Phantom Vs. Archwing FINISHED LOCK PLZ

[Phantom M.C.]

i haven't been doing well in 1on1 contests, but oh well, here's another one

 

Rules:

All YCM rules apply

Voters must have a valid reason

First to 3 votes win

Winner gets 1 rep from the loser

 

Reuirements:

Make an "Ancient Gear" SUPPORT, it must be a monster.

 

[spoiler=Galadrien's Card]

Lore:

While you control another face-up "Ancient Gear" monster, this card cannot be destroyed during the Battle Phase (damage calculation is applied). While this card is in the Graveyard as the result of a Tribute Summon, you can treat this card as up to 2 Tribute monsters for the Tribute Summon of an "Ancient Gear" monster, then remove this card from play.

 

 

[spoiler=Archwing's Card]

This card cannot be attacked if there is another "Ancient Gear" monster on your side of the field (Other than Ancient Gear Mechanic). During your Main Phase you can tribute up to 3 "Ancient Gear" monsters on your side of the field to Special Summon 1 "Ancient Gear" monster whose star are equal to the number of total stars on the monster(s) tributed.

 

 

(if you don't know what the Ancient Gears are, go look them up before you vote)

[Archwing]

Ive never really tried 1 vs 1's so dont expect much

actually this well be my first time :D

[Phantom M.C.]

ok, post your card first

[Archwing]

Ugh sorry that took so long, i had a card ready but the pic was gone so i had to start from scratch...

This card cannot be attacked if there is another "Ancient Gear" monster on your side of the field (Other than Ancient Gear Mechanic). During your Main Phase you can tribute up to 3 "Ancient Gear" monsters on your side of the field to Special Summon 1 "Ancient Gear" monster whose star are equal to the number of total stars on the monster(s) tributed.

 

I think i messed up on the OCG D:

So expect an easy win ;D

[Phantom M.C.]

its not the ocg archy......oh well, start voting

[StealthyTyranitar]

I VOTE FOR GALDERIAN BECAUSE HIS EFFECT ISNT AS POINTLESS AS THE OTHER CARDS EFFECT

[Spoon]

I VOTE FOR GALDERIAN BECAUSE HIS EFFECT ISNT AS POINTLESS AS THE OTHER CARDS EFFECT

 

Neither of the effects is pointless... and you should really do something about your keyboard... gnah, didn't I want to ignore you? It's hopeless I guess :(

 

Anyways, my vote goes to Archwing. The Ancient Gear Archetype isn't really known for it's swarming capabilities, but with this, they pretty much could be. With quite some high level monsters to choose from and Ancient Gears en masse, this could be like a factory to ownage.

 

Galadrien's card isn't all that bad either, a Tribute Machine par excellance, fits the Junkyard name pretty nicely, but I think to really hold up, it should have done something different than what the archetype already does.

 

What I miss on both cards is the specialty of the archetype, negating the activation of Spell and Trap Cards. What both cards could've done was preventing the opponent from using said cards in relation with the Special/Tribute Summoning, that would've enhanced both cards imho.

It's a close call, and I have to go by my personal preferance here because I can't really say that one card or the other is objectively "better".

 

So long,

 

Spoon

[Phantom M.C.]

actually, as much as i don't want to say it, archy's card is pointless. the whole point of the ancient gears archetype is "tribute summon". the high level ancient gear monsters cannot be special summoned, and the 2 gadjiltron monsters only gain their effects when they're tribute summoned. archy's card however deals with special summon, which makes it pointless.

[Spoon]

actually, as much as i don't want to say it, archy's card is pointless. the whole point of the ancient gears archetype is "tribute summon". the high level ancient gear monsters cannot be special summoned, and the 2 gadjiltron monsters only gain their effects when they're tribute summoned. archy's card however deals with special summon, which makes it pointless.

 

Oh... I see... that's when you think you know something about the TCG, and in fact you don't :( Well then, you're right about it, if I can, I'll take my vote off and rather not vote for anybody. I still like the idea though :/

[Phantom M.C.]

don't worry, a knowledge of TCG isn't really needed to make good cards;)

[Archwing]

yah, i didnt think this one through a ton, like i said, i had a card allready done from quite awhile ago but the pic was bad (deleted from photobucket) and i couldnt find a new one.

I guess i was going for the idea tribute 2 ancient gears and special summon one of the weaker gears like soldier, knight or even just use it to turn ancient gears into ancient gear cannons ect.

I thought it would be OPed if it could summon the stronger ones AND couldnt be attacked.

'~'

Like i said i dont expect to win, but calling it pointless hurted mai feelins D': ~Jk

[Phantom M.C.]

don't worry archy, i run an ancient gear deck, so its only natural that i know how to make good supports for them

 

anyways, 1-0 galadrien

[Phantom M.C.]

bump

[Phantom M.C.]

bump vote

[hexcalibrate]

i vote for galadien, his is a machine type ancient gear, which allows it to fit in with most of the machine supports in the average AG deck, it also keeps in mind that ancient golem (pretty much the main card) can't be specail summoned so his is used for tribute.

 

i have no problem with eithers ocg or pic, and i don't think either are OP'd

[Phantom M.C.]

2-0 galadrien

[Phantom M.C.]

bump vote

[Phantom M.C.]

le bump

[Phantom M.C.]

bump.

[Phantom M.C.]

bump

[Phantom M.C.]

i command you to vote

[Phantom M.C.]

bump

[Dark Glass]

Phantom M.C. GMV, like they said before Archwing's card is pointless because high level ''Ancient Gear'' monsters cannot be Special Summoned.

[Phantom M.C.]

and there's the final vote. good match archy.

 

lock plz

[Smesh]

This is now over and unofficially locked. Please do not post anymore.