Smesh Vs. Galadrien VOTE

[Smesh]

Yo.

 

-First to post is opponent.

-First to 4 votes wins

-Winner gets 3 reps from loser

 

You pick the requirement(s) because im too lazy to think of one.

 

[spoiler=My Card]

This card can only be activated when a Counter is removed from the field. Place the removed counter on this card. As long as you control this card, whenever a Counter is removed from the field, it is placed on this card. During your Standby Phase, place 2 Sound Counters on this card. When this card has 20 Counters on it, you win the Duel.

 

 

[spoiler=Opponent's Card]

Lore:

When a level 4 or lower non-Plant-Type monster your opponent controls declares an attack or activates its effect, you can Tribute 1 Plant-Type monster you control to negate the attack or effect and destroy the monster. Place the destroyed monster as a Nutrition Counter on this card (max. 3). During your Standby Phase, you can remove this card from play to increase the ATK and DEF of all Plant-Type monsters you control by 600 x the number of Nutrition Counters on this card until the End Phase, the attack of Plant-Type monsters the turn you activated this effect cannot be negated.

 

 

[Phantom M.C.]

me!!! a continuous trap

[Guest +Kokonoe]

Reserved~

 

Requirements:

 

Level 10 ROCK monster with 3500 DEF or more which specializes in supporting the Flip Sphinxes.

 

EDIT: Nevermind. =/

[Smesh]

Meh. Smesh don't like traps. But fine.

 

@+Kokonoe: maybe next time :D

[Phantom M.C.]

[spoiler=my card]

Lore:

When a level 4 or lower non-Plant-Type monster your opponent controls declares an attack or activates its effect, you can Tribute 1 Plant-Type monster you control to negate the attack or effect and destroy the monster. Place the destroyed monster as a Nutrition Counter on this card (max. 3). During your Standby Phase, you can remove this card from play to increase the ATK and DEF of all Plant-Type monsters you control by 600 x the number of Nutrition Counters on this card until the End Phase, the attack of Plant-Type monsters the turn you activated this effect cannot be negated.

 

 

yeah, its only meant for plant decks, so don't go "smesh gmv cause galadrien's only works in plant decks"

[Smesh]

Not my best. Well, time for Galadrien to win..

[Guest .:Overdrive:.]

...Vote for Smesh. Why ? His card has better OCG and it's more useful. It can help a lot arch'types involving Counters. Also, Galadrien's card is a bit OP'd...

[Smesh]

Teh score beh 1-0 Smeshy

 

God, do i love talking like that

[Phantom M.C.]

...Vote for Smesh. Why ? His card has better OCG and it's more useful. It can help a lot arch'types involving Counters. Also, Galadrien's card is a bit OP'd...

 

i will never understand the thinking of newbs :P <_<

[Smesh]

Dont get all high and mighty. Its just one vote.

[Phantom M.C.]

lol, i'm not.....only at the "more useful in lots of archetypes" aka "galadrien's is limited to only plant decks" -.- oh well, end of discussion for me

[poopybuttoxes]

Smesh's card has that first bit of stuff thats pointless EDIT: not pointless haha, but its a free final countdown except the opponent can destroy it. Which makes it a pretty interesting card. That one card that doesnt let continuous traps be destroy would make this card really really good, and you could use it in a deck with a bunch of counters which would probably OP the card.

 

Galadriens card would be good for plants. It would be staple for plants actually, but the part about "Place the destroyed monster as a Nutrition Counter on this card (max. 3)". How do you "place the monster on the card"? Is the monster like equipped to the trap? because it would keep the monster out of the grave. That would be cool. If thats the case then i really cant vote, cause they are both really cool effect wise.

 

Can i vote for both? haha If not sorry for wasting your time.

[Smesh]

D: you gatta vote fo one

 

I need to stop talking like that.

[poopybuttoxes]

Well i wanted to vote for yours, but then i thought of how horrible playing against a deck built around it would be.

 

Guess i'll vote for Galadrien. I mean that card is balanced and can stop anything. Sorry bro. Your card is good though.

[Smesh]

1-1

 

This card started a rant in the RC.

 

I own a rant :'D

 

EDIT: 3000 posts bishes

[Phantom M.C.]

offtopic: congratz smesh

[Spoon]

Vote goes tooo... Smesh.

 

I always appreciate alternate ways to win duels, and this one is unique and well executed. Galadrien's card is nice and colorful (read: Has the better picture in my opinion), the effect is great... but it just doesn't win duels ;)

[Smesh]

2-1

[Smesh]

Bump

[♫♪GoldenBoy♪♫]

I'll rate the two cards and if you wish to ask about the rating PM me. The person with the highest rate got my vote.

[spoiler=iSmesh!'s Rate]

OCG = 10/10

Picture 9/10

Effect Balance/Usability 9/10 (Still an Insta-Win)

Card Flow 10/10

Creativity 10/10

Total 48/50 or 9.6/10

 

[spoiler=Gala's Rate]

OCG 10/10

Picture 10/10

Effect Balance/Usability 8/10

Card Flow 9/10

Creativity 10/10

Total 47/50 or 9.4/10

 

[Smesh]

It be 3-1 Smesh

[Phantom M.C.]

BUMP?

[Smesh]

vote please.

[Smesh]

Yo, people, you can vote now.

[Smesh]

...VOTE