Lockage.

[Smesh]

Reserved for Mecha.

 

As soon as he gets here, he gets to pick the card requirements.

 

First to 3 votes wins, winner gets 1 rep. Both of us will be able to give a "Defending Statement" which basically says why our card is not OP'd, why its useful, etc.

 

If votes are not based on good criteria, me and Mecha have the right to disregard your vote.

 

My Card

1 Tuner + 1 Pyro non-Tuner

When this card is Synchro Summoned, place 1 Arrow Counter on this card for each face-up card on the field. When this card is destroyed distribute the Arrow Counters on cards on the field. Cards can only have 1 Arrow Counter on them at a time, besides this card. Cards with Arrow Counters are destroyed in 2 turns, except for "Archer Pyromaniac". If this 4 or more cards are destroyed by this card's effect, Special Summon this monster from your Graveyard in Defence Position.

 

[spoiler=Defending Statement]

The arrow counters must be distributed all over the field, possibly your own. And its likely that not many counters will even be made. In the 2 turns of waiting, you could Tribute the cards, and cause havoc.

 

 

Mecha's Card

[spoiler=Lore]1 Dragon-Type Tuner + 1 "Infernal Flame Emperor"

Every time this card destroys a monster by battle, place 1 Infernal Counter (max. 10) on this card. When this card has 10 Infernal Counters on it, it cannot attack. You can remove all 10 Infernal Counters on this card to inflict damage to your opponent equal to every card in your opponents Graveyard x300.

 

Defense: This card is nowhere near OP'd. First off, you have to destroy 10 monsters before it's effect is even useful. Then, when you destroy 10 monsters, you do 300 damage for every card in your opponents Graveyard, which would mean your opponent would need to have at least 27 cards in their graveyard for it to be a 1 hit win. Sure, you do a minimum of 3000 damage with the cards that this card destroyed, but it'd kinda be a kick to the nuts if you went to the trouble of taking out 10 monsters just to do 900 damage or whatever.

[John A. Zoidberg]

Sweeeet, let's go.

Okay, let's say:

A Fire Pyro-type Synchro that uses counters to burn the opponent. (Yes, unoriginal, but whatever.)

[Smesh]

Ok, pm me your card and defending statement when ready.

[John A. Zoidberg]

Will do.

[Smesh]

START VOTIN.

 

And to make sure you understand, I know i dont have a burn effect. Me and Mecha talked about it.

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

Alright they are both very creative and both of them have OCG errors. However, my vote goes to Smesh only because IMO Mecha Pedobear's is OP'd stat-wise. The stats just seem too high or if it was level 8 then I wouldn't be able to decide, so this was a close judgment.

 

Smesh GMV

[Smesh]

1-0 Smesh.

 

Thanks for voting.

[John A. Zoidberg]

Alright they are both very creative and both of them have OCG errors. However, my vote goes to Smesh only because IMO Mecha Pedobear's is OP'd stat-wise. The stats just seem too high or if it was level 8 then I wouldn't be able to decide, so this was a close judgment.

 

Smesh GMV

 

There's honestly not a huge difference between lv7 and lv8.

Same amount of tributes needed and all that.

But whatever. 1-0 Smesh.

[FTW (For The Wynn)]

There's honestly not a huge difference between lv7 and lv8.

Same amount of tributes needed and all that.

But whatever. 1-0 Smesh.

 

I know but this seems just a wee bit too strong for a level 7. Stardust has that killer effect but is a LV 8 with LV 7 stats because he has such an effect.

[John A. Zoidberg]

True. I mean, the reason I made my card Lv7 is because of the difficulty of using his effect.

[CMRenji]

Mecha Pedobear's card isn't OP'd but it's a little uncreative IMO. Both cards seem balanced to me, the OCG in both seem fine(the distributing part in Smesh's seems a little off though) and overall they are both pretty good cards.

 

But, Smesh GMV since his card seems more creative to me.

[Smesh]

That would be a valid vote IMO.

 

2-0

[Spoon]

Vote goes to Smesh. A unique idea and a really nice usage of Counters for different reasons. Even that last effect fits in very well, an overall well rounded card.

Pedobears card is... while not exactly boring, very far away from being interesting :( Just burn stuff (one or the other way), nothing to get excited about.

[Smesh]

That's 3. Let's see if this can actually be spiritually locked. Good match Mecha :D

[John A. Zoidberg]

Lol, Smesh got a perfect win xD

That's what I get for not making a card for 1+ weeks :P

1 Rep coming up :D

 

Wait, I gave my max for the day. Remind me later.

[hexcalibrate]

sorry i voted, but didn't realise it was over.

[John A. Zoidberg]

quality wise i think the cards equal, but i think ismesh's will be usefuler (not a real word you know what i mean)

 

Contest's already over, bud.

[Smesh]

Lol, Smesh got a perfect win xD

That's what I get for not making a card for 1+ weeks :P

1 Rep coming up :D

 

Wait, I gave my max for the day. Remind me later.

 

Sure :D

 

quality wise i think the cards equal, but i think ismesh's will be usefuler (not a real word but you know what i mean)

 

ITS OVAR