Mahandra vs Sirbobert !! Aprreciated Votes

[MibeR]

[align=center]Synchro MOnster warrior Type, level 5.

 

All rules apply

 

3 votes to win

 

3 reps to winner, and 1 to loser

 

first to response[/align]

 

[align=center]=MINE=

[/align]

 

"Tune Warrior" + 1 or more non-Tuner Warrior-Type monsters

When this card is Synchro Summoned, remove from play all Synchro Material Monsters used for Synchro Summon this card to reduce this card's ATK equal to half of the combined ATK of all removed from play monsters. Whenever this card's ATK become 500 or less, one time only, you can destroy cards on the field up to the number of cards in your hand. This card cannot be destroyed by battle if this card's ATK is 500 or less (Damage Calculation is applied normally).

 

[align=center]=Sirbobert's=

[/align]

 

1 Warrior-type tuner+1 or more non-tuner monsters

This card is also EARTH, WATER, FIRE, and WIND attributes. Once per turn, select 1 card on the field, and remove it from play. This effect cannot be negated.

[sirAragorn]

I'll go against u...... it'll be my first 1 0n 1

[.:Blu:.]

I'll challenge you!

 

[spoiler=Strikeforce Samurai]

 

1 "Strikeforce" Tuner + 1 or more Warrior-Type non-Tuner Monsters

On the turn this card is successfully Synchro Summoned, increase this card's ATK by 300 for every "Strikeforce" monster you control. Once per turn, you can tribute a "Strikeforce" monster you control to decrease the ATK of a monster your opponent controls equal to the tributed card's ATK. When this card battles a Warrior-Type monster your opponent controls, increase the ATK of this card by 500 until the end of the Battle Phase.

 

[MibeR]

sorry blu dawn, sirbobert first

[sirAragorn]

OH! um, i haven't seen anything new, so i haven't posted, but here I GO!!!!!

 

 

 

 

1 Warrior-type tuner+1 or more non-tuner monsters

This card is also EARTH, WATER, FIRE, and WIND attributes. Once per turn, select 1 card on the field, and remove it from play. This effect cannot be negated.

 

[MibeR]

now votes please

[sirAragorn]

NO ONE IS VOTING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.......Bump.

[Cows198]

mahandra, while an interesting effect, it is extremely really hard to pull off. only two monsters that can naturally tune with tune warrior can decrease your card's attack below 500 (D hero departed and iron chain blaster) You also have a few ocg errors. Props for the creative effect though.

 

sirbobbert, your card on the other hand is really easy to summon. it is also rather op, having really high stats and a ridiculously deadly effect. you also have a few ocg errors. effect isnt really original

 

In the end, i would have to give the vote to the more creative card mahandra's, though both cards have major balance issues.

[MibeR]

1-0 to me, thanks for the vote..

 

moar votes

[MibeR]

1-0 to me, thanks for the vote..

 

moar votes

[MibeR]

1-0 to me, thanks for the vote..

 

moar votes

[sirAragorn]

Um............... Bump.

[MibeR]

i post 3 times, i dont realize that

[sirAragorn]

This is taking a loooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooong time............................................. bump.

[Mr Hobo]

-_- the point of this forum and me posting this message is?

[Mr Hobo]

BOREDOM! :()

[hexcalibrate]

vote mahandra it's too powerful for a five star

[MibeR]

2-0 to me

[poopybuttoxes]

I vote for sirboberts

 

Both are poor exuses for cards. Expecially for contest cards. The OCG was really bad on the first one and i didnt even fully understand it at first. Which is really really bad. I always liked the all attribute effect monsters, and even though the card is kinda OPed ima vote for Vest.

[MibeR]

can you show where's the errors?if not. i wont count the vote cz really my card has a good ocg

[poopybuttoxes]

Let me point something out first, cause i just loled really card at what you just said.

 

When this card is Synchro Summoned, remove from play all Synchro Material Monsters used for Synchro Summon this card to reduce this card's ATK equal to half of the combined ATK of all removed from play monsters.

That doesnt even make sense OCG aside.

 

I know its kinda harsh to blow up one word, but it threw me off alot.

[Flash Flyer - Sakura]

mahandra's card gets my vote for better OCG, creativity and balance.

sirbobert's card is very easy to summon, has extremely powerful stats for LV5 and the effect is OPed (with the non-negation effect)

[sirAragorn]

Okay............................... I lost. I don't think there is way to give reps at the moment.......so................ CONGRATS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[jhjjhj]

i vote for sub zero hero but they are both good cards