Smesh Vs. AxManBoy VOTE

[Smesh]

K, I go against someone, first to post gets it. Opponent calls requirements. If I don't like the requirements, I decline them.

 

First to 3 wins.

 

Smesh's Card

 

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set, except by it's own effect. You can Normal Summon this monster from your hand by removing 4 DARK monsters in your Graveyard from play. As long as this card is on your field, monsters you control, except this one, have their ATK decreased by half. This card's ATK and DEF are equal to the total combined ATK and DEF of all monsters your opponent controls. If your opponent controls only 1 monster, increase this card's ATK by 100.

 

AxManBoy's Card

 

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card cannot be Special Summoned except by Tributing 2 monsters whose total Level equal to or more than this card (max 12). This cards Original ATK is equal to the total Level of the monsters used to Summon this card x 300. This card can attack your opponent directly. If it does, destroy this card and all Spell and Trap Cards on the field. Your opponent gain 100 Life Points for each card destroyed by this effect. If this card is destroyed by it's own effect, your opponent cannot attack for 2 turns after this effect is activated.

[Squirrel Girl]

A Trap Card that support plants. The name must include "Wall"

[Smesh]

Eh...Me no likey.

 

I'll go against you though.

[Squirrel Girl]

So I am accepted, then here is my card:

 

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card cannot be Special Summoned except by Tributing 2 monsters whose total Level equal to or more than this card (max 12). This cards Original ATK is equal to the total Level of the monsters used to Summon this card x 300. This card can attack your opponent directly. If it does, destroy this card and all Spell and Trap Cards on the field. Your opponent gain 100 Life Points for each card destroyed by this effect. If this card is destroyed by it's own effect, your opponent cannot attack for 2 turns after this effect is activated.

[Smesh]

><

 

Since I fail at support, I said I wanted it changed.

 

New requirement: Fiend with ? ATK and ? DEF. Must be Level 8-10

[Squirrel Girl]

Ok I edit the post.

[Smesh]

If anyone calls my card OPd, they haven't seen The Wicked Dreadroot.

[Squirrel Girl]

OPed ^^ JK I dont call your card OPed

 

Start Vote

[Smesh]

I hate bumping.

[Squirrel Girl]

VOTE PEOPLE, VOOOOOTE

[Buttercup]

AxManBoy's has shenanigans with Phantom of Chaos.

 

So go AxManBoy.

[Smesh]

1-0 Ax.

[Sploda]

I vote Smesh for better OCG and because it would be more useful in a generic deck as a power player.

[Guest Tainted Black]

Smesh.

 

Ax's is pretty darn broken, even with the +LP. Its AT LEAST 2700 points of direct attack. Max reimbursement is 1100. So, it's a 2500 ATK direct ATK (Potentially) that destroys all S/T. Also, as Warjacksworth pointed out, too Phantom abusable.

[Smesh]

2-1 Meh.

[Mugendramon]

The Life Gain effect in Ax's card is a bit random imo...

 

Smeshy, your card is quite situational, best fitting in a Swarming Deck. Zombies would be likely, because they are mostly DARK.

 

This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set, except by it's own effect. You can Normal Summon this monster from your hand by removing 4 DARK monsters in your Graveyard from play. As long as this card is on your field as you control this card, monsters you control, except this one, have their ATK decreased by half halve the ATK of all monsters you control, except this card. This card's ATK and DEF are equal to the total combined ATK and DEF of all monsters your opponent controls. If your opponent controls only 1 monster, increase this card's ATK by 100.

 

I think that fix is correct.

 

As for Axy's,

 

EX: Tribute 2 Level 6 for a 3600 Direct Attack, granted your opponent won't counter it? Risky.

 

So my vote goes to Smeshy.

[RedRuler]

AxManBoy's card can be OP'd, so i vote for Smesh, his card has also a more creative effect.

[Smesh]

I win ^^

[Squirrel Girl]

Congrats smesh