Jump to content

Smesh Vs. Chedbonlahor VOTE NOW


Smesh

Recommended Posts

Yo, anyone can challenge me.

 

Requirement: Most CREATIVE card you can make. Made up OCG is fine, if someone says "derp the OCG is weird" I'll deny it, unless you have OCG errors.

 

Prize: 3 reps.

Votes needed: 3

 

First to POST is my opponent

 

[spoiler=My card]

221030fa.jpg

Once per turn, you can change this card's Type. During your Battle Phase, this card must attack all monsters your opponent controls of the same Type as this card. During your opponent's End Phase, declare 1 Type. During your Draw Phase, if the card you draw is a monster of the declared Type, equip it to this card. This card is also treated as the Type of monsters equipped to it. Once per turn, you can pay 500 Life Points to destroy 1 Monster Card equipped to this card. If you activate this effect, destroy 1 monster of the same Type as the destroyed monster on the field.

 

[spoiler=Opponent's Card]

217615t.jpg

 

LORE:As long as this card remains face-up on the field, all Spell Cards on either player's side of the field, or in either player's hand or Deck are treated as Trap Cards and can be used as Trap Cards. Whenever a Trap Card is activated, the owner of the Trap Card must pay 200 Life Points.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here's my card:

 

217615t.jpg

 

LORE:As long as this card remains face-up on the field, all Spell Cards on either player's side of the field, or in either player's hand or Deck are treated as Trap Cards and can be used as Trap Cards. Whenever a Trap Card is activated, the owner of the Trap Card must pay 200 Life Points.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You don't need to bump this once an hour :blink:

 

Anyways:

 

Smesh's card has a highly complicated, but unique effect... always a good thing in my opinion. The picture is dark and scary, good choice, the name fits.

 

Ched's card has a nice idea, the picture looks cool but... I don't know, I think you didn't think far enough. Of course, rules are there to be broken, but only paying 200 Life Points to use each and every Spell Card in your opponents turn... could break the game. I'm usually not the one to say this, because I like to break rules myself, and this card does it very well...

 

Gnah, point goes to Smesh, because it's the more well-rounded card with dimensions I can currently see. I'd give out a prize to ched for breaking the rules though ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Winner: Smesh

 

Pic: Chedbonlahor - I like both pics, but I like Ched's just a bit more.

 

OCG: Smesh - I could see this going either way, but I gave it to Smesh due to his long effect.

 

Originality: Chedbonlahor - Effect hasn't really ever been done that I can think of.

 

Creativity: Smesh - For another creatively long and balanced effect. P

 

Playability: Smesh - They are both very playable, but I think in the long run Smesh's would be more useful.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Smesh Chedbonlahor

Pic: X

 

OCG: X

 

Originality: X

 

Creativity: X

 

Playability: X

 

Winner: Smesh

 

Reasoning: I like both pics, but I like Ched's just a bit more. As for OCG, I could see this going either way, but I gave it to Smesh due to his long effect. As for originality, I gave it to Ched because his effect hasn't really ever been done. Creativity goes to Smesh for another creatively long and balanced effect. Finally, for playability, they are both very playable, but I think in the long run Smesh's would be more useful.

 

So effectively you gave smesh the win because both our OCG was perfect the effects were both original and creative, but because his effect was LONGER, cheerz...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"This is what he said: "Creativity goes to Smesh for another creatively long and balanced effect" what he really means is, they are both so good, i'm going to give it to smesh who has a LONGER effect."

 

Learn to bold the relevant information.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...