field, you can Normal Summon it to have it be treated as an Effect Monster with this effect:

-When this card is successfully Normal Summoned, all face-up Gemini monsters on the field are treated as Effect Monsters and gain their effects. When a face-up Gemini Monster you control is destroyed and sent to the Graveyard, treat that monster as an Equip Spell and equip it to this card. This card gains 200 ATK and DEF for every Gemini Monster equipped to it. If this card would be destroyed by a card effect you can remove from play all Gemini Monsters equipped to this card to negate the activation of the effect and destroy the card.

 

~Cherry~'s Card:

Cybernetic Sky Titan

1 Machine-Type Tuner + 2 or more non-Tuner monsters

When this card is Synchro Summoned, destroy up to 3 cards on the field. As long as 1 of those destroyed cards are in either players Graveyard, this card can attack twice per turn and cannot be destroyed by battle. If this card attacks your opponent directly while this effect is in use, the damage is halved.

 

Go Go Go!

[Guest Tainted Black]

I'mma go... Andx.

 

His card seems like a very good card for Geminis. It also serves as destruction negation. In the end. this card completely helps Gemini monsters.

 

Cherry-Senpai's card is good, Andx's is just better.

 

Side note: Man, Andx has a Gemini fetish XD

[Andx]

Side note: Man, Andx has a Gemini fetish XD

Fun deck is fun. But I would hardly call it a fetish. lol

 

Just wanted to make a Gemini Synchro to overly complicate the effect try and make something different.

[Sploda]

I'm going to vote Cherry

 

While Andx did do an excellent job with his OCG and he was more original, his card is very limited in it's application while Cherry's would be useful in most decks. Also her pic is great.

[Guest Tainted Black]

Also her pic is great.

While this is not his FULL reasoning... I really hate this reasoning =/

[Spoon]

Hands down Andx.

 

The concept is awesome, Gemini's need more support like that and this one does it in a very creative and effective way as no other I'd say. There's not much more to say, it's original, the picture is... just meh, but in this case, it doesn't really matter.

Cherry's card is... more generic (in another way as it is meant in the requirements), therefor more useful, but way less creative.

Therefor, yeah, vote to Andx.

[Guest ~Cherry~]

Cherry's card is... more generic therefor more useful, but way less creative.

 

I thought my card was creative...

 

Come on guys. We need more votes than this.

[Sploda]

@Black

I'm sorry but if you have a S*** for a pic and awesome OCG while the other one managed to balance both, I vote for the other.

 

The picture is just as important as the OCG, this is why I cannot stand the Written Card section.

[Guest ~Cherry~]

The picture is just as important as the OCG, this is why I cannot stand the Written Card section.

 

Sorry, even if it is your opinion, I have to say something.

 

The picture shouldn't influence your opinion in the slightest. It's the card's usefulness and effect that should matter.

[Guest Tainted Black]

Senpai got it spot on. The pic is not the most important thing. In fact, it's only there like Flavour Text is on Vanillas.

[Andx]

Funny how it seems like I'm the only one who actually likes my card's pic.

 

Anyway, thanks so far to all the voters. (Though a few more than 3 would be nice, lol)

[Mugendramon]

Like said before, both cards are quite good and original. BUT! I must also say, Cherry's card is far more generalized, and works both as a field clear and a beatstick, as well as not being able to be destroyed by battle.

 

Andy's card on the other hand, has some serious disadvantage: It will take up your Spell and Trap card Zone in order to gain imperviousness to Spell & Trap destruction, and a slight ATK bonus. Though it also provides a beatstick.

 

OCG-speaking, I think Andy's is a bit better. Not much though. In terms of picture... meh. Cherry's looks more like a pic you would find in an actual card than Andy's, but meh.

 

Rounding up; ~Cherry~'s is my choice.

[Guest ~Cherry~]

Andy's card on the other hand, has some serious disadvantage: It will take up your Spell and Trap card Zone in order to gain imperviousness to Spell & Trap destruction

 

I kinda thought that'd be a fair deal.

Give up Spell and Trap card zones for Spell and Trap card protection.

 

We need more votes. ><

[Mugendramon]

It's kind of Ironic, in some sense. 8D

 

AND all of those equipped monsters would be Tributed. Regardless if there is 1 or 5 equipped monsters.

[Sploda]

@Cherry

I'm not saying it is the MOST important part of the card, but it is still factored in by me. I've lost many contests because I was to lazy to look for a decent card picture.

 

And these weren't regular 1v1 contests either.

[Andx]

I find the idea of this ending in a tie funny.

 

Of course now that I say that someone's going to come in to vote.

 

Anyway, a little BUMP for this contest in the hope to see if someone won't break the tie.

[Guest ~Cherry~]

It's been 5 Days, so this should've been over.

But seeing as it's currently a tie, we need a tie-breaking vote.

So someone vote, damn it.

[Aesirson]

Cherry's pic is more awesome, but the pic isn't important so let's look at playability and creativity instead.

 

It's a hard decision, but I think I'll go with Cherry.

 

While Andx card is awesome and creative it's only a beatstick useless in a non-Gemini.dek (but still, since it requires a Gemini non-Tuner I don't think it would be run outside Geminis anyway) while Cherry's card could be run in any .dek that uses Machine-type Tuner monsters.

 

Also; Poll please?

[Andx]

Well it took the full time but fun match Cherry. I've given you your rep in the first post.