Smesh Vs. Chedbonlahor VOTE

[Smesh]

This is between me and Chedbonlahor. First to 3 votes wins a rep.

 

Requirements:

-Burn

-Trap

-Involve hands

 

My Card

During your End Phase, your opponent declares 1 Card Type. (Monster, Spell, Trap) If they call it right, inflict 500 damage to your Life Points. If they call it wrong, inflict 500 damage to their Life Points and remove the card from play. The card is returned to their hand during your next Standby Phase.

 

Chedbonlahor's Card

Place 1 Spell Counter on this card during each of your and your opponent's Standby Phases. When this card has 8 Spell Counters on it, destroy it and inflict 3000 as direct damage to both players' Life Points. When this card is activated each player discards or draws cards until both players have 4 cards in their respective hands. When a player holds 7 cards in their hand, inflict 1500 as direct damage to the opposing player's Life Points and destroy this card. As long as this card remains face-up on the field either player is permitted to select and activate any of the following effects during their turn:

-Pay 500 Life Points to discard 1 card at random from your opponent's hand

-Increase your Life Points by 500, your opponent must draw one card from their Deck

[Newfie Kuriboh Shark]

i gotta go with smesh. i think chedbonlahors card has a better pic but it is to detailed.

 

smesh has an ok pic but at least you can read what it says. no offense chedbonlahor

[Spoon]

I think on Smesh's card something is missing... eh... you only declare a card type, but not the card that has to be picked (from your hand/your opponents hand maybe?). Anyways, regardless of that part, my vote goes to chedbonlahor.

 

I like the overall idea and the tactical situations it could provoke, though you should limit the use of that last effect to "once per turn". Since it works for both players, it could've also been a nice Field Spell... anyways: interesting idea, therefor my vote.

[StealthyTyranitar]

the vote goes to smesh for the same reason as newfie

 

 

[NightGuardian1764]

You guys (Ultima and newfile) just lazy to read the lores.

[Smesh]

i gotta go with smesh. i think chedbonlahors card has a better pic but it is to detailed.

 

smesh has an ok pic but at least you can read what it says. no offense chedbonlahor

 

Need a better reason.

 

I think on Smesh's card something is missing... eh... you only declare a card type, but not the card that has to be picked (from your hand/your opponents hand maybe?). Anyways, regardless of that part, my vote goes to chedbonlahor.

 

I like the overall idea and the tactical situations it could provoke, though you should limit the use of that last effect to "once per turn". Since it works for both players, it could've also been a nice Field Spell... anyways: interesting idea, therefor my vote.

 

Fair enough.

 

the vote goes to smesh for the same reason as newfie

 

Better reason pl0x

 

You guys (Ultima and newfile) just lazy to read the lores.

 

Vote?

[NightGuardian1764]

I vote Smesh.

 

Ched's cards efect is kinda......OPed.

[Smesh]

1-1

[~Hado~]

Vote 2 iSmesh!

Chedbonlahor's card is weird, and a bit tedious. I could toy with my opponent for hours with that card, and it takes too long to do much.

iSmesh!'s card is fun to play. I like those kind of cards that make turns less boring.

[Smesh]

I guess that'll work.

 

2-1 Smesh

[chedbonlahor]

i gotta go with smesh. i think chedbonlahors card has a better pic but it is to detailed.

 

smesh has an ok pic but at least you can read what it says. no offense chedbonlahor

 

Did you read it then?

[RedRuler]

Chedbonlahor's card has a complicated effect, but in Smesh's card there is something missing, like Spoon said,

as it doesn't say from where you pick the card.

 

Conclusion: I vote for Chedbonlahor.

[chedbonlahor]

2-2 it's turning into a classic

[Smesh]

I thought it would be common knowledge :/ end phase > draw phase.

I want a rematch whoever wins my card sucks.

[chedbonlahor]

I thought it would be common knowledge :/

I want a rematch whoever wins my card sucks.

 

We will have a rematch at some point, you are my favourite member to compete agaisnt you know

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

Alright, it's my turn to vote. I vote for Smesh because of 2 reasons:

 

1. Ched has some OCG errors

2. I think that Ched's card is OP'd because somebody is gonna lose at least 4500 life points, quite possibly more.

[Newfie Kuriboh Shark]

You guys (Ultima and newfile) just lazy to read the lores.

 

we just think its to descriptive. were not lazy but if that was an official yugioh card i dont think you would be able to read it

[Smesh]

Thank you for voting. Nice match Ched.

[Newfie Kuriboh Shark]

We will have a rematch at some point, you are my favourite member to compete agaisnt you know

u 2 r both big legends here. this is practically the ultimate battle u know

 

Did you read it then?

 

no but just looking at it confused me. no offense

[Smesh]

We're really not. You haven't seen the best.

 

Icy vs. Yankee would be the best.

[chedbonlahor]

We're really not. You haven't seen the best.

 

Icy vs. Yankee would be the best.

 

Dont tell them lol

[Smesh]

Oh, Ched, did you give me the rep?

[chedbonlahor]

Alright, it's my turn to vote. I vote for Smesh because of 2 reasons:

 

1. Ched has some OCG errors

2. I think that Ched's card is OP'd because somebody is gonna lose at least 4500 life points, quite possibly more.

 

OMG you have read it incorrectly, the point of the card is that there are two outcomes:

 

1st outcome. Both players lose 3000 LP when the card has 8 spell counters the card is destroyed

2nd outcome. Either player takes 1500 LP when the other player draws 7 cards and the card is destroyed

 

only one of the outocmes can take place because the card is destroyed when one of the outcomes is reached

 

The point of the card is to use the added effects to steer the card into one outcome or the other at the cost of LP or cards themselves

 

Why did you vote if you clearly didnt understand the card itself, I just lost because you didnt read the card.

 

The phrase "somebody is gonna lose at least 4500 lifepoints" is completely incorrect.